Thread: War Room Mafia BYOB - Live and Learn - NEW AGE WINS - ratings are up

Unless, of course, two people claim cop to one person, which is highly unlikely.

Something's not right here. Are we having an argument about why the cop would claim to his targets that he was cop and got innocent reports on both of them?

If Belarus is checked by the cop, then we shouldn't lynch her and I'm not voting her her. The odds of her being godfather (~1/18) are much lower than the odds of someone else being mafia.

For now: Vote: Bernie Kuneon

Pretty much the entire game you've sheepvoted -- voted only after everyone else has laid the groundwork. You haven't really acted independently. Convince me why that isn't scummy.

Originally Posted by Phoenicks

Something's not right here. Are we having an argument about why the cop would claim to his targets that he was cop and got innocent reports on both of them?

That is not the only thing that is in question here. In fact, this didn't even come into play about the argument until fairly recently. There are legitimate reasons to suspect Belarus., and a "supposed" cop check under these circumstances is somewhat questionable at this moment.

After reading through all of this I don't know what to think so for right now:

Vote: No Lynch

This IS a placeholder until I make up my mind.

*sigh* You know, I always like to act on my hunches. And I'm so involved at this point anyway, I might as well vote.

VOTE: Belarus.

In addition to what has already been said, I have another reason why I suspect you, as it is something that really confused me. And unless your eventual answer convinces me, I think this is the best course of action.

Yeah... It looks like I won't win this war...

It doesn't help that Belarus. is offline... DX

WHY MUST I HAVE A LIFE THE DAY IT'S IMPORTANT I NEED TO BE ON sifaliksd

Flonne... DX Let me read the posts...

Originally Posted by Mintaka

You guys seriously never read the rules, when I had you write a brief summary for your sign-up post. -_-;

There's this awesome feature of Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V lol XDD

Anyways, if Belarus turns out to be a mafia, then Lithuania will be up for the next questioning, it seems XDD

But really... what might happen if Belarus IS a townie...?

@Destiny Queen; Even so, you should be reading them.

Originally Posted by Destiny Queen

Originally Posted by Mintaka

You guys seriously never read the rules, when I had you write a brief summary for your sign-up post. -_-;

There's this awesome feature of Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V lol XDD

Anyways, if Belarus turns out to be a mafia, then Lithuania will be up for the next questioning, it seems XDD

But really... what might happen if Belarus IS a townie...?

Everyone else would have some explaining to do. XD

Okay, vote tally first to sort my mind.

Belarus.: VI (Exor, Pichuboy, Destiny Queen, Buoy, Feralize, FinalArcadia)
No Lynch: I (Hawkeye)
Bernie: I (Phoenicks)

X_X

Defense pending...

You missed my vote for Destiny Queen. XD

Okay, I've been looking through all of Flonne's posts. She has been very vocal about trying to appear innocent. Much more so than in any other game I've seen her in. I don't quiet buy the fact that it's because of her restriction to only be in one game, she played in skyward sword mafia under the same restriction and wasn't like that at all. Also, her claiming to Lith day 1 isn't odd per say, but that convention cop check just doesn't sit well with me.

Unvote: No Lynch

Vote: Belarus.

FoS: Lithuania

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Originally Posted by Phoenicks

Something's not right here. Are we having an argument about why the cop would claim to his targets that he was cop and got innocent reports on both of them?

That is not the only thing that is in question here. In fact, this didn't even come into play about the argument until fairly recently. There are legitimate reasons to suspect Belarus., and a "supposed" cop check under these circumstances is somewhat questionable at this moment.

It's hard to judge Belarus's behavior without knowing what her role is. Lithuania seems to trust her on this basis, and so, apparently, does the cop. I don't want to throw away what may be a power role just yet. If she's scum, we can get her tomorrow. If she's a townie, we'll never get that back.

"Legitimate reasons" -- could you elaborate? The reasons as I see them are "Greece didn't vote for Belarus" and "Belarus said scummy things because she didn't want to be lynched". I agree that those are legitimate reasons in their own right -- but I want to hear what Belarus has to say first.

I'd rather lynch Bernie. I'm willing to take full responsibility for a lynch on him.

Unvote: Destiny Queen

My vote doesn't really matter at this point, anyway...