Thread: Loveless Mafia - Day 5 - 12/8/12

Nope. Our QT is pretty much empty. :/ He did say he was suspicious of Buoy, though.

It's like both sides have way more information than the average one of us knows about.

Originally Posted by Phoenicks

Vote: Buoy

I can not think of anyone else who would kill the guy intentionally acting scummy.

Intentionally acting scummy? You said yesterday that he was always suspicious, but not once did you say anything about him being intentionally suspicious, so how was I supposed to know that he was 'intentionally' being scummy? By the way, why would I kill him if he was acting scummy? It'd be better to score a mislynch, from a mafia point-of-view, than to kill a scummy person themselves.

Also, what Master Mew says. Are you just saying that because you think I'm the type of person who would do that or what?

Anyway, what would you guys think of a silencer claim? Mafia or not? They're most often mafia-aligned, so I'm just wondering how you guys would react if I outed a silencer.

Originally Posted by Buoy

Anyway, what would you guys think of a silencer claim? Mafia or not? They're most often mafia-aligned, so I'm just wondering how you guys would react if I outed a silencer.

I would have to say that I would think of them as mafia. Silencers really have no reason whatsoever to be town-aligned, considering that there isn't any scenario (that I, at least, can think of) where a townie would find it useful to use. There would really be no point for the mafia to kill a silencer, either, so the reward of revealing them and potentially hitting scum far outweighs the risk of outing them.

that is what i like to hear, akuraito, because i'm pretty sure nobody was goin 2 listen to me if i said that

u r verry gud thinkingperson

ok here goes:

HUMAN IS DA SILENCER!!!

Originally Posted by Buoy

that is what i like to hear, akuraito, because i'm pretty sure nobody was goin 2 listen to me if i said that

u r verry gud thinkingperson

um

thank you?

Also, um, one question: did Human claim with no prompting, or did you have to ask him?

Originally Posted by Akuraito

Originally Posted by Buoy

that is what i like to hear, akuraito, because i'm pretty sure nobody was goin 2 listen to me if i said that

u r verry gud thinkingperson

um

thank you?

Also, um, one question: did Human claim with no prompting, or did you have to ask him?

[30/11/2012 21:45:47] Buoy: do u have a night-action btw
[30/11/2012 21:46:00] Human: why do you care so much
[30/11/2012 21:46:04] Human: maybe i do
[30/11/2012 21:46:14] Buoy: because i am scouting for opinions
[30/11/2012 21:46:14] Human: do you have a night action???
[30/11/2012 21:46:26] Buoy: well if u won't give me a straight answer i won't give u one
[30/11/2012 21:46:34] Human: okay
[30/11/2012 21:46:36] Buoy: this is not a one-way street
[30/11/2012 21:46:36] Human: w/e
[30/11/2012 21:46:43] Human: could still be mafia
[30/11/2012 21:46:48] Human: but i'll take the risk
[30/11/2012 21:46:52] Human: Silencer here

i didn't specifically ask him for a roleclaim, just whether or not he had a night-action

yup i confirm that i am the silencer

Originally Posted by Buoy

Originally Posted by Phoenicks

Vote: Buoy

I can not think of anyone else who would kill the guy intentionally acting scummy.

Intentionally acting scummy? You said yesterday that he was always suspicious,

Almost everyone is almost always suspicious.

What I actually said:

[11/30/2012 4:15:42 PM] Buoy: it's okay i'm talking to him anyway
[11/30/2012 4:23:40 PM] Buoy: do u think hurristat is mafia
[11/30/2012 4:23:43 PM] Buoy: or
[11/30/2012 4:23:44 PM] Buoy: at least
[11/30/2012 4:23:45 PM] Buoy: suspicious?/
[11/30/2012 4:23:49 PM] Nick Murray: he's always suspicious
[11/30/2012 4:23:53 PM] Nick Murray: but i wouldn't lynch him

but not once did you say anything about him being intentionally suspicious,

He's always suspicious because he chooses to be that way. Also:

so how was I supposed to know that he was 'intentionally' being scummy?

Originally Posted by twinArmageddons

jda95; dude i am flaky as shit. i know. i am proclaiming it to the thread right here and right now.

Originally Posted by twinArmageddons

Buoy; It's because I'm mafia.

You were supposed to know by opening your eyes. That's a lame argument to hide behind.

By the way, why would I kill him if he was acting scummy? It'd be better to score a mislynch, from a mafia point-of-view, than to kill a scummy person themselves.

Buoy
[11/30/2012 4:24:32 PM] Nick Murray: you've got about as much of a chance of lynching him tomorrow
[11/30/2012 4:24:34 PM] Nick Murray: asd you do of me
[11/30/2012 4:25:57 PM] Buoy: why is that
[11/30/2012 4:26:19 PM] Nick Murray: i don't think you could pull it off
[11/30/2012 4:26:38 PM] Buoy: u underestimate me

You nightkilled him because you wouldn't've been able to lynch him and then turned that into a persuasive-sounding argument about why you wouldn't have killed him.

It also appears to me that as mafia you'd have a pretty good day target already since Human claimed silencer. If Human's not mafia then it's very likely that this is what you did.

Also, what Master Mew says. Are you just saying that because you think I'm the type of person who would do that or what?

I think that you would kill twinArmageddons on meta.

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

yup i confirm that i am the silencer

Did you silence anyone last night?

Nope. I was originally going to target twin, but after you and Buoy telling me not to, I decided that it was a bad idea.

5. @FinalArcadia;
7. @Booster Gold;
11. @CharAznable;
15. @jda95;

Please post to confirm that you have not been silenced.

I've not been silenced.

This wouldn't be the first time a town-aligned silencer has existed, if his claim is true. I don't think anyone with anything to hide like that would have the guts to claim a role like that.

That's a pretty strange role - personally this is the first time I've encountered that. I don't think Human would lie about having such a role though - its just way too risky to claim something like that, but...that's just me. ^^;

Originally Posted by Rio Kamishiro

This wouldn't be the first time a town-aligned silencer has existed, if his claim is true. I don't think anyone with anything to hide like that would have the guts to claim a role like that.

Which leads to a whole circle of WIFOM, really. I had asked Buoy about how he got his claim, since if he had been caught off-guard, it would've eliminated some of the WIFOM.

...Although it kinda just led to even more, so that didn't really help.