Thread: Oakwood Mafia [11-6-12] [ENDGAME - Town Victory!]

@VeloJello;
@Feralize;
@Hitomi;
@Akuraito;
@Rio Kamishiro;
@Ryoga Kamishiro;
@GliscorMan;
@Master Mew;
@Human;
@Laterose;
@Leavanny Duo;
@Elysion;

What do you guys think of FinalArcadia? :)

Honestly, I don't really have much of a judgement on FinalArcadia at the moment.

I've looked through her posts and I do agree with her statement that mass - claiming so early in the game isn't the best option. She also had another statement that I thought was quite interesting - that I also thought of as well.

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Mafia might've thought that you were bluffing on protecting Human or something. Or they don't believe your claim?

Of course the mafia's going to have doubts about you claiming doctor so early in the game. Therefore, I suppose, that's why they chose another target.

Well, I'm just going to jump in with the Ryogas sharks and take a risk. *shrug* I honestly don't think that FA's mafia. Her opinion on massclaiming--especially so early--is most definitely valid, even shared. So suspecting her on that...really doesn't work for me.

And then with you saying suddenly that you have proof that she's mafia... it seems more as if you were testing her for her reaction--helped by how much you had been trying to pressure her--not that you actually had any evidence, since withholding such essential information is just...not something you should do. Really, I don't see the point in doing so.

I'm certain that you'll call this buddying. *shrug* But it's my honest opinion, and I'm sure that's better than me lying.

Once I feel the absolute need to reveal the PM, I will. It will surprise the crap out of her, I know that for sure. XD

Hm, I haven't really formed an opinion on Arcadia's alignment. She hasn't done anything incredibly mafia like to me, but she doesn't seem really town either. So... At the moment, I don't know. Although I don't think Sputnik is lying about having some type of evidence, but I won't believe it until I actually see something.

I won't believe it until I see it with my own eyes. I can't fully trust anyone at this point.

Well that sucked.

And yes, FinalArcadia is suspicious. I find her mafioso..... Again.

Originally Posted by Leavanny Duo

Well that sucked.

And yes, FinalArcadia is suspicious. I find her mafioso..... Again.

Why do you find her scummy?

I will not role claim. You can call that scummy if you like, but it just isn't going to happen. For one, I don't trust Sputnik because there is no true confirmation of her role. Mafia didn't go after her, and I am not entirely sure why, unless they know something I don't. For another, mass claiming puts all of the power in the hands of one player, which I am uncomfortable with given this situation (especially this early in the game). And lastly, I don't like to role claim to anyone, ever.

Since the general consensus thus far (besides Leavanny, I guess) seems to be that mass-claiming is a terrible idea, FA isn't scummy so much as everyone who refuses to role claim.

Vote: Sputnik to cancel out her vote, until more evidence is procured.

Originally Posted by Leavanny Duo

And yes, FinalArcadia is suspicious. I find her mafioso..... Again.

What do you mean again?

What do you guys say about this?

That...doesn't totally convince me, really. It reminds me a lot of the fourth War Room mafia, actually, when she did the exact same thing in hopes of being able to manipulate the fakeclaimed independent into helping the town. ^^;

EDIT:

Wait, no. I'm stupid. Misread the PM. ><

Thing is, though, I mean... FA being so reckless like that...she knows that it's definitely possible that a player'll lie about being independent... so it just rubs me the wrong way, that she'd do that if she were mafia...

Still, though, uh... VOTE: FinalArcadia, I guess?

For the record, I already PM'd Sputnik telling her I knew who her ally was and a basic idea of her "evidence."

I was correct on the first count, and semi-ish on the second.

EDIT: Here's our PMs.

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Originally Posted by Sputnik

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Originally Posted by Sputnik

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Originally Posted by Sputnik

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Originally Posted by Sputnik

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

Hee hee, you won't surprise me, trust me.

I know exactly who your ally is, and I'm pretty sure I have a hunch as to your "evidence" as well.

Who is my ally, then?

P.S. Atomic has run out of room for PMs, just so you know.

That damn PM limit. XD We can send her the conversation once her box isn't full.

It's my dear Bulbahubby, correct?

Why, yes. He told me everything. XD

Did he also tell you how I refused to ally with him, because I didn't trust his independent claim?

Let me guess, he believes me to be mafia because I didn't want to work with him, and proceeded to provide some sort of "evidence" to "prove" that. And from the way you described it in-thread, I'm guessing he either fabricated a screenshot, or he simply made a quote thingy putting words in my mouth.

No, actually. Let me take a screencap of the PM he sent.

Oh boy, this should be good. XD

For the record, he approached me saying he was willing to work with mafia. I didn't want any part of that, knowing that he'd easily be able to toss me aside if he switched over to mafia.

That's not what he told me. XD ...Or showed me.

Then I don't know if you should be trusting him.

Case closed, FinalArcadia. Also, please tell us all of your fellow mafiosi. :)

Okay, so... Sputnik, it looks like you just outed Human to the Mafia against his wishes--not only his information, but his role and alignment as well?

I mean, if you are the doctor, then I guess you could protect him, but... really?

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

For the record, I already PM'd Sputnik telling her I knew who her ally was and a basic idea of her "evidence."

I was correct on the first count, and semi-ish on the second.

Please elaborate.

I just added the elaboration into my previous post, under the spoiler.