The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword Mafia [Game over. Town and Independents Win!]

@Mijzelffan; Though it was Ghirahim that caused it, he didn't kidnap him at that point though. Instead, she set off to the Temple. But that's beside the point.

But yeah, nevermind that. But y'know, there's a difference in following the story for flavor, and not doing that.

Because the flavor implied Zelda was kidnapped as opposed to what actually happened, it could've meant that either it was a mistake, or that Zelda might not be in the game because of what the flavor said. And it seems it was a mistake. Or something.

That was my point here, as opposed to nitpicking, which nobody would like from me when it comes to this franchise. Actually, I think I'd get lynched purely for doing that way too much. :P

Changed the title, sorry I was gone for so long.

@GliscorMan; is this your first game?

@Baron Dante;
Well, considering we can't name claim, I'm not sure how much it matters. Unless we end up speculating what roles could be in the game based off of characters.

As for lynch vs no lynch (not directed at you Baron Dante), I think we should try our best to find evidence and if towards the end of the phase we have nothing then maybe settle on a no lynch, but not so early in the phase.

I'm going out to dinner, but I shall be back later.

@Luminosity; Precisely that. Knowing roles allows us guesswork on what characters are in game which allows more guesswork on potential roles. Just by knowing Zelda is in the game we know one more character to guess on.

This is a game of information after all. ;) Even something that might not matter at all might come into play.

Why wouldn't Zelda be a character in a game based on Legend of Zelda?

That's beyond me, but you know, it was a matter of flavor text implying she would be kidnapped at the very start of the game, which could mean she isn't in it. I think it's settled now, no?

Sorry, I haven't been here all day. What's been happening? Anything important?

It's still Day 1. You can go read it if you want.

Alrighty, thanks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Joltik

@GliscorMan; is this your first game?

---

Oh ho ho, not at all. By the sounds of it, there's not much, if any, evidence for a lynch. Safest bet would be to no lynch, unless something turns up.

If we don't lynch someone, we'll give the Mafia the first move. We might as well try to lynch scum.

Everyone keeps having that mindset. But here's the thing. If we kill town that leaves two townies dead by day 2, as opposed to 1 if we don't kill them. Sometimes, it's best to spare a life on day 1.

There's still a chance that we can hit scum, though.

There's a chance, but after seeing what happened in YGOTAS, I'm a bit reluctant to vote yet. I don't want to get into another argument.