Thread: Warrior Cats Mafia [ENDGAME - The Dark Forest and AlaskaPigeon wins!] [8.15.12]

Originally Posted by Scarlet Enchantress

There wasn't a restriction listed in her role PM. :/

Oh, yeah! Stupid me. :(

...no i didn't hate my role.....i intended to play it....i just intended to lynch someone and said "just because" because I'm first a noob, and the person above me didn't really seem to give a good reason in my opinion...i didnt' defend self because to me pleading innocent means nothing...I'd have to prove it somehow...so tried to leave some hints(I'm sorry if it wasn't legal) in the last poster thread(I'll get them later if needed) but no one caught on....and i liked the posts so i could be assumed to be the fool after everyone thought i was suspicious so i could avoid getting lynched....yeah..may have not been the best strategy...oh well....

But you could have left the hints or even just a reason for voting here. That would have solved it.

I'm sorry your first game ended this way.

Seems I should've pushed harder. Something just seemed off to me with the whole reasoning, but...
I'm with Neonsands on this one, Ryuu's a great player, but we have to think for ourselves.

Also, sorry Jolty, hope you have a better game next time.

[MENTION=42956]Jolty Febe[/MENTION]; hon, just because people found your reasoning suspicious doesn't mean that they won't believe you if you defend yourself. It wasn't as though we were dead set on lynching you in particular. But because you stayed quiet and didn't actually post anything, people got even more suspicious. The vote before yours had a very obviously tongue-in-cheek statement following it - it wasn't hard to figure out that it was supposed to be a joke. The lack of any sort of statement like that in your vote, however, was what tipped people off, and I take full blame for not thinking harder on my vote and helping to lynch you off.

I'm sorry your first game had to end this way, but please don't think we're all just out to get you because you were new. We weren't trying to scare you off - trust me, I know how scary and disheartening it can be to get bandwagoned and lynched off on the first day. But no one's going to think badly of you or attack you if you speak up and defend yourself. If you truly had no reason, then explain that. It won't take any more than "Well, the person ahead of me voted for no reason, so I thought it would be okay if I did too." They may or may not find faults in your logic, but that has nothing to do with you, all right? And who knows? You might've convinced a few people of your innocence. So next time, don't be afraid to make more than one post, okay? We're all just here to have fun.

...Maybe this's just me, but I really didn't like the flavor text leading up to this kill. I mean, I know there wasn't a whole hell of a lot to go on, and I fully admit I hopped on the bandwagon a little quicker than I should've, but everything in the flavor text just felt so...token. Then again, that's probably just the writer in me flailing around.

Now that that's off my chest...I agree with Neonsands. We all need to keep our wits about us from now on. Acting as mouse-brained as we did today is only gonna help the Dark Forest. StarClan watch over you all this night.

Originally Posted by Thunder Lord Z

[MENTION=56536]Soulmaster[/MENTION]; It was a joke, you even admitted that. No one (or at least no one smart) would reveal themselves as mafia as soon as they got their role.

Just saw this so here is my response.

Why were you defending him when he only had one vote? It wasn't like anyone else was paying attention to it so why are you? As of now I'm thinking you and him are the most suspicious.

Well, it is time for this ol' deputy to got get his evening rabbit and settle down to keep vigil. StarClan guard your path.

Originally Posted by Soulmaster

Originally Posted by Thunder Lord Z

[MENTION=56536]Soulmaster[/MENTION]; It was a joke, you even admitted that. No one (or at least no one smart) would reveal themselves as mafia as soon as they got their role.

Just saw this so here is my response.

Why were you defending him when he only had one vote? It wasn't like anyone else was paying attention to it so why are you? As of now I'm thinking you and him are the most suspicious.

Oh, I don't care about his vote. In fact, I'm scrolling through the posts right now to see who he voted for. I've played with Axle before and he makes, "Confirming that I'm mafia—oh, did I say that, no one must know" jokes quite a bit without actually being mafia is all I'm saying.

And he didn't hold a vote on anyone anyways.

Nah, I didn't have any real suspicions yet, and the bandwagon had already started, so I didn't really see any reason to vote.

^Still liking posts, Jolty? :-P

Well it's upping my like count, so I can't complain.

Isn't it considered dead talking to keep liking posts after death?

Actually, I think you're right there. [MENTION=42956]Jolty Febe[/MENTION]; Even though the posts you're liking are innocuous, it's technically breaking the rules, so I'd suggest not doing it anymore.

I do normally keep neutral after death posts, though that scene brings back memories. The whole incident with Swiftpaw was pretty heart wrenching. It's a sad poetic way to end the first phase considering Swift was a very shortlived character and relatively young.

But keep your head up Jolty, there's a lot of great players here giving some good advice! Don't be afraid to stick your neck out a bit in the next game even if the situation seems rough. You come out less suspicious for trying something than not trying at all. And if you don't know what to say, even if it might not be the 'right' thing, you'll eventually find your way and get better the more you do it!