....... I still find it odd, buuuuut.....
Unvote: Master Mew
I think our main priority today should be finding out which Bulletproof claim is fake. I'm leaning more towards Mijzelffan since the last cop just happens to die the same night we need a check on him.
When someone says or does something and you don't understand the reason behind it, it is more often a towntell than a scumtell. Why? Because Scum are usually very rational.
The Scum win-condition is very simple: Eliminate the Townies. They know who the Townies are, and they know exactly how to remove them from the game.
The Townie's win condition is far more complex: Eliminate the Scum, without knowing who they are and without knowing who they can trust and coordinate with.
When someone does something you don't understand, it means they are approaching the game from a different perspective than you are - and yes, it's true that Scum are approaching the game from a different perspective than Townies, but remember that Scum are trying very hard to look like they are approaching the game from the same perspective as Townies. Other Townies, by comparison, don't worry themselves with looking like Townies, they're busy trying to find scum.
FinalArcadia suddenly seemed almost positive that Momoka was scum at the end of Night 4. Her original reasoning was this post, although she made many more before the update, always pushing more suspicion on Momoka:
...Come to think of it, Jokool, the very next post after FinalArcadia's was yours in which you said you agreed with her:
What changed your mind about Momoka? After all, I was the first to vote for Momoka - and all the attention had previously been on Mijzelffan and Paperhorse, so there was no need for Mafia bussing. Therefore, I have concluded that if you thought my vote for Momoka was scummy, you are assuming that Momoka is innocent.
You were suspicious of her before, what changed?
That is true...
Case open, Case shut
Yeah, and the strongman was oneshot. So, for the sake of getting more activity, who do you think should be lynched?
By the way, @Doctor jokool;, you changed your vote to PH in the previous phase, and then went to vote Mijzelffan again in this phase. Why?
@Mijzelffan;, you seemed to be extremely convinced that PH was lying, and then you went to vote BD. Did you change your mind on PH or are you still suspicious of her?
That's what I get for playing multiple games...
And now that I remember, I still think her actions are odd, but I'd like to wait on voting her until we have something more to go on.
Yeah, and Baron Dante was recently modkilled in the DPPT Mafia too. Maybe he's an Independent who needs to live until the end of the game to win? There hasn't been a single independent dead yet, I think. Laying low could be it. And Mijzelffan's case on him was just because he was inactive, which is pretty shitty when you think about it. Especially when he had a stronger case on Paperhorse and insisted that she was the Mafia godfather. Trying to avoid attention perhaps?
I'll VOTE: Mijzelffan again then. Subject to change.
EDIT: of course i get 2 more responses
That's true. But then I think she would have enforced the lynched more. She's the type of player that can't make up her mind, so that COULD be it. If you're Town and PH is somehow really Mafia, I'd theorize that she didn't vote for Paperhorse to not risk lynching her.
why u no vote mijzelffan before???
Last edited by HumanDawn; 11th January 2013 at 04:59 PM.
I like the Momoka wagon, this needs to happen.