Thread: The Situation Room - Talk about the games or anything!

I always enjoyed playing games with my family, but we can't do it much anymore because most of the family has a job. XD

Sort of the same situation here. We don't do it all that much, but we could, if we wanted to.

What would you guys think of a game that only showed a player's aliment and not the role PM after lynching/Nightkilling? All Roles would be shown at the end of the game though.

^Sounds interesting.

Also, guys, I am an idiot.

(19:55) Belarus.: Oh Flonne xD
(19:55) Belarus.: I forgot the pokemon were mafia.
(19:56) Belarus.: Lol.
(19:56) Thyla: lol
(19:56) Belarus.: Utter fail. xD
(19:56) Thyla: Well, sure made it easy for us :P
(19:57) Belarus.: You're welcome. xD

And I had claimed my character to a confirmed innocent.

xDDD

Thyla is America*.

Originally Posted by Joltik

What would you guys think of a game that only showed a player's aliment and not the role PM after lynching/Nightkilling? All Roles would be shown at the end of the game though.

It would be pretty interesting but also much harder.

@Joltik;

You should host a game like that. :)

Deck-claiming. Yay or nay?

I can't decide if I should allow people to claim their characters' deck types in the Zexal mafia. The fact that some characters have never dueled is what's making the decision hard.

I'm leaning toward no, but does anybody think it would be better to allow deck-claiming?

^The mafia got pretty destroyed due to deckclaiming in the 5-D's mafia, so I would say no.

They still managed to win, though.

I disagree as well with deck claiming. That is practically name claiming, each character has a unique theme. Plus, I do not know who the mafia are but some antagonists - though some protagonists as well - do not have decks to claim.

@Belarus. and @Mintaka, thanks for your feedback! Yeah, I was thinking about how things turned out in the 5D's mafia, and the not-everybody-having-a-deck problem, so I think I'll go ahead and not allow deck-claiming. ^^

On a completely unrelated note... UGH. I won't say what that "UGH" is about, but it's probably pretty obvious, isn't it? XD

I don't even know what I'm doing in the Star Trek Mafia...

That's me in the Fire Emblem mafia. Everything's moving so fast, I don't know when to say anything. XD

Late to the party but I will also say no to deckclaiming BECAUSE in 5Ds mafia, the town had like only one mislynch and the only reason the mafia pulled through - aside from Zenax being incredible - was because there were so many of us. Pretty much, deckclaiming is mostly like nameclaiming. It's just not fair for the mafia and makes it too easy for the town to weed out fakeclaims.

@Hitomi

I went looking through the 5D's mafia, and boy, that was one interesting game! Definitely makes a good case for NOT deck-claiming, LOL.

And I don't want to give too much of an advantage to the people who are more familiar with Zexal. ^^

Thanks for your feedback!

Originally Posted by Joltik

What would you guys think of a game that only showed a player's aliment and not the role PM after lynching/Nightkilling? All Roles would be shown at the end of the game though.

Could be good, but I can't see it making a huge difference. All you'd need to do is ask someone to claim before they get lynched - if they're town, then they were telling the truth, if they're mafia, they're lying if they claimed something like Doctor, and even so, the role of the mafia member is irrelevant, just the fact that you have one down is good enough.