Thread: Make-A-Mafia - ENDGAME: TOWN VICTORY [9/11/12]

@Buoy;

Would you mind claiming to me?

Yes, I would mind claiming to you. I've claimed to Croag, and I do have reason to distrust you that I've given to her, but am not releasing yet until Croag says I can/should.

Originally Posted by Buoy

Yes, I would mind claiming to you. I've claimed to Croag, and I do have reason to distrust you that I've given to her, but am not releasing yet until Croag says I can/should.

i'd like to hear of this reason

i mean

sure I've been inactive

but thanks to me, I've lynched the Captain :D

Originally Posted by Human

Originally Posted by Buoy

Yes, I would mind claiming to you. I've claimed to Croag, and I do have reason to distrust you that I've given to her, but am not releasing yet until Croag says I can/should.

i'd like to hear of this reason

i mean

sure I've been inactive

but thanks to me, I've lynched the Captain :D

you'll hear of it when it's appropriate and not a moment before, thanks

Originally Posted by Human

well...

he could have converted to the mafia and screwed us last minute

Thanks XD

GG guiys, and guess what? I FINISHED MY PAPER XD

I received an anonymous message saying there is a godfather in this game.

Not sure how the message sender would know that.

But, there you go.

If that is the case, then they would be in the innocent list and the "unsure list" composing of Human, Buoy and FinalArcadia is pretty much cleared.

Though take this with a pinch of salt imo.

Well, let's count.

There were originally 20 players in this game.

8 players remaining. (7 can vote).

of the dead:
2 were indeps
4 mafia so far (Including both traitors)
7 town so far

So that means that there is probably one more mafia. And if the godfather info is true, then the one we are looking for probably is in the innocents list. (...maybe).

Yes, that is what I assume. There would be no more than one mafia, which is why I said to only focus your attention on the innocent list as a pinch of salt; it might lead us of the trail. Which is why I need more claims, from people in the innocent list too, please.

Dear Elysion, you are a Vampire.

You are a supernatural being, a wonder amongst the town. However, should the town ever lynch you, you would stay alive and convert to the mafia’s faction. If you are targeted for any kind of kill, you will die as normal.

You are sided with the Town. To win, you must eliminate all threats.

Elysion, a member of the Town, has been killed.

---

It is now DAY 8. This phase will last for 48 hours and end Friday 8 November at 8:00pm GMT.

@Buoy @Ryoga Kamishiro @FinalArcadia @Akuraito @Elysion @Croag @Human @Neon Borealis

All those converting prospects. o.o

Sad we lost a town, but good we didn't lynch her.

Well, too bad. X3

Good luck, town! And...Mafia! :D Thanks for letting me play KidBeano!

Okay... 7 players left with one confirmed townie.

That leaves 6 of us as potential suspects.

mmm anonymous message saying that there was a godfather... but how could that person have gotten that info in the first place. Me thinks whoever sent that message is trying to divert attention to "cleared players" That way the last remaining mafia will have some more time.

I'm honestly thinking that Buoy is the last Mafia.

Vote: Buoy

And that he's the person who sent the anonymous message to Croag.

Why would the last Mafia kill Elysion? Oh that's right, to save themselves from suspicion. Elysion did vote for Buoy after all.

Why would the person that sent the anonymous message tell Croag of this? Why not via PM? Are they hiding something? How would they know as well? If they're not showing their faces, then they're not on our side.

Originally Posted by Human

I'm honestly thinking that Buoy is the last Mafia.

Vote: Buoy

And that he's the person who sent the anonymous message to Croag.

Why would the last Mafia kill Elysion? Oh that's right, to save themselves from suspicion. Elysion did vote for Buoy after all.

Why would the person that sent the anonymous message tell Croag of this? Why not via PM? Are they hiding something? How would they know as well? If they're not showing their faces, then they're not on our side.

your entire vote is based on wifom, i.e. "why WOULD somebody do xyz?"

who knows why or how anyone would do anything?

and you don't actually have any reason to believe that i sent any sort of message except you want to look like you have information. also, this might just burst your little 'i'm so clever' bubble, but i myself received an anonymous message at one point, stating that rio kamishiro was a serial killer. i'm personally willing to believe that this anonymous messenger is telling the truth about a godfather, since they were right about rio, at least.

Originally Posted by Buoy

Originally Posted by Human

I'm honestly thinking that Buoy is the last Mafia.

Vote: Buoy

And that he's the person who sent the anonymous message to Croag.

Why would the last Mafia kill Elysion? Oh that's right, to save themselves from suspicion. Elysion did vote for Buoy after all.

Why would the person that sent the anonymous message tell Croag of this? Why not via PM? Are they hiding something? How would they know as well? If they're not showing their faces, then they're not on our side.

your entire vote is based on wifom, i.e. "why WOULD somebody do xyz?"

who knows why or how anyone would do anything?

and you don't actually have any reason to believe that i sent any sort of message except you want to look like you have information. also, this might just burst your little 'i'm so clever' bubble, but i myself received an anonymous message at one point, stating that rio kamishiro was a serial killer. i'm personally willing to believe that this anonymous messenger is telling the truth about a godfather, since they were right about rio, at least.

I'd love to see both of what these anonymous messages had written on them. Have they told you how they gathered this information? And IIRC, wasn't Rio Kamishiro Nightkilled?

Again, the person that sent these anonymous messages has no reason to hide to Croag. If their aim was to help the Town by telling them of the Godfather being one of the people in the "maybe innocent" list, then why hide? They can only send PMs to other players only through this ability? Then why not tell Croag? The only 100% confirmed innocent?

Yeah, I'm not going to believe this anonymous messenger who isn't even willing to personally PM Croag.