Thread: Unovian Murders II - Aftershocks Sgt. Pepper's WINS, THE TOWN LOSES

Originally Posted by Psych

I have a feeling that's a trap...

Naw,naw see?
Vote:Sourcandy

Vote: TFSpock

The Zwelious has a point.

You know what? Lynch me. When Flame Alex announces me a a townie, you'll regret it.

Okay, now with the WIFOM I may be beginning to think TFS is looking guilty.

Your seriously trying to make this difficult for me to count all the votes, aren't you?

Inspect these three quotes. Does anyone find it odd, that first Opg thought it was irrational for IK to be mafia?

Originally Posted by Opossumguy

Is it really smart to vote based on the Pokemon? That didn't really help us in the last game...

, as more people joined, so did he?

Then, as more people hopped on the bandwagon, he did too?

Originally Posted by Opossumguy

Vote: Ice Kyurem


The more I look at the situation, the more likely it seems that he's mafia.

Originally Posted by Opossumguy

hurristat's right. We have far more evidence for TFSpock.

Unvote: Ice Kyurem

Vote: TFSpock

Don't wanna seem suspicious? Ahh. hurristat stated that I am using the bandwagon trick to cover myself. That's not far more evidence than IK's position. I think it's obvious.

Originally Posted by TFSpock

Inspect these three quotes. Does anyone find it odd, that first Opg thought it was irrational for IK to be mafia?

, as more people joined, so did he?

Then, as more people hopped on the bandwagon, he did too?






Don't wanna seem suspicious? Ahh. hurristat stated that I am using the bandwagon trick to cover myself. That's not far more evidence than IK's position. I think it's obvious.

This really isn't helping you. At first, I didn't see justice in voting IK, so I didn't vote. Then TLZ said that it would be more likely to be mafia if the previous Kyurem had no role. Afterwards I foolishly followed any lead we had. Then, hurristat came in, and, being an expert mafia player, pointed out more evidence toward you being mafia. It's the first day, we need as much info as possible, and we would get a lot of info out of you being mafia or not, and signs point to you being mafia, as pointed out by hurristat. Now, you accuse me of being suspicious, yet you make bogus claims.

You all know who to vote for.

I don't mean to sound scummy, but how do you know I'm making bogus claims?! I suppose you can read my mind? After my first post, people bandwagoned against me because of hurristat's evidence. How do we know hurristat is telling the truth? Don't get me wrong, it's fine evidence, but what if he made it up? I'm not saying he's lying, but who here actually knows anyone else is lying/truthful? I made the same mistake as you, jumping on the bandwagon. You said, "Now, you accuse me of being suspicious,". Yes, I accuse you of being suspicious. Oh- that's a crime, right? I'm a mafia for that. So, then, if that's the case, EVERYONE IN THIS GAME IS MAFIA.

Wait, what claims did I make are bogus? Maybe they are, but, you're not bogus? I have just as much right to accuse you that you have to accuse me.

Yeah, this isn't helping me. But maybe, this will help the others, somehow, sometime.

Originally Posted by Psych

Why are we voting TFSpock? Didn't Thunder Lord Z make the first vote on IK?

##Vote Thunder Lord Z

Thunder Lord Z was randomlynching. The rest were not.

Originally Posted by TFSpock

You guys are right.
Unvote: Ice Kyurem

But, hurristat, what evidence do you have that I'm mafia? So I'm suspicious about IK. That doesn't give you a reason to vote for me.

Yes it does, you blindly followed a lynch. And then when we applied pressure, you switched.

I'm neutral on your position. You were mafia last time, so I say
Vote: No lynch

Roles determined by RNGs. Past roles don't mean jack shit now.

Originally Posted by ! Thunder Lord Z

Keep in mind this is his first game. He might not know that following bandwagons is never a good reason for anything

Even if he is a noob, how does it serve us to ignore scumtells?

Originally Posted by Opossumguy

Then, hurristat came in, and, being an expert mafia player, pointed out more evidence toward you being mafia.

[plankton voice]Oooh, I'm an expert now![/plankton voice]

All joking aside, I think that opossumguy's defence isn't much better than TFSpock's. I'll be keeping my eye on you as well, opossumguy.

Originally Posted by TFSpock

How do we know hurristat is telling the truth? Don't get me wrong, it's fine evidence, but what if he made it up? I'm not saying he's lying, but who here actually knows anyone else is lying/truthful?

Look -- the reason they bandwagoned you was because I picked up on a scumtell. I wouldn't get a response by lynching SoulMelody, and I knew what opossumguy's response would be (that still doesn't exonerate you, opossumguy). That left you. I didn't necessarily want a bandwagon, but that's what I got. You haven't really given me a reason to unvote yet, but if you will, I will unvote.

For the mafia, it's hard to take a step and just say "Let's lynch him" on the first day. Hard to make up a reason too. That brings attention to them. So I don't really find Thunder Lord Z suspicious yet, but rather the ones that followed the lead.
But I don't feel confident enough to vote...
Much as it seems suspicious, I'm not going to vote. Besides, later on, the murderers will leave behind clues and we'll get information about the murderers from them...if that system applies to this game too.

Kyurem wasn't given a role last time...dunno about this game. Like hurristat said, the murderers are chosen randomly... :/

@Sourcandy: Someone votes for him/herself again on the first Day...I never got to understand what that move meant. xD

Vote: TFSpock

He seems be motivated to please the town with his votes. Which is usually what a mafia does, to avoid lynching.

Originally Posted by hurristat

Even if he is a noob, how does it serve us to ignore scumtells?

Not my first game, my first game on here. Yet no matter what I end up doing something scummy by trying to do something unscummy.

It's really a curse.

Cause later if you all want to lynch me, you'd think "Oh, he just bandwagoned right along. Mafia." so I can't do that, but if I vote the other guy that's even more scummy, so I have to say why, so that's also scummy and IT'S ALL SCUMMY.

While it is regarded as suspicious to not go along with the crowd sometimes, even more suspicious is always going with the crowd. That's because a crowd is a good place to stay low, which is of course, what the mafia wants.

Therefore, trying to do something unscummy actually makes one very scummy (god I hate that word, "scummy"). Innocents might actually enjoy a little suspicion in order to avoid nightkills, and maybe get checked by the cop to get cleaned, whereas being suspicious doesn't help the mafia. Therefore the mafia will try the hardest not to seem suspicious (or as you put it, "scummy").

Oh yea, I forgot.
Unvote: Psych

(S)He explained himself/herself.

Originally Posted by Mintaka

@Sourcandy: Someone votes for him/herself again on the first Day...I never got to understand what that move meant. xD

to draw out the impatient ones.

Hey. Not voting is a scumtell, too.

+allows you to stay on the sidelines with a plausible alibi
+lets you off the hook [exception is if you're dealing with a town that loves to analyze wagons based on votecounts]
+not saving you from a overzealous townie

ffs, you pretty much have to vote today.

Anywho, opossumguy strikes me as some poster that's trying to stay UTR by unvoting and voting way too much-which isn't gonna work here. My train of thought: only vote when everything you have is enough so that you won't unvote.

Vote: Opossumguy