Yay town won. Congrats Mijz, and indeps, thanks for the help at the end.
@Feliciano; Are you going to do ratings?
Holy crap, no wonder we lost. Mijz's role is insane! I was not expecting that.
I think I've learned a valuable lesson from this: don't get too cocky. XD
Good game, guys! And Feliciano, thanks for hosting!
Guess Mijz was busy brewing up some poison.
Good game everypony! Congratulations to everypony who won :)
Thanks again for letting me play, Feliciano. This was a very stimulating game.
Oh wow. If I hadn't decided to active my ability the day I was lynched, the Mafia would have surely won. Good game Mafia! The Town performance was a bit weak at first, but got stronger in the end. The roles in this game were creative, albeit, a bit overpowered, but still fun! Great job hosting Feliciano! The Flavor Text was immense fun!
I will be doing ratings, but I'll be doing them tomorrow.
In the meantime, please leave some feedback! This was my first time hosting a game, so I'd love to know what everypony thought!
Good game, guys! Sorry to the mafia for not giving you the win this time, and well sorry to everyone for putting up with our constant alignment shifting. :P And thanks to Feli for letting me play, it really was super fun.
Ignoring the backstabbing independents...
Well done Town for pulling through, was a mistake on our part to assume Mijz had been revived with the same role. We thought of roleblock-killing him as well ):
Thanks for the game, Feli, even if my fakeclaim actually ended up being in the game. What are the chances, eh? xD
~The Artist Formerly Known As PichuBoy~
Um, wow. At one side I'm suspected for replying to votes, and at another end mafia were planning to kill me. x)
I didn't expect Mizzle to be revived with a different role, seems the role changed the course of the game a lot. :/
Something I noticed, were the masons Town-aligned? The game progressed despite mafia outnumbering the town, given that CMC were Independents and not Town.
Well I didn't sub in till pretty much the end, but it seemed you did good, minus the slight confusion about what day it was at the beginning that I saw.
Thanks to Feli for hosting and congrats to the rightful victors. You earned it, mafia.
After all, the indeps had to survive and the mafia was threatening them. Didn't want to ruin the chance at the fun of that. >:3
That was an awesome game. Mafia, I hope you have learned a valuable lesson about who to align with. XD
Both the mafia and the town were very active, which makes for a more fun-fulfilling game. Feli was great about answering questions, and she wouldn't let anyone be inactive for too long. She was pretty consistent with updating.
I thought that the original roles were very balanced. The hidden abilities were fun. It was when the roles were changed that things got unbalanced. For example, Mijz's role was way overpowered. One endless vigilante was balanced, but when a second was added late to the game, that was unfair. Four out of six mafia were nightkilled. That's a really unbalanced number. Things would have been much more fair if Mizzle hadn't been revived with a new role.
I thought it was really unfair how the mafia win condition changed. Our win condition was to equal the background ponies, which explicitly didn't include the independents. If you hadn't changed the rules, we would've won this game. I'm seriously upset by how things went. After we lynched Buoy, we should have won. We were equal with the town at that point. As far as I knew (at that point) our win condition was that we needed to equal the town in number, and after we lynched Buoy, we were going to win. That is the mafia team made the decision to ask the independents for their help. Of course we threatened to kill them if they didn't agree- although at that point I was convinced we were going to win because we were going to outnumber the town which was our original win condition.
However, congratulations to the town and the independents for winning. It was a good game, even if I decided that I'm not going to count it in my win/loss because I felt like it was unfair.
Which leads me to the question, why didn't you side with the mafia?
@jda95; I understand a bit better why you didn't side with us, but can you still explain it?
Just to add, Mijz said something about how we couldn't kill the Independents without losing - obviously, you counted towards their side, so by eliminating you, we could've won. It was foolish to think killing you was just an idle threat.
~The Artist Formerly Known As PichuBoy~
I have to agree with paperhorse in this one. The Mafía were just about to win and had done such a wonderful job, just to have it janked from them. It seems kinda unfair an biased to me.
But that's just me.
Winner of: Professor Layton Mafia, Warrior Cats Mafia, Kid Icarus Mafia, Star Wars Mafia,Legendary pokémon mafia, Make a Mafia, Smash Bros Mafia, Phoenix wright: Justice for all mafia and Eeveelution mafia
Other games won: Vigilantes, Trauma Center: Virus attack