Thread: War Room Mafia BYOB - Live and Learn - NEW AGE WINS - ratings are up

Went back through the thread, found something I consider a little odd.

(After Joltik was lynched)

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

Originally Posted by Mintaka

a Veteran.

Allright, who didn't see this coming. Seriously.

And yet, during the entire day phase, he didn't try to defend Joltik at all. Despite him apparently having reason to believe she was town.

:/

@Exor; She was most likely town because there was literally no good reason to vote her, as she was voted as random target (Phoenicks), to prevent Belarus from getting lynched (Lithuania,, fahrenheit?, Greece?), to have a no lynch (Fahrenheit?, Pichuboy), to not have a no lynch (Ryuutakeshi), or to simply bandwagon for no good reason at all (Greece?, Bernie).

These people didn't vote Joltik for logical reasons, so trying to dissuade them with logic wouldn't have helped.

But why didn't you bring up your problems with the lynch? Surely someone would have listened.

Can I haz rainbows?

Wow this works!! XDD

But srsly, knowing that a fellow member was a townie and not saving her does sound odd...

Hmm sad to see you go Zenaxwell there goes one of our forever suspects

Still, your behaviour wasn't all that... cool XDD

Vote: Mijzelffan

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

to have a no lynch (Fahrenheit?, Pichuboy)

I didn't vote to No Lynch. Yeah, I said I would in the Skype Chat, but then I voted because Ryuu said he was certain that I was defending one of the people who was up for lynch by wanting a No Lynch, so I said I would vote for whichever one he told me to. Lo and behold, Joltik was town, so through his train of thought, me and Belarus. must be mafia buddies.

I'm confused by your last statement, however, especially since there wasn't much logic to defend Joltik with other than "I don't feel this is a right lynch", which isn't logic, that's instinct. Even if people did vote randomly, they're not going to unvote without someone giving them good reason (i.e. logic). I'm just puzzled as to why you felt it was a lost cause.

Originally Posted by Destiny Queen

Still, your behaviour wasn't all that... cool XDD

Vote: Mijzelffan

Me not being cool is a bad reason to vote me, as that says squat about my allignment. If you actually have a reason as to why I'd be mafia then you might want to use that as a reason instead.

But on to my vote, which will go to Greece. As I pointed out earlier, Greece seemingly only voted either because she wanted to keep Belarus alive, or to randomly hop on a bandwagon. The former being scummy because why would you want to keep Belarus alive for no appearent reason unless you're on the same team, and the latter being scummy because she might try to avoid being pinned down for lurking later on.

vote: Greece

Originally Posted by Central African Republic*

I'm confused by your last statement, however, especially since there wasn't much logic to defend Joltik with other than "I don't feel this is a right lynch", which isn't logic, that's instinct. Even if people did vote randomly, they're not going to unvote without someone giving them good reason (i.e. logic). I'm just puzzled as to why you felt it was a lost cause.

I think something along the lines of "statistically voting someone just because they pointed out you can't vote the host is more likely to hit you an innocent than a mafioso" sounds pretty logical. Also I already told you why I felt it was a lost cause. Not to mention the update was only 30 minutes away when you and Ryuu suddenly flipped the bandwagon in Joltik's favour; before that I expected more people to vote Belarus due to the better arguments to due so. And yes, I think 30 minutes is too less time to trigger any major changes and thus consider it a lost cause.

Give me your reasons for voting Belarus outside of her behavior. She always acts the way she did in this game. I had nothing to go on and I did not like us having yet another "No Lynch"

Besides, aren't you the one who always says you'll always take a Day 1 Lynch over a No Lynch?

Originally Posted by Ryuutakeshi

Give me your reasons for voting Belarus outside of her behavior.

This:

Originally Posted by Zenax

Originally Posted by Belarus.

I didn't want to vote her since that'd put suspicion on me due to your vote...

That's bad reasoning because if you are a townie you should be focusing on trying to find who's mafia and who isn't instead of doing your best to avoid being suspected by the other players. That's what the mafia is supposed to do.

As a rule of thumb mafia are the ones who take measures to avoid looking suspicious, not the townies. 100% accurate? No, but neither is a guilty copcheck. I'll take what I can get, especially since I didn't really see better options at the time.

Besides, aren't you the one who always says you'll always take a Day 1 Lynch over a No Lynch?

Who said I wanted a no lynch? Also, >implying I play every mafia game the same way

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

Originally Posted by Zenax

Originally Posted by Belarus.

I didn't want to vote her since that'd put suspicion on me due to your vote...

That's bad reasoning because if you are a townie you should be focusing on trying to find who's mafia and who isn't instead of doing your best to avoid being suspected by the other players. That's what the mafia is supposed to do.

As a rule of thumb mafia are the ones who take measures to avoid looking suspicious, not the townies. 100% accurate? No, but neither is a guilty copcheck. I'll take what I can get, especially since I didn't really see better options at the time.

While I don't disagree on that, consider it is Belarus I really couldn't justify using that as a reason. I wanted to make sure that if I voted someone I wasn't going to get the entire town on my back.

Who said I wanted a no lynch? Also, >implying I play every mafia game the same way

I actually think I have a quote of you saying you always prefer getting a Day 1 Lynch :p

Vote: Milzelffan

Survival technique.

Mijzelffan: II (Destiny Queen, Greece)
Greece: I (Mijzelffan)

[Vote: Greece]

I don't think we should lynch someone mijz just yet

I didn't realize Mijz had a vote on him ^^; I'd unvote him but then I would die.