Thread: Pokemon RSE-Hoenn Mafia - THE END - Room of Glory - 12/16

What does a governor do?

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Actually, one other possibility is maybe that of a governor. I don't think anyone's brought that possibility up yet.

True, but that would be a bit odd for a governor to do on Day 1. Unless she is the governor.

^A governor can stop a lynch.

Even if the cop does check her, how would anyone else know her alignment? Not like they could trust anyone enough to tell. And anyway, I think it would waste a cop check. The only way to find out would be to try and lynch her again, because she could always be the godfather. Even that I'm slightly opposed to since I haven't found anything that scummy with her.

@Scarlet Enchantress; A Governor can stop a lynch.

Oh, okay. Never seen the role before so I had to ask. ^^;;

and besides, what was the point of wanting to lynch her to begin with @Sputnik; if I recall correctly, weren't you the first one to vote for her?

No, actually. I was the last one to vote her. XD

The Cop should check someone they have a null-read on, not someone who the Town is already suspicious of.

i keep confusing rio and ryoga omg change your avatars pls

Well...damn, can't say I wasn't hoping to save that for later and feel empowered to be aggressive for once. T_T 1x lynchproof, as if it weren't obvious.

Originally Posted by Sputnik

Most lynchproof roles are mafia-aligned, therefore making her a good person for the cop to check and to be lynched again.

Actually, it's a fairly common argument that having a mafia member be lynchproof is overpowered, iirc. It's hardly 'most common' as a mafia role.

Anyways, you seem much too dead-set on lynching me...and only because I didn't get lynched? That's a horrible argument, no offense; while I do realize that it does place me in a less-than-favorable light dat bkmn mafia, I think that you're being much too aggressive and hasty on this, and...like I said, because I failed to die. That's really not an argument; think about it, really. Because I'm a 1x lynchproof, I should die? That...doesn't work. ><

Aside from that, you're being extremely aggressive towards anyone against me being checked. You seem almost desperate to tag anyone as scummy; so Rio doesn't want me to be checked? There's plenty of valid explanations for that which do not include us being mafia buddies. You're being quite quick to accuse, and it's rubbing me the wrong way, not only because you've FOS'd me.

And...that vote. Did anyone else notice how it was before when the phase update was supposed to be? There would be no way that I would be able to respond, since--and she knows this--I have school at that time and am unable to get on. Even without that, the phase update was coming quickly; seems like a nice way to make it likely that nobody would come in to counter it. It was like she wanted to secure a townie lynch, and was making sure that no double voters could screw with the tally. And it was hardly as if there was any good reasoning for lynching me! Because she 'wanted a lynch' and because I was 'acting strangely'. That's not logic.

Originally Posted by Ryoga Kamishiro

Even if the cop does check her, how would anyone else know her alignment? Not like they could trust anyone enough to tell.

If only screenshots were allowed, huh? XD

I think getting the cop to check Akuraito would actually be a good idea, since lynchproof can be either a townie or mafia role.

Besides, if Akuraito comes up mafia, Rio might too.

Originally Posted by Atomic

I think getting the cop to check Akuraito would actually be a good idea, since lynchproof can be either a townie or mafia role.

Besides, if Akuraito comes up mafia, Rio might too.

Lynchproof is normally a Town role. As a Lynchproof Mafia would be way to OP, as in they would automatically win as said person couldn't be lynched. But still likewise it is a excellent role for a Mafia to claim, so yeah do check whoever it is.

...I just saw that is basically what she said but oh well.

Several times I have encountered a lynchproof mafia in the games I've played so far, so I definitly wouldn't ignore the fact that Akuraito could possibly be a 1x lynchproof mafia. However, I do find Sputnik's persistence quite odd.

Originally Posted by Elysion

Several times I have encountered a lynchproof mafia in the games I've played so far, so I definitly wouldn't ignore the fact that Akuraito could possibly be a 1x lynchproof mafia.

i knew that bkmn would come back to haunt me someday

Originally Posted by Atomic

Besides, if Akuraito comes up mafia, Rio might too.

Ehm.... why?

Infinite Lynchproof on Scum would break the game, 1-Shot Lynchproof on the other hand could actually be Scum, but is usually Town-aligned. So yes, Akuraito is still a suspect, but so is everyone else - and Akuraito's role is generally Town-sided, so I am inclined to say Akuraito is, in fact, looking more clear at the moment than anyone else.

Just because someone's role could be mafia-aligned doesn't mean they are scum. Akuraito is not a top suspect at the moment and we really shouldn't waste all of our precious time in such a fast-paced game focusing all of our attention on the least-likely suspect.

Originally Posted by Rio Kamishiro

Ehm.... why?

Me coming up as mafia and you not wanting a check correlate if we were both mafia, although that's not really strong reasoning.

update pending