Mafia: Nameless Mafia - Endgame - Mafia Win [11-14] - Page 3

Page 3 of 17 FirstFirst 1234513 ... LastLast
Results 31 to 45 of 247
Like Tree7Likes

Thread: Nameless Mafia - Endgame - Mafia Win [11-14]

  1. #31
    カジカ Zima's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    Kansas
    Posts
    3,512
    Blog Entries
    118

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    With so few players and no information whatsoever, I Vote: No Lynch​.

  2. #32
    shsl music club member Catspring's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Gender
    Genderless
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    862
    Blog Entries
    8
    Add Catspring on Facebook
    Follow Catspring on Tumblr

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    And where will a no lynch get us, exactly?

  3. #33
    カジカ Zima's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    Kansas
    Posts
    3,512
    Blog Entries
    118

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    We don't know anything right now, and there are so few players that it would be a huge risk to vote anyone out yet.

  4. #34
    shsl music club member Catspring's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Gender
    Genderless
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    862
    Blog Entries
    8
    Add Catspring on Facebook
    Follow Catspring on Tumblr

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Okay, so let's sit around and do nothing and wait for the mafia to kill us all?

  5. #35
    カジカ Zima's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    Kansas
    Posts
    3,512
    Blog Entries
    118

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Why allow for two very possible townie deaths when we can only have one? But then again, we could possibly lynch a mafioso... It's unlikely, though.

  6. #36
    shsl music club member Catspring's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Gender
    Genderless
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    862
    Blog Entries
    8
    Add Catspring on Facebook
    Follow Catspring on Tumblr

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Okay, instantly voting no lynch will get us nowhere. If we lynch someone it'll at least get us information. Even if we just vote randomly and don't lynch anyone it'll give us something to analyze later. Right now I'm waiting for more people to join in the discussion before I place my vote.

  7. #37
    I am the Dragon Midorikawa's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    In fields of grey
    Posts
    10,630
    Blog Entries
    18

    Follow Midorikawa on Tumblr Visit Midorikawa's Youtube Channel

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Sound like me Atomic. Voting no lynch will get us no where. Voting gives information. Voting No lynch makes me think that you're afraid of being lynched and not afraid of being nightkilled because you're mafia. Of course that's only one possibility. You may just be a townie afraid of being lynched. Otherwise no lynch is getting us nowhere.

  8. #38
    Rock of Ages! Zenax's Avatar Forum Head
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    3,894
    Blog Entries
    79

    Follow Zenax on Tumblr

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Quote Originally Posted by Sputnik View Post
    We don't know anything right now, and there are so few players that it would be a huge risk to vote anyone out yet.
    You are saying this like day 1 implies that if the town decides to lynch someone, then it has to be done absolutely randomly with zero reasoning behind the bandwagon. That is not how lynches work. First, there has to be some game-related conversation going, and it can be done without voting no lynch because it's already useless in a game like this anyway. Once it has started, then the town can start to analyze posts and scumhunt from there. Accusations are thrown, people defend themselves, and reads are gotten on the other players. From that point on, everyone theoretically should start having their opinions on the other players and start deducing what their alignment might be. If they have a scumread on someone, then they can start pushing for their lynch, or at least try to pressure them in case their opinion could change. In a game like this, there has to be a general consensus on the person that will be lynched, so scenarios where players are lynched because of a stealth vote that stayed until the deadline don't even happen.

    Also, remember that day phases in this game last 3 real life days, so there's absolutely no point in rushing things or worry about eagerly voting someone out, because that would only set the town aback.

    Quote Originally Posted by Sputnik View Post
    Why allow for two very possible townie deaths when we can only have one? But then again, we could possibly lynch a mafioso... It's unlikely, though.
    There are no cops in this game, so letting a night phase pass before starting to actually play is pretty useless. The information gained from a night kill would be abysmally low if there was no discussion beforehand. Of course, it's possible that at the end of the day a townie will be lynched, but we're not in LyLo and it's not the end of the world if it happens; that's part of the game. With most likely two mafia, the town can afford two mislynches before falling in MyLo.

    tl;dr over. Can we now please drop the subject? Debating lynch vs. no lynch on Day 1 for the 982th time is not helping scumhunting.

  9. #39
    カジカ Zima's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    Kansas
    Posts
    3,512
    Blog Entries
    118

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Who do you want to vote for, Zenax?

  10. #40
    Rock of Ages! Zenax's Avatar Forum Head
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    3,894
    Blog Entries
    79

    Follow Zenax on Tumblr

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Voting for someone after I explained how we don't have to rush things would be pretty hypocritical, don't you think?

  11. #41
    カジカ Zima's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    Kansas
    Posts
    3,512
    Blog Entries
    118

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    I never said anything about voting along with you; all I asked was who you were going to vote for.

  12. #42
    I am the Dragon Midorikawa's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    In fields of grey
    Posts
    10,630
    Blog Entries
    18

    Follow Midorikawa on Tumblr Visit Midorikawa's Youtube Channel

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    What he's saying I think is that he's going to wait for more info before voting. Let's wait for others to post that haven't yet.

  13. #43
    Rock of Ages! Zenax's Avatar Forum Head
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    3,894
    Blog Entries
    79

    Follow Zenax on Tumblr

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Quote Originally Posted by Sputnik View Post
    I never said anything about voting along with you; all I asked was who you were going to vote for.
    I never said anything about you voting alongside me, either.

  14. #44
    TheMissingno.'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    No.
    Posts
    15,034
    Trophies
    Blog Entries
    408

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    Ah, I see we have the typical "no lynch" vs "random vote" argument that happens in almost every single game, followed by [Zenax, Phoenicks, Ryuutakeshi, etc.] explaining how mafia games are actually played. TheMissingno. was disappointed, but he was not surprised.

    Now Zenax, if you could indulge the thread further, please tell me why I shouldn't vote for you right now.
    That's nice.

  15. #45
    Hipsteeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeer Phoenicks's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    Cleveland, Ohio
    Posts
    4,509
    Blog Entries
    37

    Default Re: Nameless Mafia - Day 1 - Dawn of uncertainty [10-24]

    10 players alive. If we assume 3 mafia, that leaves 7 innocents. 2 mafia could be killed, giving 2 free nightkills. With 5 innocents left, there'd be 2.5 lynches, which rounds up to 3 -- one per mafioso. This sounds like too many on a vanilla setup. If we assume 1 mafia, that leaves 9 innocents, coming to 4.5 --> 5 lynches. Too high. Hence I am assuming 2 mafia. This leaves 8 innocents, 7 after the free nightkill, for 3.5 --> 4 lynches. Lynch 4 innocents and we lose. This is the likeliest possibility.

    Conclusion: Lynch 4 innocents and we lose.

    If we assume 2 mafiosi, then lynching today is statistically suboptimal. With 10 players, we have 8 by Day 2, 6 by Day 3, and 4 by Day 5 (2 players left is impossible with one mafioso). If by Day 3 there are 2 mafia (out of 6 players), then the game is in MYLO (Mislynch or Lose) -- lynching an innocent loses the game automatically. The same occurs if there is 1 mafioso (out of 4) on Day 5. Another way of putting it is that MYLO is when the town has 2 more players than the mafia. Lynching wrong turns to night, which lets the mafia kill to tie in numbers and win.

    LYLO (Lynch or Lose), in comparison, is when the town has 1 more player than the mafia. MYLO and LYLO are both "possibly the last phase". MYLO has one more innocent that LYLO -- meaning that the chance of lynching an innocent is higher in MYLO. The optimum result is only possible if there is at least one vote of "No Lynch".

    Conclusion: We should vote not to lynch at least once.

    As play progresses we have more data points about each player. Currently we're in the blind stage: we know next to nothing. A no lynch must occur at some point for optimal play. It makes the most sense to use it now -- extending the time different players interact. The more each player interacts, the more data we have when lynching begins in earnest.

    Conclusion: This is the best time to vote to not lynch.

    I will take responses now. Okay, I took them. Here's my rebuttal to a series of strawmen:

    "We need to lynch someone today to get information immediately!"

    Go read up about LYLO and MYLO. Now read this. Don't keep reading this sentence when you haven't understood what comes before it.

    If we do not lynch today, we will have more time before we come to our first lynch. There will still be just as many lynching days as there would be with a no lynch. Getting the information immediately confers almost no benefit; so what if we get that information slightly earlier?

    "We should lynch some other day besides Day 1."

    Day 1 is the best day to not lynch because it's the day least likely to produce a mafia lynch. Once we have the "information" that starts the lynching chain there will be no convincing the town to stop. "He's surely scum, we have to act NOW!" <-- Actual quotation from the future.

    "Why not save the no lynch for the final day when there are 3 townies and 1 mafioso?"

    LYLO is optimal for the town; MYLO optimal for the mafia. Because the chances of killing an innocent are greater, the mafia will prefer MYLO. It is in the mafia's best interest to not kill at all when killing would shrink the game from MYLO to LYLO.

    "What if the mafia decide to not kill after we no lynch so they can get to MYLO?"

    If my plan doesn't work out then we can always default to your plan with no harm done. If anything, that would hurt the mafia -- the more days the town has to discuss something, the closer we get to rooting them out.

    "Why haven't you advocated this policy before?"

    This is an entirely vanilla game. There are no surprises -- doctor protects, bomb kills, vigilantes, etc. -- to change the basic calculation of what is the most optimal behavior.

    "What if there are 3 mafia"

    Okay. Assume 7 innocents and 3 mafia. If we mislynched today we'd be at 5 innocents and 3 mafia tomorrow; the town would have 2 players more than the mafia, putting the game in MYLO. It's not about the number of mafia -- it's about the number of players the game has at start. With an even number, a no lynch is optimal.

    "What you're saying is optimal in theory, but what if lynching early gets more innocents confirmed or something? The usual way could work out better."

    If we're going to play "what if" with the future, I'd rather go with the path that gives us the highest chance of winning. Nothing that could happen if we (read: the rest of you) lynch today can be accounted for at present.

    "Phoenicks is arguing for a no lynch he's scum."

    Did you not try reading my post.

    "Phoenicks, you got the math wrong."

    No I didn't.

    "Phoenicks you're wrong."

    No I'm not.

    "Phoenicks."

    No.

    :P

    "Phoenicks why didn't you vote for No Lynch in your massive wallpost?"

    Because we have 3 days to lock in a No Lynch. 3 Days to discuss. I don't want this to end up like Zenax's Mini Mafia where bandwagons developed quickly. (Bandwagons are not often optimal either; that's another day's post.)

    Conclusion: We should vote to not lynch.

Page 3 of 17 FirstFirst 1234513 ... LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •