Harpy wanted to know why Buoy was so keen to hear Mijzelffan's opinion of her. It was a fair question since he seems intent on knowing. His response was pretty aggressive which never sits well with me. If you have nothing to hide, just calmly tell the truth or if it's dangerous to state the truth in thread, point that out. No need to go into attack mode. I'll be watching his actions closely, as well as Harpy's.
There really is no point mentioning somebody everytime you vote, especially if it's just so soon after a phase update. They are guaranteed to see your vote, and you do not have to defend yourself or even react to every single vote on you if there is nothing to defend if you feel like the vote was done for no reason. Mentioning a player is not 'common-courtesy', that practice has become common recently, but never used to be used. You should be expected to read the thread yourself, rather than being tagged every time, which make it seem much more desperate to get a response out of the voted player when usually it's much nicer to let them read it at their own pace and when they would like to, rather than being hounded to reply.
In response to Harpy's role revelation thing, I say that a nexus role could be either way. As the tracker died last night, and the cop died back in day one, having a nexus role as a mafia member would actually be a very powerful role, as they completely hide themselves away from alignment-finding roles. I don't really see a point of a town nexus, as all it could hide them from are doctor protects, cop checks (when they'd turn out innocent anyway), and a mafia rolecop which I guess would be useful. I'd like to say nexus is a mafia role, however I've seen it swing both ways so sorry I can't give a definite answer to that.
It's pretty dubious. Softclaim or not, I don't know. Doesn't sound like Nexus to me though. Might be wrong but kills are usually not included. I'm intrigued to know more. If you are saying that the role redirects the votes back on to the caster, then that would pretty much make the person lynch proof. When you put it like that, it definitely sounds scummy.Tell me does being able to redirect votes off yourself and back at the one who cast them sound like a mafia ability?
I'm with Buoy here. We haven't heard from Mijz yet, so keeping the pressure up is a must. Otherwise, we may not know for sure. Glossing over it is losing a vital chance for discussion regarding the lynch.
The way Harpy is jumping on Phoenicks is enough to say to me that my previous theory is wrong. Harpy and Nick couldn't possibly be on a maf team. That kind of tension can't really be faked.
Aside from that, to what they actually said. There's something really wrong about what Mido posted. There's nothing much that's really solid in her posts, aside from claiming to have knowledge about some sort of role in the game, and claiming to not be a rolecop at the same time. How that works? I can't even begin to guess. But every point she's made is subjective, and can be to mean how she took it or how Phoenicks took it. The fact that Mido's being so aggressive with her side, without considering Nick's side strikes me as wrong.
Now that I have your attention.
Is your feeling about Phoenicks rooted in a factual/circumstantial/evidential base or is it using the same reasoning that got Noivern lynched? While it'd be great, you don't necessarily need to answer this. Just keep it in mind while you two argue.
Credit to HikaruIzumi for the awesome avatar!
There wasn't even any attention on me before I voted Noivern, so I'm not sure what to say in defense to that theory either.
What specifically are you accusing me of?
Vote: J J M
I'd still rather lynch an inactive at this point, as nobody is seeming particularly scummy to me yet. This vote is subject to change, depending on what we find out over the next few days.
Originally Posted by Zima
"The inward skies of man will accompany him across any void upon which he ventures and will be with him to the end of time." -- Loren Eiseley
as it is
@Mijzelffan; thanks for ur reply. v helpful
Man is my opinion that important? Almost flattering. It's like you already know all you need about harpy and only want my opinion to get a better read on me. Allright let's play your game. While I didn't catch most of her arguments against phoenicks I think she's acting weirder than usual, claiming meta is essential to a game and such. Almost seems an act of desperation. As for her supposed scumslip, not sure about that one. Sometimes people think I slip up whenever I talk hypothetically too.
I don't think Phoenicks is that suspicious yet but you never know for certain with Phoenicks.