Post your favorite Creepypasta story here. Mine would probably be Lost Silver.
Lost Silver was just a bunch of random stuff that didn't add up. Pokémon Channel was cool though.
The one that freaked me out most was probably Jeff the Killer,
as for my "favorite", it would have to be either:
a joke one i found about pacman,or Hypno's Lullaby,
Jeff the killer! I don't know why, it stood out. Hated the supposed sequel, though.
Lavender Town,Ben, Jeff the killer,Squidward's Suicide
Oh, yeah, Squidward's Suicide was the only one that really creeped me out. Also, the pictures and fanart that go with Cupcakes can be sort of memorable.
One of my favorite ones I found a little while ago is called "The Angelica Theory". Remember that old-ish cartoon "Rugrats"? Well, that's what the theory is about.
Lost Silver, BEN drowned, Smile.dog and Jeff the Killer are my faves. BEN drowned and Smile.dog are the only ones that have made me have trouble going to sleep, and BEN drowned was only because I read it on my 3DS, in my bedroom, at night, in utter silence. And I couldn't go to sleep for ages after.
Lavender Town syndrome ftw.
Definitely BEN. Not sure if it counts but Marble Hornets was very good too.