Thread: Warrior Cats Mafia [ENDGAME - The Dark Forest and AlaskaPigeon wins!] [8.15.12]

Originally Posted by Feliciano

Originally Posted by Rayne*

If I may ask, would we be allowed to guess who other cats might be? Like can we discuss if someone might be Leopardstar or Firestar (though given the timeline, I'm thinking we might be dealing with Leopardfur and Fireheart.)

Well, considering both were made leaders during the middle of the series (and there are pretty obvious references to Tigerstar in the flavor text of the signup but also wasn't a leader until the middle of the series), I'm not sure what sort of continuity he's playing with. Especially since the Dark Forest subplot didn't show up in the book until the third series.

The Dark Forest context is definitely throwing this timeline out of whack for me. Which isn't a bad thing, I like to keep on my paws.

But if there's a fool out there, I can think of quite a few. Purdy, even Graystripe, that gray haired goofball. And then there's Berrynose :P

But if we're sticking to the old forest I don't think Purdy would fit here.

If it were a 'fool' role, I'd say it had to be a one-shot character.

Originally Posted by Rayne*

If I may ask, would we be allowed to guess who other cats might be? Like can we discuss if someone might be Leopardstar or Firestar (though given the timeline, I'm thinking we might be dealing with Leopardfur and Fireheart.)

Yes, you may guess, but you can't confirm other's guesses as that's borderline name claiming. But it's okay to say, "Based on his role claim he could be Firestar."

As for the timeline... think after the second series when Tigerstar, Hawkfrost, etc. are dead, but we're only dealing with first series cats :x

Originally Posted by America*

Originally Posted by Rayne*

If I may ask, would we be allowed to guess who other cats might be? Like can we discuss if someone might be Leopardstar or Firestar (though given the timeline, I'm thinking we might be dealing with Leopardfur and Fireheart.)

Yes, you may guess, but you can't confirm other's guesses as that's borderline name claiming. But it's okay to say, "Based on his role claim he could be Firestar."

Ah thanks, I'm sure that shouldn't get too out of hand.

I admit not being able to roleplay the character is a small disappointment, but I can make do in other ways.

As for the timeline... think after the second series when Tigerstar, Hawkfrost, etc. are dead, but we're only dealing with first series cats :x

Now that makes for an awesome alternate universe.

We're not supposed to roleplay our characters or give hints to their identities. I don't think her posting style has anything to do with anything.
@Neonsands; I voted because while it was a random vote, it was a random vote without an ounce of justification given. Not even a, "Just to get things rolling," kind of response. Her reasoning was, "just because." Because is not a reason. Because is what people say when they don't want to say what they really mean. And I'm only holding the vote on her until I get some kind of defense or reasoning. All I'm getting are liked posts.

Originally Posted by America*

As for the timeline... think after the second series when Tigerstar, Hawkfrost, etc. are dead, but we're only dealing with first series cats :x

Wait, Hawkfrost? I thought Hawkfrost was strictly a second-series cat.

Well...I'm pretty sure we're dealing with Leopardstar, Blackstar, and Firestar, now. Crookedstar and Bluestar are probably filed under StarClan. That also means Tallstar is probably still kicking around somewhere. I'm with Ryuu - I can't think of a cat that fits a post-limiting role like that. I thought it could be Bone, but since we're dealing with the Dark Forest and not BloodClan, that's probably not it. Could be Ravenpaw, I guess. He was always too scared to say much of anything.

But if it's later in the series, Ravenpaw would actually be braver.

Honestly, I don't think her reason to not post has anything to do with her role.

Wait asdfghjkl;

There actually are a few cats from the second series :/

I counted and there's three. They all appear very early in the second series though.

Well, that narrows it down to...pretty much the entire main cast of the second series. And Hawkfrost, apparently :/

No question Hawkfrost is mafia. As for the other two...Mothwing and Sasha as town and independent, maybe?

It's the liking that's really throwing me off. What reason could she have to like so many posts, even if she can't post herself?

Um... Feathertail? Stormfur? Brambleclaw? Squirrelflight? Leafpool?

@America*; Can I be subbed out? Personal reasons.

@Gotpika;

Would you like to sub for Hawkeye?

D:

Sad to see you go, Hawkeye. I hope everything is okay *hug*

Febe, does your role prevent you from posting more than once? Let us know!

...If he does have a role that prevents him from posting more than once, how could he let us know?