The "What If" Thread - A Place for Crazy Speculation & Wild Theories!

The "What If" Thread - A Place for Crazy Speculation & Wild Theories!

  1. FinalArcadia
    FinalArcadia
    Ah, this should get interesting...*I hope*

    This is the place for us to come up with bizarre or just intriguing theories about Reggie. Anything goes, folks! Let's keep this going for awhile, because I think we can come up with some pretty great stuff...

    I'll start with something one of my sisters told me: What if, through some strange (possibly Celebi-related) time paradox, Reggie is Ash's dad? They ARE similar, after all
  2. Madame Pika
    Madame Pika
    No way, Reiji is Jindai's dad. Only they have no way of knowing. Jindai is still Shinji and Reiji's dad, BTW. I could add to this but... oh flip it, Shinji is the mother.

    Everyone is Satoshi's dad, especually Satoshi... and Nyasu. There's actually very little Reiji in Satoshi thanks to the sheer power of his cotd no 183679.7 DNA.

    [/overfocus on the word crazy in the title] Sorry, I couldn't resist. Feel free to get revenge.

    Actually I love the idea of Satoshi's father being someone in Serebii paradox. It would explain why the guy never appears. He had to go back to his own time. I can't see Reiji abbandoning Satoshi's mum like that though.

    What if Reiji were female? What would Shinji call her instead of 'Aniki'? Would Shinji be harsher on a Rei/Reiko? The only thing I'm sure of it that there'd be even more people saying that the writers are referencing Evagenlion.
  3. FinalArcadia
    FinalArcadia
    Quote Originally Posted by Madame Pika
    No way, Reiji is Jindai's dad. Only they have no way of knowing. Jindai is still Shinji and Reiji's dad, BTW. I could add to this but... oh flip it, Shinji is the mother.
    So Reggie and Paul had a child together...who then became their own father? Oh god, I'm LOVING THIS!!! I feel like this must be expressed in fan comic form, it's so epic/bizarre/disturbing! I'm leaning towards "epic", lol.

    This is the kind of crazy I love! XD

    If Reggie was Paul's sister, first of all, I could see him being super fanservice-y. A strange thing to imagine, but true. Secondly, I could see Paul struggling to hide feelings for her (him? her? You know what I mean). Like some kind of complex.

    Alrighty, I don't think I can top those, but what if Reggie secretly (okay, this is really weird, bear with me here) killed his mom? And he killed her to take her place, because he was jealous of the attention she got from Paul? Might be interesting...
  4. Madame Pika
    Madame Pika
    Quote Originally Posted by FinalArcadia
    So Reggie and Paul had a child together...who then became their own father?
    Well... that was one way of reading that...

    If Reggie was Paul's sister, first of all, I could see him being super fanservice-y. A strange thing to imagine, but true. Secondly, I could see Paul struggling to hide feelings for her (him? her? You know what I mean). Like some kind of complex.
    So pretty much like the current sitsation then.

    Alrighty, I don't think I can top those, but what if Reggie secretly (okay, this is really weird, bear with me here) killed his mom? And he killed her to take her place, because he was jealous of the attention she got from Paul? Might be interesting...
    Part of me can see that... but then I always liked the idea of yandere Reiji anyway... I'll see what the others say first.

    Throwing out another idea. What if it turned out that Reiji was a quietly mastering the strings so that his brother would come out a more powerful trainer? That his sole reason for teaching Satoshi bravebird was to give Shinji a strong rival. [/headcannon] Or even that he deliberately lost to Jindai and became a breeder just to drive Shinji on.
  5. FinalArcadia
    FinalArcadia
    Quote Originally Posted by Madame Pika
    What if it turned out that Reiji was a quietly mastering the strings so that his brother would come out a more powerful trainer? That his sole reason for teaching Satoshi bravebird was to give Shinji a strong rival. [/headcannon] Or even that he deliberately lost to Jindai and became a breeder just to drive Shinji on.
    You know, that makes a lot of sense... Although deliberately losing to Brandon seems like a big gamble. Then again, people do crazy things for the ones they love. That would be so sweet...XD

    Also, I had to LOL about things being the same if Reggie was Paul's sister. You're right, there's no difference. :D
Results 1 to 5 of 5
Bookmarks