Thread: Witchhunt -- GAME OVER: MAFIA WIN 12/15/12

I have an announcement to make on Human's behalf: He is now known as HumanDawn.

Please announce all name changes in-thread.

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

Since nobody was lynched in the 3rd Day Phase, I'm thinking that it was the executioner's doing of killing Elysion and that the Mafia decided to kill Rio Kamishiro.

This seems like a legitimate theory. I'm just wondering what was the Executioner's reasoning for killing Elysion, then. Because he had to have a reason or (I hope) he wouldn't have arbitrarily killed someone unless Ely came across as scummy somehow.

This no-reveal thing makes it incredibly difficult to figure out who is dead/alive. :/ All we know for sure is that the werewolf is still alive...

And that the doctor is most likely dead, right?

Originally Posted by Neon Borealis

If Kidbeano is mafia, then He had made a wild guess based on Mijs claim and killed Rio in order to appear innocent.

What do you mean by wild guess? I'm not sure what you're saying.

Originally Posted by Paperhorse

Originally Posted by Neon Borealis

If Kidbeano is mafia, then He had made a wild guess based on Mijs claim and killed Rio in order to appear innocent.

What do you mean by wild guess? I'm not sure what you're saying.

What I meant was that if Kid Beano were mafia (Which is unlikely), and he fakeclaimed that role, then he would need an alibi.

Now, Mijzel had claimed Bulletproof, That gave him one potential townie to work with. Now he only needed another one, so he made a wild guess and choose someone that wasn't part of his faction.

Of course, all this is hipotethical.

BTW: @Phoenicks; @Light Bringer; I'm going to be attending a wedding tomorrow and will be out all the day. As a result, I won't be able to post in here, or the forums in general. Just a heads up.

Vote: Akuraito

For a pile of if-thens that I don't feel like explaining at the moment - basically for being the first person, after Rio, to jump ship on the Mijz-wagon right after he claimed Bulletproof and vote for Kyouhei! instead.

Well, we don't have anything else to go with, and that does sound like a good enough reason to lynch her...

She's been very inactive as well. Not even active lurking :/
@Akuraito;

Vote: Akuraito

what do you have to say to us girl

Are you hiding something?

Thank you for the notice Neon Borealis.

Akuraito is in the process of being subbed out.

Vote: Akuraito-or-whoever-the-sub-is

^_^

Knowing that she's going to be subbed out is making me rethinking my vote. The activity has to be in thread for it to count right?

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

Knowing that she's going to be subbed out is making me rethinking my vote. The activity has to be in thread for it to count right?

Whether she's being subbed out or not doesn't change the fact that you agreed that her being swift to unvote Mijz was a good reason to vote her. You only added inactivity as an afterthought. To say you're rethinking your vote purely for that reason is a bit strange.

Originally Posted by KidBeano

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

Knowing that she's going to be subbed out is making me rethinking my vote. The activity has to be in thread for it to count right?

Whether she's being subbed out or not doesn't change the fact that you agreed that her being swift to unvote Mijz was a good reason to vote her. You only added inactivity as an afterthought. To say you're rethinking your vote purely for that reason is a bit strange.

That is true, but there wasn't anything that made me think she was innocent :/

It's a weak reason to rethink a vote, so I guess I'll keep the vote.

So wait a minute. KB is FoSing Human for having doubts about a random lynch on an inactive person? This is what I'm getting, and it doesn't make KB look any better. Especially when the WW is looking at a potential meal, which isn't dead yet. Although I will admit that the WW might be saving him as a late-game snack.

Originally Posted by GliscorMan

So wait a minute. KB is FoSing Human for having doubts about a random lynch on an inactive person? This is what I'm getting, and it doesn't make KB look any better. Especially when the WW is looking at a potential meal, which isn't dead yet. Although I will admit that the WW might be saving him as a late-game snack.

He didn't FoS me in the first place :/

And I doubt the werewolf would save what could screw him as a late-game snack.