Thread: War Room Mafia BYOB - Live and Learn - NEW AGE WINS - ratings are up

I don't plan on telling anyone who the reviver is. He trusts me fully.

Originally Posted by Feralize

Originally Posted by Exor

I wouldn't tell anyone, or else we've got ourselves a forever dead doctor.

I really don't see a good reason for Lith - or any of us - to trust you at this stage of the game.

So you're implying that it's okay for Lith to go around telling people who the reviver is? Great idea.

What makes you guys think I'd do something stupid like that? I know I'm reckless, but not THAT reckless...

Originally Posted by Exor

Originally Posted by Feralize

Originally Posted by Exor

I wouldn't tell anyone, or else we've got ourselves a forever dead doctor.

I really don't see a good reason for Lith - or any of us - to trust you at this stage of the game.

So you're implying that it's okay for Lith to go around telling people who the reviver is? Great idea.

I didn't imply that, don't twist my words pls. All I was saying is that IF Lith was going to tell anyone (and she has made it clear that she isn't going to) she shouldn't tell you.

Originally Posted by Feralize

Originally Posted by Exor

Originally Posted by Feralize

Originally Posted by Exor

I wouldn't tell anyone, or else we've got ourselves a forever dead doctor.

I really don't see a good reason for Lith - or any of us - to trust you at this stage of the game.

So you're implying that it's okay for Lith to go around telling people who the reviver is? Great idea.

I didn't imply that, don't twist my words pls. All I was saying is that IF Lith was going to tell anyone (and she has made it clear that she isn't going to) she shouldn't tell you.

And yet you twist my words. I never said she should tell me.

Originally Posted by Exor

Originally Posted by Feralize

I didn't imply that, don't twist my words pls. All I was saying is that IF Lith was going to tell anyone (and she has made it clear that she isn't going to) she shouldn't tell you.

And yet you twist my words. I never said she should tell me.

That's why you said that you "wouldn't tell anyone", which makes it sound like you expected her to tell you. That, and I said what I did because I am suspicious of you.

@Feralize; Oh. That was another way of saying that I wouldn't tell anyone if I was in her position.

Why is that?

Originally Posted by Exor

@Feralize; Oh. That was another way of saying that I wouldn't tell anyone if I was in her position.

Why is that?

Oh, okay.

Let's start with how you led a lynch on a townie.

Originally Posted by Feralize

Originally Posted by Exor

@Feralize; Oh. That was another way of saying that I wouldn't tell anyone if I was in her position.

Why is that?

Oh, okay.

Let's start with how you led a lynch on a townie.

Which lynch are you talking about? I wasn't the first on Mizzy. I found him suspicious. So did you.

Originally Posted by Feralize

Without absolute certainty that Joltik was town, Mijz was under no obligation to defend her. However, that said, I don't think that keeping quiet and letting Joltik get lynched was the right (or town) thing to do, because "She was a lost cause" is a pretty poor (and scummy) excuse.

Vote: Mijzelffan

Originally Posted by Phoenicks

Sorry guys; I messed up. I've been really rusty and I shouldn't've lead a lynch when I had been away for two phases. I'm going to have to regroup and do some serious thinking. It's not fun being wrong.

You didn't lead a lynch. We all thought we had reasonable reasons to back up our votes, but somehow it turned out to be wrong XDD It was all bad luck. We shall get the mafia in the next day phase

Originally Posted by Exor

Which lynch are you talking about? I wasn't the first on Mizzy. I found him suspicious. So did you.

Originally Posted by Feralize

Without absolute certainty that Joltik was town, Mijz was under no obligation to defend her. However, that said, I don't think that keeping quiet and letting Joltik get lynched was the right (or town) thing to do, because "She was a lost cause" is a pretty poor (and scummy) excuse.

Vote: Mijzelffan

And you got pretty aggressive and insistent with your suspicion - and you were the second vote on the wagon (not gonna count Greece's vote as she only voted Mijz for voting her). That said, I did agree based on the evidence, mostly his unhelpful defense.

@Feralize; Don't see how I was being aggressive.

Originally Posted by Exor

Don't see how I was being aggressive.

Well, it was mainly this one that I was referring to.

Originally Posted by Exor

I wanted to see what Mizzy's response was before voting him. The way he responded to Joltik's death without defending her made me suspicious. After hearing his response, I've gotta say he seems the most anti town atm. He said it would be hard to defend her, but he didn't try at all.

Vote: Mijzelffan

Pushing the wagon by placing the second vote (of that justification) on Mijz, and listening to his defense only to apparently toss it to the side, seeing as how you just passed it off as "he didn't try".

I voted him for the same reason you did, essentially, I don't see what you're getting at...

Whatever, I'm just going to drop this.