Whatever, I give up. All we're doing is debating in circles, irritating each other to no end, and it's obvious that we're not changing our votes by this point.
Though there's one thing I have to say:
Not really, no. Whether or not he's silenced, he really wouldn't be able to defend himself against us since a lie detector got him lying on being a vig. Fakeclaiming twice isn't something a townie's going to do, and I fail to see what reasoning he would have for doing that unless he's scum, hence why he can't defend himself against us.Also, interesting choice of words. Look at the bold. That's a slip, if I ever saw one. It implies that he would, but he is physically unable to defend himself. This further supports my theory.