I'm actually really confused as to why people are voting Phoenicks.
I read your explanations so far. There's no solid facts, not a single thing. All meta and WIFOM. In addition, all the "reasoning" behind lynching Phoenicks smells of the "reasoning" which got Noivern lynched last phase. Every specific event cited by the people in the "Nick is Scum Party" are the same events which were/are leading me to the opinion that Nick is Town.