Thread: Pokemon Best Wishes! Mafia - ENDGAME! - VICTORY FOR TOWN AND INDEP 10/11/12!

I don't know, I still think Leavanny could be independent. She doesn't seem to care about the Town at all, and only for her own survival. Or, she could just be obvious mafia, I guess...?

Agreed on that point, but as I said before, I don't think an independent would be a lynch redirector... of course, it could be possible I guess.

either way she's not helping the town at all

Originally Posted by Rio Kamishiro

Agreed on that point, but as I said before, I don't think an independent would be a lynch redirector... of course, it could be possible I guess.

What?! I'm not an independent! I swear I'm town!

Originally Posted by Leavanny Duo

Originally Posted by Rio Kamishiro

Agreed on that point, but as I said before, I don't think an independent would be a lynch redirector... of course, it could be possible I guess.

What?! I'm not an independent! I swear I'm town!

;_;

Since you're relatively new to mafia games, I guess you could be desperate about your alignment and as it is much too early in the game there's no way to prove you're town - no one to vouch for you, and no actions in particular had been done, except for the lynch redirect you had.

A few months ago, I was new to mafia games, and I was more or less the same as you. Whenever I posted something people would say I was scummy and started picking me as a target - and I would panic over that. After several games, it became known as my playing style (bad habit of scummy postings regardless of alignment XDD). However, I did learn the hard way to not overreact when other players chose me as a target since nobody knows my alignment (except for the mafia), they would want to make sure I won't harm the town.

Of course, you could be a mafia pretending to panic, or an independent pretending to rage. Yet I'm leaning more towards that you are a rookie townie. However, remember that overreacting will only draw more attention to you and only after you are lynched/killed will people stop suspecting you.

Stay cool, play cool.

Normally someone would not be fully afraid of being and indep since they aren't usually a threat. Leavanny doesn't seem to understand that so I'm guessing she's mafia assuming wrong or a townie that really has no idea what she's doing.

My favorite rival is... *sniffle* Paul. XD

Leavanny doesn't seem like much of a team player in my eyes, and that's not exactly helping town very much regardless of alignment. Lynch redirector can go either way, so that doesn't give us much, but if nothing else comes up by the day phase (or during the day phase), I wouldn't be opposed to voting Leavanny.

She's obviously the one with the most indication to mafia. I would definitely not be opposed to vote her.

My favorite rival is Paul. : <

Leaveanny Duo is still very scummy in my eyes, in fact she got even scummier.

Even if she's not mafia, she's definitely not acting like she's town. Her behavior definitely does point to her being mafia. If not that, maybe she's independent. But I'll be very surprised if it turns out she's town.

Originally Posted by Atomic

Anyways, I'm going to assume Leavanny Duo's ability is one-shot, since NEVER being able to be lynched is a bit overpowered, especially if she's mafia. I've seen town-aligned redirectors before, but IIRC it usually isn't.

If it's one-shot: Probably mafia.

If it isn't: Almost certainly either Town or Independent. A lynchproof mafioso would be... unlikely, to say the least.

Either way, if she's Town she will inevitably be the Nightkill target eventually. The mafia won't risk trying to lynch her again.

I'm so confused about her actions, I don't know what she is... The cop should check her.

Originally Posted by Sputnik

I'm so confused about her actions, I don't know what she is... The cop should check her.

I disagree, the cop should spend their precious investigative time checking into someone whose role we don't already know (Leavanny's already used her redirect).

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by Sputnik

I'm so confused about her actions, I don't know what she is... The cop should check her.

I disagree, the cop should spend their precious investigative time checking into someone whose role we don't already know (Leavanny's already used her redirect).

I think Sputnik meant the cop should check Leavanny's alignment, not role. We all know Leavanny used her lynch redirect, but better safe than sorry.

But why should the cop check her? She seems to be the best lynch target for tomorrow, and it's not as if the cop will be able to contact someone with their result to confirm that she's a good choice or to stop her lynch; it'd just be a wasted check.