Originally Posted by Phoenicks
Last night? I doubt that because 1) My role says nothing about stealing an ability 2) I wasn't told of your role until after the update.
-it doesn't well indicate town or scum but consider: in a game with 24 players and probably 5-7 mafia is there really going to be one mafiasos who needs to be lynched twice?
Seven mafia in a game that lets face it was obvious that it was going to have an indep or two? I doubt it. Five is most likely the max.
You said this already.
Harpy. The mafia now know that the first lynch on me will fail. You just told them who to nightkill.
You just said that you couldn't use it for day two so that would mean the lynch would not have failed. Then again this just can be used to prove you were lying.
DO YOU UNDERSTANF WHY DID NOT WANT YOU TO OUT MY ROLE. I AM NOW AS USEFUL TO TOWN AS A VANILLA.
Vanilla can do a lot especially in a no outside communications game.
The only use claiming my role for me has is supposedly to our me as scum -- but I'm not and the role doesn't prove I am. Because, again, it is way too early to reliably learn something from role claims.
No. No its not
If you want to be pro-town you need to be prepared to tell us what you are going to do with the rest of your ability and why we shouldn't ask a vig to shoot. So far, outing my role so you could have an easier time of it. Has. Not. Helped.
Well obviously I'm going to use it but I won't tell you on who.
Originally Posted by GliscorMan
This shows neutrality. In other words its a way to defend Phoenicks with being able to say he never saw him as town if Phoenicks turns up mafia.
Both Mijz and Harpy have self-defeating cases, as already pointed out by Nick.
How so because most of his case has been complaining about being targeted and saying how I'm anti-town for helping the town with my ability despite being an indep.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but Nick claims to not be able to use his power this phase, and in addition had to correct Mido about the role she supposedly took.
I will correct you for being wrong because he never corrected me on anything. His ability reflects votes back at their original users as I said.
I made a similar mistake once as a rolecop feigning cop. This whole thing is sounding more suspicious by the second.
Thats because you claimed someone as indep over town. Huge difference than those of us being honest about our roles.
Originally Posted by Dark Kyriaki
Anything else to say
Originally Posted by Nytie
WRONG!!!! Phoenicks had no choice and I'm so used to mafia killing me as indep that I don't care if they do.
I'm seeing more logic in Mijz's points than you guys are giving him credit for, though. The mafia would probably spare Harpy just for the fact that their win condition is "outnumber town" and if she is indep, then killing her doesn't count towards a win for them.
This has been said multiple times already