Thread: My Little Pony: Mafia is Magic - ENDGAME! Town, jda95, and Sputnik win!

psst I'm female

And honestly, the main reason I voted for Dark Blueberry is because they already had the majority of the votes and I find no-lynches to be a waste. I myself don't understand why exactly the lynch on DB started, I just didn't want there to be a no-lynch. Whether I'm mafia or not has nothing to do with it. It was the first day; there's no way to tell who's innocent and who's not unless someone is really obvious. Normally I vote to lynch someone not because there's a bandwagon, but because I actually think they are suspicious. The only time I follow a bandwagon just for the sake of it being a bandwagon is on day 1, never any other time.

Originally Posted by Insanish Danish

psst I'm female

And honestly, the main reason I voted for Dark Blueberry is because they already had the majority of the votes and I find no-lynches to be a waste. I myself don't understand why exactly the lynch on DB started, I just didn't want there to be a no-lynch. Whether I'm mafia or not has nothing to do with it. It was the first day; there's no way to tell who's innocent and who's not unless someone is really obvious. Normally I vote to lynch someone not because there's a bandwagon, but because I actually think they are suspicious. The only time I follow a bandwagon just for the sake of it being a bandwagon is on day 1, never any other time.

and why, pray, do u think this is a good idea

Originally Posted by Insanish Danish

psst I'm female

And honestly, the main reason I voted for Dark Blueberry is because they already had the majority of the votes and I find no-lynches to be a waste. I myself don't understand why exactly the lynch on DB started, I just didn't want there to be a no-lynch. Whether I'm mafia or not has nothing to do with it. It was the first day; there's no way to tell who's innocent and who's not unless someone is really obvious. Normally I vote to lynch someone not because there's a bandwagon, but because I actually think they are suspicious. The only time I follow a bandwagon just for the sake of it being a bandwagon is on day 1, never any other time.

"I don't know why a lynch started on this particular person but I'm going to enforce it anyway."

Day 1 lynches are worse than Day 1 nolynches because of the risk of getting a Town. It's just lazy to enforce one out of the blue like that with nothing. You lynched a Townie... what information did we get? What did we get that made us "progress"?

Honestly, it was pretty much set in motion that you guys were voting for Dark Blueberry because she was acting scummy towards you (the ones that originally voted for her before the said 'bandwagon'). We could've voted no lynch and nothing would've happened. So, it's like a double-edged sword. It just turns out that the sword came back and stabbed us.

Dark Blueberry would have been lynched anyway since they had the majority of the votes, so I don't know why my vote towards them is such a huge deal. If all the players who had votes were equal, I wouldn't have voted for any of them. It's true that I hate no-lynches, but I also don't want to just randomly pick someone to vote for just so we'll have a majority and therefore get a lynch. But since Dark Blueberry already had a majority of the votes, then what was the harm in adding one more to it?

Originally Posted by Insanish Danish

Dark Blueberry would have been lynched anyway since they had the majority of the votes, so I don't know why my vote towards them is such a huge deal. If all the players who had votes were equal, I wouldn't have voted for any of them. It's true that I hate no-lynches, but I also don't want to just randomly pick someone to vote for just so we'll have a majority and therefore get a lynch. But since Dark Blueberry already had a majority of the votes, then what was the harm in adding one more to it?

Not so much what was the harm, but, as you said DB would've been lynched anyway, what was the point? The point is, you're voting for the sake of voting, as if you're trying to say "Yup, look at me guys, I'm being active and not-suspicious." 'It was Day 1' is not an excuse for mindlessly bandwagoning.

Night fell, but most residents of Ponyville were still mingling out in the square. Many were staring at the spot where Lyra had once stood, the reality of her absence sinking in as the moon rose higher in the sky. Princess Celestia had retired to her quarters, a grim look on her face, and refused to speak to anypony until the morning.

“This is your fault!” one mare snapped at another. “You let this happen!”

“Me?”

“Yes, you! I never trusted you!”

“I just agreed with somepony else’s suspicions!”

“Why?”

The argument grew more and more heated as those who had initially suspected Lyra struggled to avoid becoming suspected themselves. In the commotion, nopony seemed to notice that one of Lyra’s accusers was absent from the crowd.

“Look out!”

The shouts of anger turned to shouts of alarm as a flowerpot plummeted from the sky. Ponies scrambled out from underneath it, but one little filly couldn’t quite get out of the way fast enough. “Quick! Get her to the hospital!” somepony ordered as two others began to pick her up. They rushed her over to Ponyville General Hospital, and for a while, the town was united, waiting with baited breath to know the little filly’s condition.

Finally, near dawn, the town wandered back towards the square. The filly would live, but she would have many long days of bedrest ahead of her. There was no way she’d be able to participate in this investigation anymore.

Dear Phoenicks,

You are Scootaloo!

Despite your feathers, you are most certainly not a chicken. You are always ready to try anything, especially if you think it will earn you your cutie mark. You are exceptionally stubborn, much to the annoyance of your two best friends, Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle, but you idolize Rainbow Dash and are always trying to emulate her. You were the first to stand up for Apple Bloom when she was being teased for being a “blank flank,” and this act led to the creation of the Cutie Mark Crusaders (CMC for short). Because you share such a close bond with your friends, you will know each other instantly, and will be able to use your clubhouse for private meetings.

You are allied with the Cutie Mark Crusaders; avoid getting banished or run out of town to win.

Hidden Ability:

Because of your stubborn nature, only your original vote per day phase will be counted. Also, because you look up to her so much, votes against Rainbow Dash count x0.5

Phoenicks was sent to the hospital and removed from the game. He was allied with the Cutie Mark Crusaders.

It is now Day 2. This phase will end at 10 p.m. Pacific time on Nov. 19th.

If that was a namekill, what does that say about your own skill level? :P

Good luck town, thanks for letting me play Feliciano. :D

Ok, guys, considering how well this worked in HGSS Mafia, I think it's fair to say having one of the masons claim right now would be beneficial? Anybody care to disagree?

EDIT: Woah woah woah. Wait a sec - unless I'm reading this wrong, looks like they're independent. Might not be the best solution then.

Yeah, looks like it is a group of three independent players (two now as Phoenix was killed). But if they do claim that might help us to narrow down the possible mafia suspects a little bit.

@KidBeano; That's a valid point. There's no real risk for them though, as neither faction would get much use from killing them. It'd at least keep us from wasting time on two players, don't you think?

On the other hand, stuff like the cop or, well, anyone claiming for them might be a horrible idea on the long run, if you catch my drift.

I don't think it's a good idea to trust the masons since they could easily side with the Mafia if they wanted to.

Originally Posted by Baron Dante

@KidBeano That's a valid point. There's no real risk for them though, as neither faction would get much use from killing them. It'd at least keep us from wasting time on two players, don't you think?

On the other hand, stuff like the cop or, well, anyone claiming for them might be a horrible idea on the long run, if you catch my drift.

sounds like ur trying to discourage finding these indeps... are u hiding something??????

and wHAT is with the obscurities

'if you catch my drift'

why are you not just saying things as u mean them??????? why can't u just BE CLEAR???????? why do u have to use all these strange things with multiple interpretations omfg

Originally Posted by Human

I don't think it's a good idea to trust the masons since they could easily side with the Mafia if they wanted to.

yawn i don't see the point in posting this

a little common sense would go a long way

but 'easily'??? would mafiosi really TRUST independents enough to side with them??? because siding with indeps is a double-edged sword, u know.............they could out u nd stuf...........u assuming that mafia would trust them says a lot about u.............................*glares*

So we know that there are two more indep masons in the CMC. Probably best just to leave them alone.

EDIT:

Originally Posted by Human

You lynched a Townie... what information did we get? What did we get that made us "progress"?

We got a FoS on a bunch of people who hopped on a bandwagon just to get a kill.

Originally Posted by Buoy

sounds like ur trying to discourage finding these indeps... are u hiding something??????

and wHAT is with the obscurities

'if you catch my drift'

why are you not just saying things as u mean them??????? why can't u just BE CLEAR???????? why do u have to use all these strange things with multiple interpretations omfg

...wat. No, I'm not saying that. Like, at all. I'm simply saying it'd be honestly a pretty horrible idea to, well, anyone, to claim for them. However, I fully support them coming out, so we can stop looking at them as potential Mafia for the time being.

And come on, there's NOTHING unclear here. Srsly, you are really grasping at straws here to find your "obscurities".