Thread: Trouble in Newbieville - 1/26/13 TOWN WINS & Mentor Chat

Originally Posted by Pokemaster97

Hmm, that's true (just re-read the possible rolls list at the beginning). Maybe I'm just looking to far in to it. :p

If you re-read the thread, I brought it up.
@Sputnik; I know you're online so how about contributing

I don't have much to say! After we get some interesting information or potential leads, you'll definitely hear my voice.

I don't have much to say! After we get some interesting information or potential leads, you'll definitely hear my voice.

FoS: Sputnik

I think we'll probably vote you after hearing your voice. Ah, nothing serious - just meta.

@Sputnik; Leads? We have leads yet you aren't acting on them. You keep repeating yourself.
@Dark Blueberry; you haven't contributed much either. All you've done is joke vote our host, ask me who'd I vote for, and FoS Sputnik despite not participating in the conversations.

Vote count is 3 no lynch, and 2 on Orion

That doesn't change the fact that we don't have any solid proof. We shouldn't be reckless!

Midori, we don't actually have any leads. We're just taking shots in the dark. Which is why...

Vote: No Lynch

Before you accidentally kill someone.

When I vote, I'm prompting discussion. Not actually trying to kill anyone. Midori's crusade against Orion isn't exactly the best course of action. If you look at it, we shouldn't be lynching anyone without a good deal of evidence in a small game like this.

Sorry for the inactivity.

I happen to agree with GliscorMan about how we need more evidence to lynch Orion. But I found this a little strange:

Originally Posted by GliscorMan

Vote: Orion

Of all that I've learned, the most important thing is to vote lots on D1. Best case scenario, nobody gets lynched. Either way, we learn something.

Voting does not equal wishing a random lynch, Orion. Any defense?

GliscorMan, what made you change your mind about Orion? Why do you not think it good to vote him now? He doesn't even have the majority on him, and based on previous posts it's very unlikely he'll get lynched. So your switch to no lynch doesn't actually do anything.

I never said to lynch Orion. I voted him because I find his actions scummy and lunches help gather info. Other than voting him I've been prompting activity and questioning everyone.

I know why you originally voted Orion, and it makes sense, but I was wondering about GliscorMan's sudden switch, since the last time he posted he seemed all for voting Orion.

Edit: Never mind, I thought you were talking to me, sorry. ^^;

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

lunches help gather info.

"Lunch" is scheduled for 5 1/2 hours from now, by the way.

Originally Posted by Shadows

Sorry for the inactivity.

I happen to agree with GliscorMan about how we need more evidence to lynch Orion. But I found this a little strange:

Originally Posted by GliscorMan

Vote: Orion

Of all that I've learned, the most important thing is to vote lots on D1. Best case scenario, nobody gets lynched. Either way, we learn something.

Voting does not equal wishing a random lynch, Orion. Any defense?

GliscorMan, what made you change your mind about Orion? Why do you not think it good to vote him now? He doesn't even have the majority on him, and based on previous posts it's very unlikely he'll get lynched. So your switch to no lynch doesn't actually do anything.

Because, quite frankly, I was made to see logic. That's a little new for me, so I hope it sticks.

@Master Mew; but I want it now
@GliscorMan; and what logic is that. Everyone but me seems to be saying we shouldn't lynch without more info, but yet no one is trying for conversation except me.

@stillboy; @**Derpy.McDerpy**; What do you two think of everything so far?

I guess since I'm out of time..... Vote:No Lynch

Mentioning inactives is being thrown around like it's going out of style, and imo it's not a towntell anymore. If you're going to mention them I'd suggest you ask them about a specific occurrence, such as "Do you think we should lynch someone on Day 1, even though we have little information," or "What do you think of Orion's interactions with Midorikawa".

Personally, I would prefer to lynch someone on Day 1, because if we don't, like I said before we are giving the initiative to the mafia. They won't have to worry about being hit if we don't try to lynch anyone, and no discussion because of minimal voting is bad for the town. That said, there isn't much I can do to swing the votes at this point, so I'm not going to vote for a random person, but I will say that Orion's voting No Lynch with no other explanation looked a bit scummy to me.

I also agree with Midorikawa; we need conversation, and if we wait to lynch someone until we have "enough info" (whenever that may be), it will most likely be too late. You have to take some chances, look at posts and try to discern anti-town behavior.