Thread: Yu-Gi-Oh! GX Mafia (Endgame! Mafia and Ryoga Kamishiro win!)

FoS: FinalArcadia

...

Vote: Dark Blueberry

^Vote subject to change, FoS likely permanent.

Originally Posted by Master Mew

FoS: FinalArcadia

...

Vote: Dark Blueberry

^Vote subject to change, FoS likely permanent.

Why are you FoSing FA?

She knows.

Originally Posted by Master Mew

She knows.

Mind sharing with the rest of us

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Originally Posted by Master Mew

She knows.

Mind sharing with the rest of us

Waiting to see what @FinalArcadia says it was, first. And yes, there is a real reason - not just fishing (some of that, too, of course).

Originally Posted by Master Mew

She knows.

I'm honestly not trying to play dumb here when I say that I don't know.

Is it something to do with my semi-ish defense of Buoy? Even then, I still can't figure out what you're referring to.

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

I'd say this was a framing attempt of some sort, but on the contrary, I feel like one of those Buoy questioned could really be mafia. Both of them have been behaving a bit oddly, but I'll wait until a little later in the phase to decide which one to act on.

FoS: Midorikawa and Dark Blueberry

Personally, I'm leaning toward Midorikawa, partly because I saw her behavior after the previous night's update as something perhaps meant to distract town, by focusing so much on the flavor text when it's very likely that the order of the deaths was just to create a more coherent plot for the update.

^It's in there.

Long story short, the first person to draw attention to the Nightkill WIFOM is the most likely to be trying to manipulate it.

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

I'd say this was a framing attempt of some sort, but on the contrary, I feel like one of those Buoy questioned could really be mafia. Both of them have been behaving a bit oddly, but I'll wait until a little later in the phase to decide which one to act on.

FoS: Midorikawa and Dark Blueberry

Personally, I'm leaning toward Midorikawa, partly because I saw her behavior after the previous night's update as something perhaps meant to distract town, by focusing so much on the flavor text when it's very likely that the order of the deaths was just to create a more coherent plot for the update.

^It's in there.

Long story short, the first person to draw attention to the Nightkill WIFOM is the most likely to be trying to manipulate it.

Oh wow, I was way off in my guess. ^^;

I don't have much to say in regards to that, other than I honestly was thinking that mafia might be banking on some WIFOM to clear one of those who were in Buoy's suspicions, like a "it's such an obvious frame that they can't be mafia" type thing and I thought it was a good way to lead into my suspicions of Midorikawa and Dark Blueberry.

Guys, I know I've been acting fishy for most of the posts. I misunderstood some points, and I had no idea Buoy would die when I wanted a cop check on him.

I know this is extremely risky, but as I don't want anyone to get accused for defending me, I'll say it in the open:

I'm the doctor - and yes, I'm THE doctor who claimed to Human. So I would please like it if you took your votes off me.

Oh and yeah - I have an additional ability along with being a doctor and it could come in handy if anyone wants my help.


EDIT: @Master Mew; @jokool; @Midorikawa;

^ Believable. I get scumreads on Doctors all the time.

Not saying I believe it, but it's believable.

@Master Mew;

Nobody counterclaimed doctor when Human said I claimed to him. And if a doctor claim is scummy, then what do you exactly have to claim in-thread to be called town?

EDIT: Of course, everything is scummy to you :P

I don't get why I would be silenced out of all the players ._.

Damn, the Mafia must have been very lucky to get DD to do the kill.

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Personally, I'm leaning toward Midorikawa, partly because I saw her behavior after the previous night's update as something perhaps meant to distract town, by focusing so much on the flavor text when it's very likely that the order of the deaths was just to create a more coherent plot for the update.

It's possible, but I'm not seeing it.

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

VOTE: Dark Blueberry I've been planning on voting you since the night phase. I brought up flavor text because it can easily contain hints, but you keep brushing them off as nothing more than useless text, and then when I brought up Hassleberry's death (Gliscorman) you say he was attacked by a monster at night. No one but the one who attacked him, and the host should know that, and maybe him, though I'm not sure on the details.

well then why would the text be like

anything useful?

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Long story short, the first person to draw attention to the Nightkill WIFOM is the most likely to be trying to manipulate it.

oh what great logic this is

surely the mafia wouldn't have been careful, shut their mouths and slipped in the kill

i think my waifu would have been smarter than that

Originally Posted by Master Mew

^ Believable. I get scumreads on Doctors all the time.

Not saying I believe it, but it's believable.

._.

well why not wise one

Anyway, I believe that Dark Blueberry is Professor Akuyawa, the nurse of Duel Academy. I'm thinking that DB's additional ability is to heal Life Points or something.

So what would those who voted Dark Blueberry unvote her now? Lets hope the Mafia doesn't have a Roleblocker/Strongman.

Originally Posted by Human

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Long story short, the first person to draw attention to the Nightkill WIFOM is the most likely to be trying to manipulate it.

oh what great logic this is

surely the mafia wouldn't have been careful, shut their mouths and slipped in the kill

i think my waifu would have been smarter than that

"Surely they're smarter than that," is a wifom-defense, I could easily retort, "But surely they would know that we would think they're smarter than that," but what would be the point? It's endless.

Originally Posted by Master Mew

^ Believable. I get scumreads on Doctors all the time.

Not saying I believe it, but it's believable.

._.

well why not wise one

Because the Doctor would not counterclaim publicly, and since you aren't cleared (you were silenced by a claimed Town-silencer, assuming their claim is even true), the Doctor would not risk privately claiming to you, either. Frankly, I'm puzzled by the fact that DB claimed to you so quickly.

As for your tone ("what great logic," "oh wise one"), condescension will not help you prove your case.

Originally Posted by Master Mew

"Surely they're smarter than that," is a wifom-defense, I could easily retort, "But surely they would know that we would think they're smarter than that," but what would be the point? It's endless.

It's basic. It isn't endless.

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Because the Doctor would not counterclaim publicly, and since you aren't cleared (you were silenced by a claimed Town-silencer, assuming their claim is even true), the Doctor would not risk privately claiming to you, either. Frankly, I'm puzzled by the fact that DB claimed to you so quickly.

They could counterclaim to me privately. If you ask anybody who watched the show here, they'd know I'm innocent. 2500 ATT and 2000 DEF Monster... WHO COULD THAT BE? @FinalArcadia; @Ryoga Kamishiro;.

oh i dunno why she claimed to me

maybe because anyone who watched ONE SECOND OF the show knows there is no way i'm mafia?

Originally Posted by Master Mew

As for your tone ("what great logic," "oh wise one"), condescension will not help you prove your case.

it wasn't meant to ;_;

Master Mew, I'm seeing the case of a Mafia here trying to sink in a lynch on the doctor.

"GUYS LETS LYNCH THE PERSON WHO CLAIMED DOCTOR AND HASN'T BEEN COUNTER CLAIMED! IT'S SUCH A GREAT IDEA RIGHT?"

That's scum. I mean, if you want to risk lynching Dark Blueberry and getting the doctor, and then go into WIFOM MODE about how wrong you were, then go ahead. Go risk lynching the doctor. Then we definitely won't start asking questions. I mean, it's totally worth it. In the meantime, I'll try getting the lynch off to somebody else. Yeah, the lynch redirector claimed to me :).

i wonder who we should redirect it to....

HMMMMM

@Master Mew;

Oh fine then. Let's wait till there's someone who counterclaims in private.

The typical statement of "doctor's don't usually claim in public" isn't the logic here. You're relying on past popular methods, but hey, if I didn't claim to be doc in the open, tell me what I should've done to get the votes off me. Claim in private? Wut, should I send PMs to every single person here? People are going to assume I sent PMs to everybody pleading to not vote for me. Then what makes that different from claiming in the open?

Tell me, what would YOU have done if you were in my shoes? Let's learn something here.