Thread: The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword Mafia [Game over. Town and Independents Win!]

I guess we'll have to see what's up after he provides us with some accurate screen shots. That's what most likely will help us right now, to see if he's lying or not. Not that it couldn't be forged, of course.

Originally Posted by Baron Dante

@Feralize; That's what I thought too, but honestly... how much use is it? Chances are he will die next night phase, and if he doesn't, he will be under major suspicion anyways. There's also the thing that if he is Mafia, Ryuu would most likely be too. So, it'd be an incredibly bad lie here.

I'm not sure what to think of this.

Actually, I would think that, assuming he's mafia, he'd be truthful about Ryuu's alignment (unless Ryuu is godfather). It wouldn't be worth the risk to lie about one of his teammates unless a cop check would prove them "town".

Maybe I'm just massively overthinking this.

Originally Posted by Feralize

Originally Posted by Baron Dante

@Feralize; That's what I thought too, but honestly... how much use is it? Chances are he will die next night phase, and if he doesn't, he will be under major suspicion anyways. There's also the thing that if he is Mafia, Ryuu would most likely be too. So, it'd be an incredibly bad lie here.

I'm not sure what to think of this.

Actually, I would think that, assuming he's mafia, he'd be truthful about Ryuu's alignment (unless Ryuu is godfather). It wouldn't be worth the risk to lie about one of his teammates unless a cop check would prove them "town".

Maybe I'm just massively overthinking this.

He did the same thing in Star Trek... Claimed 1x cop and said he got an innocent check on his scumbuddy... :/

@Feralize; Eh, I think it's more likely that people would assume that, and thus it'd be genius to claim them to be Town as well. Hence the Most Likely.

Originally Posted by NfiNity

Also, Exor, is the title supposed to be like an "arrow to the knee" joke? XD

Why yes, yes it is. :3

"I used to be alive, then I took an arrow to the chest."

Yeah, guys, there is no way that this makes GWS or Ryuu innocent. I'm not saying it makes either of them Mafia, but I'm not about to take either of them as definite innocents.

Anyway, sorry for my absence.

My prime suspect this time is Lithuania. Now I know lots of people have mentioned her vote switching, but I want to look at it in more detail than merely saying "flip flopping" or "wishy washy".

She starts off by pushing for a lynch and expressing the opinion that a no lynch would be stupid. It is only once the most votes are against her that she suddenly says that she agrees with Ryuu and we shouldn't NL because Mafioso rarely get killed on D1. Wanting to save yourself, fair enough, but I find this suspicious because she was not willing to be honest about the fact that she was throwing her vote in to save herself (as other players have been).

She then changes her principles again once Gliscorman is put on to the same number of votes as her. At this point she seems to forget that she ever said she was pro-NL, merely saying "I want a lynch" and throws a vote on for me.

Now, I can understand changing your opinion in order to save yourself, but I don't buy changing your basic principles of how you should play a Mafia game. To me this seems more like a Mafioso trying to get away with killing a random townie, but switching when she felt that she was personally at risk.

It may or may not be relevant that Gliscorman, her intended target and the person who started votes against her, died in the following night phase. It is of course highly plausible that this was done by a mafia that does not include Lithuania in order to heighten suspicion against her, so I'm not going to read too much into that.

At any rate, this is the highest amount of suspicion I have towards any player at this point in the game, so unless anything else comes up, I Vote: Lithuania.

There is also the chance that he is the fool.

Lith is a girl. v.v;

her intended target and the person who started votes against her,

I was the first voter for her, if I remember correctly.

Anyway... While I did notice that, I don't understand why that equals her being suspicious. I mean, sure, it's odd, but...that doesn't seem mafiaish to me. It's...kinda null for me. I'm not getting any opinions on whether she's town or mafia because of that.

That's definitely something to think about. I would like to wait and see her defense and if anything else comes up, but great observation, @Gastly's Mama;.

So @Lithuania;, anything to say?

I'd personally like to hear something from both @Lithuania; and @GengarWithSunglasses;.

Originally Posted by Belarus.

I was the first voter for her, if I remember correctly.

You were not the first voter for her, GliscorMan was. Later, Ryuutakeshi also voted for her. Even later, Gliscorman took his vote off. In fact, you did not vote for Lithuania at all throughout the entire phase. Your vote was against Gliscorman.

I'm night cop. I said it so when you guys say something lie: "GWS, we know you're lying!" "But I'm telling the truth!" Let's say I am, well you wouldn't believe I was cop if I didn't say it early enough. Even if the mafia kills me, there's always the chance I'm an independent... Or I'm just a random town guy.

Originally Posted by GengarWithSunglasses

(because my character is good at analyzing things LOL)

You're almost over the line. >:I

GWS, may we see some PMs of you rolechecking as proof?

Umm... How?