Thread: Star Trek: The Next Generation Mafia (1/24/13) Endgame-Outcasts Win

hey so

guess who's an absolute idiot and didn't claim because she didn't want the mafia to know who she was

when my mason was mafia

so they already know

...

yeah :I

But, um, GM's mason here. Why I was defending him earlier.

It's fine, Aku. Everyone makes mistakes. ^_^ It's good to have two confirmed townies now.

...Like FA said, you're not confirmed. Why do you think I didn't claim to you even before I remembered that the mafia knew who I was? I don't trust you, tbh.

EDIT:

Also, since, well, why not, here are quotes from the QT (I can't share the link). There was a small discussion at the beginning about the past times we had been masons, but that was fairly irrelevant, so... tbh all of the QT was irrelevant but i still want to share it just in case :I

Begins on the first, right before I posted my first defense and redirection of suspicion to Sputnik:

Originally Posted by GM

Maybe a little help over here?

Originally Posted by Me

Omg, crap, I completely forgot to subscribe to the thread again... >< I'm sorry--working on a defense now.

Originally Posted by Me

horrible attempt at defense yay

Originally Posted by Me

...buoy agrees with me?

what

/never expected that someone would, tbh

EDIT:

and Ryoga?

...

O_O

This seems to be getting the heat off you, anyway, so I'm glad. X3

Originally Posted by GM

Thanks, man. I wasn't really able to get online much yesterday. I missed a lot, it seems...

Originally Posted by GM

Something tells me I'm going to regret posting while I have the brain power of a potato.

Originally Posted by GM

Any way you could convince Sput not to redirect to me? I mean, it's not like its the end of the world. In fact, it would clear you if we played our cards right. And considering there's probably still a doctor, you could lead us to victory. /thoughts

So you can see that there wasn't much. If someone asks, I'll get the beginning parts, but for now, I don't see a need.

That was unhelpful...

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

A... wolf?

Sorry, yeah, used to playing Werewolf, which is the same game but with everything renamed.

So, looking back over the previous day's posts, and Aku's chat with GM, it seems like the only people who were actually defending GM yesterday were myself and Buoy. I already gave my rationale, and have to admit wasn't entirely surprised that he was mafia: Buoy, what's your excuse?

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

That was unhelpful...

Literally my reaction when I saw his death and looked through our QT again for clues.

Originally Posted by Master Mew

@FinalArcadia Sputnik is not confirmed, but she is now more likely to be Town than most.

Maybe I'm missing something, but why's that? She hasn't been cop checked(to what I know of), she redirected her lynch to the cop when she acted like she had a plan, and her behavior doesn't exactly scream town. I just don't see what could make her lean toward the town side.

2x lynch redirection for a Mafia is extremely unlikely. Especially with a Mafia member being masons with a Townie. Then again, when I was Mafia in the GSCHGSS Mafia with lynch redirection, I could kill 2 Townies instead of one, but this was with a power up I got.

2x lynch redirection for a townie is very rare, though, too.

Yeah... I think it can go both ways, so we have no way of knowing. All I'm saying is her actions and posts aren't backing up to make her seem more town than mafia.

While Sputnik's actions aren't working in her favor(Redirecting onto the cop, odd games earlier that last phase) I don't know if I have any reason not to believe her. Yes, she was never cop checked, and the only indication is that she claimed... which isn't really an indication, since the role could be either... I can't help but feel this is all a tad too obvious for a mafioso to do. Lynching the cop, acting suspicious, this whole thing... seems off to me.

It could be balanced with a town vig killer. Yeah... about the Sputnik behaviour, it's coming off as her usual self. We have to consider that she did use the 2nd lynch redirection on a Mafia, but that was after you guys forced her to. She seemed to be content with using it, but that could have been an act.

I probably shouldn't bring up another game, but... In the Bleach mafia, she pretty much bussed/called out her own teammate, when it wasn't even needed. So I wouldn't doubt that she would put on an act. But then I guess this is all meta? But still, maybe something to keep in mind.

Maybe we should start trying to figure out what kind of character would have a 2x lynch redirect role.

Anyone have any ideas, like maybe Worf?

Originally Posted by Doctor jokool

Maybe we should start trying to figure out what kind of character would have a 2x lynch redirect role.

Anyone have any ideas, like maybe Worf?

What's the point?