Thread: Tales of the Abyss -END GAME TOWN WON - 9/13/12

Not completely. Yes they give reactions but most of the time unless more then one vote is on the person so bunches of random votes on all different people is not bad at all.
Unvote: Tris79
Vote: Takaki
For your reactions to this.

Um, not really. We can find out a lot through reactions to day one lynching. For example, once someone was mafia being lynched day one, and two people were defending them and turned out to be mafia as well. Even if we hit a townie, we still get information. The worst thing we can do is sit down and do nothing and wait for the mafia to kill us all.

I fail to see how me questioning the usefulness of a tactic makes me mafia. There are inherent flaws with day one lynching regardless of whether it is optimal or not and me pointing them out and asking caution before reaction testing a guy because he confirmed in spanish has nothing to do with alignment. As mafia there would be no reason for me to object to it and in fact sharing my opinion shows positive play as I'm willing to get involved and interact with other players. Your vote on me has zero weight behind it and is completely unjustifiable. Plus your reasoning was ridiculously vague.

I'd rather everybody speak until I even touch my vote.

Vote: HilbertCressLover. She wasn't in my last game. Only a confirmed mafia would willingly ignore my game.

Also you need to have the date present in each title.

Thanks again Shinobu.

VOTE: Shinobu For having had a mafia game and for helping the host

Vote: Neonsands

Originally Posted by Takaki

Vote: Neonsands

And that's not a dreaded random vote how? :P

Vote: Greece

It's Day 1 anyways. Getting lynched right after you confirmed your role is something really mean XDD

Well - still, as long as the votes are tied, it shouldn't do much harm.

Unvote: Greece

Vote: VeloJello, for posting before me.

It's not random. I'm voting him for a reason.

Originally Posted by Takaki

It's not random. I'm voting him for a reason.

Mind telling us?

Well they're almost the only person who hasn't spoken yet and reading their posts on the rest of the board they don't seem all that verbos in their writing.

Originally Posted by Takaki

Well there almost the only person who hasn't spoken yet and reading their posts on the rest of the board they don't seem all that verbos in their writing.

Actually, provided Neon isn't mafia, he's usually one of the town's most valuable players.

I will give @Takaki; that @Neonsands;' quietness is a little bit suspicious (emphasis on the little), but it's still only the start of the game. We should give him a chance to defend himself.

Originally Posted by Axle Helios

I will give @Takaki; that @Neonsands;' quietness is a little bit suspicious (emphasis on the little), but it's still only the start of the game. We should give him a chance to defend himself.

So...for how long? I do hope we don't have to wait forever for someone to post something...