Thread: Yu-Gi-Oh! All-Stars Mafia ~ ENDGAME (Town and Independents Win!) ~

Oh, Greece... FinalArcadia would never put a female character in a game featuring her favorites. XD

Just making sure :l

Originally Posted by GliscorMan

Incredible game, I must say. Brilliant job, guys! An Arclight won, that's good enough for me.

Oh and now that the game's over. I wanna know what gave it away to you @Human; about the PMs I sent.

I'll have you know I worked my V off making those.

The black line not showing was what made me think of it as fake ^^;

By the way, why did you tell me that Laterose was an Independent? Why not Town?

I'm surprised that the cop made it to endgame!

Anyway, thanks for hosting, I had fun with this one~

is it wrong that this mafia made me want to make a mafia about my favorite video game characters?

Thanks for letting me play FA. It was a good learning experience for me and an okay first step I guess. Woo, go town.~

RATINGS!

Please don't take these too seriously, as I'm definitely no expert. But here they are, without further ado!

@jokool

1.5/5

It’s hard to rate the first player to die, but you did show enthusiasm, which I appreciate. However, being so quick to change your vote on Rio led to your premature demise, as did your ill-thought out fake claim. Losing the godfather so early on was a major blow to the mafia, and one they never were able to recover from. Things might have worked out better if you planned out your actions a bit more.

@Buoy

4/5

Despite dying early, you were spot-on with many of your suspicions, and were seen as a major threat by the mafia. You utilized your 1x bulletproof ability well by being active in-thread, and if the strongman hadn’t killed you, you definitely would’ve been a town leader.

@KidBeano

3/5

Your strongman kill helped take down a dangerous townie, and you were active in the mafia QT, with some good ideas. On the other hand, though, your playstyle was noticeably different than usual for you, which led to the suspicion placed upon you early. Your fake claim could have been a good idea, but in that case, a lack of knowledge of the anime hurt you when claiming Visitor (which I can’t really fault you for; though your later claim of Traitor was much better), as did losing your cool when your life was on the line.

@Poyo

3/5

This was the first time that I’d seen you around in mafia games here, and it’s nice to see new faces. Even when votes were cast against you on Day 1, you held your ground, and I felt that you handled being under suspicion pretty well. It’s a shame you didn’t last long enough to use your ability, but while you were alive, you seemed to be a relatively active team player.

@Rio Kamishiro

3/5

Well, you are tenacious, I don’t think anybody can deny that. But your reckless nature seems to get you into trouble, which you were unable to escape from this game. You were a bit too obvious with some buddying with jokool (which I estimate was at least 50% the result of him being Kaito), but your vote lock did save you guys from losing a mafioso for one extra phase. I think that you might benefit from a bit more caution, particularly on Day 1.

@Akuraito

3.5/5

The doctor is a difficult role to have, but you seemed to do a good job on your own initially, protecting yourself and Buoy (which ended up not mattering, but still), and later you began to work with your alliance to coordinate night actions. Unfortunately for you, a traitor was in your midst, allowing for you to easily be night-killed. Still, you laid low well, which is a good plan for the doctor, and you were willing to speak up when discussion was on-going.

@GliscorMan

3.5/5

There was a period of time that I thought you might be able to squeak by, but alas, town caught on to you. Your gambit of claiming cop was surprisingly effective for a little while, and I was amused at how Sputnik’s negation ability actually inadvertently aided your claim. With such a claim, though, the end was imminent; still, claiming to have checked Laterose as town rather than independent might’ve helped. In the time before that, though, you were a good contributor in the mafia QT.

@DrumBeats

2.5/5

Initially, you were not a very active member. During Night 5, however, you actually had the potential to completely alter the game in a way that likely would have meant town’s victory much sooner. You chose a good target to receive your flashback, and if you had not been roleblocked, your flashback would have revealed the identity of the mafia silencer much quicker. Things did not work out, but it was a nice plan in theory.

@Soulmaster

2.5/5

You didn’t get to stick around long after subbing in, but your entrance was perfect timing for the mafia to finally utilize the roleblocker ability. In roleblocking DrumBeats ,you essentially prolonged the game, and would end up allowing the last mafioso (Elysion) to survive longer. You weren’t particularly active in-thread, but being that you joined late and there were so many pages to read through, I’m able to ignore that to a degree.

@AlphaMouse

1/5

Another new face, which I was happy to see. After the early phases, though, you kind of disappeared, which would end up being the reason for your death. Your ability of being a double voter could’ve been useful, yet it was never really utilized.

@Stuntology

5/5

You were a great force behind the scenes, making fantastic use of your ability as a watcher. It was through this that you were able to get in touch with the doctor. In addition, you were a very active player, especially behind the scenes, so I was glad that you subbed in. You began the big QT alliance that town had, which worked out pretty well until the mafioso within started to take action, but your initiative was very impressive.

@Sputnik

3.5/5

The first winner of the game! You fulfilled your win condition, but I found your play style a bit dangerous. To me anyway, you came across as a bit scummy, but that might’ve worked in your favor, so that mafia would never use a kill on you. Either way though, things worked out for you, and I must admit, you were amusing to watch, even if I was baffled by some of your moves.

@Neon Borealis

1/5

Being able to commute certainly insured that you would survive longer than you had in other recent games, but it came at the cost of not assisting the town in scumhunting. Being a commuter – an ability that mafia likes to claim – you probably would have benefit from claiming to a safe bet townie (such as Human) before randomly deciding to claim in-thread on the first night you commuted.

@Laterose

4/5

I’m glad you seemed to have developed in interest in the series now! Once you became a part of the Destiny Alliance, you a good contributor in the QT. In addition, you utilized your role very well, taking the Akuraito’s doctor ability and making sure to send in a night action from that point on. Though not extremely active in-thread, you made up for that behind the scenes, leading to a solid performance.

@Elysion

5/5

The lone mafioso for the latter portion of the game. For a first timer in mafia, I was incredibly impressed with your game, the way you garnered town’s trust for so long. You did a great job appearing town, and your fake screenshot early on was well put together. However, a large part of your downfall was the false nameclaim. Honestly, if you had claimed Dartz as a JOAT, you probably would’ve had more of a chance of passing under town radar. But still, a fantastic performance overall.

@Light Bringer

1.5/5

I imagine that with the massive page count in the game, it was difficult for subs to jump in. I would’ve liked to have seen more activity from you (both in-thread and out) and a usage of your ability, but I do appreciate that you let me know that you may not be able to be active in the game. So it’s all good. Plus, your ability to change a person’s vote could be tricky to use properly, so it is understandable why it wasn’t used.

@Greece

4/5

After the vigilante powers went unused in my previous mafia, I was glad to see you make use of them. The first instance on KidBeano was a great boost for town, and allowed you better access as an independent into their discussions. Though AlphaMouse was not mafia, your kill on him might have helped fill in some missing pieces to the “final mafia question,” and besides, risks are necessary. Your enthusiasm was also appreciated, though you might’ve been a bit quick to trust people, such as with Rio Kamishiro.

@Dark Blueberry

4.5/5

Early on, I didn’t completely get what you were trying to do, but your reports I always enjoyed reading over. You did well in finally winning over the support of the town, and though your ability couldn’t really be used much to aid in rooting out mafia, you made up for that by being a very active player in discussions, in and out of thread. My one suggestion would be that you were pretty obvious in hinting that you were the reporter, which for other roles could’ve been dangerous, but luckily it all worked out in the end here.

@Baron Dante

4/5

One of the few times I’ve actually seen the cop survive and win the game. Your copchecks were obviously very useful, particularly toward the end of the game in recruiting more members to the alliance. A little more activity in-thread would be nice, but the amount in the QTs and PMs made up for that, and you were good at not being too quick to trust others. I must admit though, I was amused when you forgot to send in a check for Night 2.

@DefinitelyNotAGirl

2/5

It’s nice to see you around in this section of the forum! Hopefully, being a part of the winning faction this game (and in Best Wishes!) will encourage you to speak up more in future mafia games. That you did discuss the game outside of thread was good, though. Your ability could’ve given you the leeway to make some risky moves, though, so it would’ve been interesting to see you take some risks.

@Midorikawa

4.5/5

You know, your Gauche avatar fit you quite well when you had it, in my opinion. XD But anyway, being one of the most active players was very much appreciated by me, and whenever you were approached for an alliance and/or information, you were good at making sure to not give too much away or trust too easily. In addition, your lynch redirect was saved for the perfect moment to eliminate Soulmaster, you definitely put a lot of effort into scumhunting.

@Ryoga Kamishiro

3/5

The “identify” ability could’ve hardly fallen into better hands, considering that it required knowledge of the series, and your early check on Elysion wound up being useful. Still, I think you could’ve been a bit more active in-thread, and perhaps a bit more willing to work with some of the townies who were pretty much cleared. Although your reluctance was good for not falling into tricks, some alliances would probably have made things easier on you and possibly town in general, since you were under suspicion to an extent.

@Joltik

3/5

You’ve got the distinction of being the only person to win in both of my games, so congrats! You were a bit quiet until the later part of the game, though, and the one time you used your ability, it impeded town a little. But you did play a part towards the end on to victory, especially after your claim was validated after Soulmaster’s death.

@Master Mew

4.5/5

How dare you try to lynch me, LOL? XD But in all seriousness, you were a very analytical player with a lot of skill to bring to the town. Using the lie detector ability to make certain of Rio Kamishiro’s alignment helped keep the string of mafia lynches going, and additionally, I found the way you brought attention to your being silenced through seemingly random VMs quite ingenious. Though your suspicions on DNAG were not correct, you played a great game.

@Human

5/5

My dear hubby, you certainly kept me entertained throughout this whole game, and lived up to your role as Tron! <3 Pretty early on, you established yourself as a force to be reckoned with, and once you found somebody suspicious, your logicombat was hard to beat (as well as fun to watch). The level of activity you maintained throughout the game was fantastic and definitely helped keep the game as a whole very exciting. And it was almost scary how accurate you were with your guesses on things. And most importantly, you brought glory to Tron, LOL. I found how... willing you were to allow your restless spirit ability to activate quite amusing, though it never came to be. XD

Originally Posted by FA

Well, you are tenacious, I don’t think anybody can deny that.

Aw shucks, thanks~

Hm, you tell me I'm reckless a lot. Guess I better work on that... XD Thanks for the rating!

Um... FinalArcadia, I knew if I acted just the right way, neither the town nor mafia would want me dead. XD

Thanks for the rating FA! Definitely that false nameclaim that mostly brought me down in the end...XD But still, like I said before, this was a wonderful learning experience! So yeah, it was great! XD

Oh right - I forgot to say this earlier, but I really enjoyed your flavortext - it was really well written and pretty depressing at some parts. X3

Thanks for the rating, Arcadia~ I'm surprised I got that much to be honest, since I knew my distrusting thing would bring it down. But yay, about the role part.

Originally Posted by Sputnik

Um... FinalArcadia, I knew if I acted just the right way, neither the town nor mafia would want me dead. XD

That's why I said I'm no expert, LOL.

I've never been an independent, I don't know how it works, okay? XD

I really loved this game. I enjoyed my role to da max and it let me develop interest in the series (all due to Fubuki XDD) I am so 10-joining as a fan!!

The reporter role was quite difficult to use cuz while I could write whatever I wanted, it was hard to get people to notice it without me pointing it out XDD I guess I should thank @Rio Kamishiro; for the epic poem I posted for you - it brought up some discussions XDD

Thanks for the rating. I've never done this well in a game on judging who is mafia but I got two right so I'm good.

Sorry, FinalArcadia. I had forgotten that you have never been independent.