Thread: Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia III: The Mafia & Shendu Win!

>soulmaster, netto azure and aesti stick out
>vote hitomi instead

Makes perfect sense.

I know Bouysel...its cos I skimmed read them and maybe them three are still suspicious but I scrapped them because I feel more confident Hitomi is more likely to be it because I read them again..


Don't do this to me....I like pretending I'm clever

Originally Posted by Buoysel.

>soulmaster, netto azure and aesti stick out
>vote hitomi instead

Makes perfect sense.

precisely this
vote:Ma†erialGirl McQüeen

Demanding justifications that are already given for votes and throwing out as many names as possible to get people to FoS to deflect attention away from yourself and YOUR lack of justifications does not fool me one bit and makes you extremely suspicious.

Originally Posted by Aestivate

It was just by chance that it was PB this time and not Mizzle - whom I guess has proved his case enough for town. I don't like the justification for most of the votes on PB - "oh he followed a bandwagon blahblahablabh THEREFORE HE IS DEFINITELY MAFIA" even though it worked, it feels like a shot in the dark. The only one who I could even consider to actual have remote justification for votes on PichuBoy during his lynching is @Paperhorse but that is only because she is crazy and psychic. YES, it WORKED but ALL of your votes were votes towards PichuBoy were following a bandwagon... which was the justification over half of you had over voting him in the first place. The reasoning is circular, wouldn't you say? At least our justifications towards voting Mizzle actually had something attached to them.

So, in theory, there could still be mafia members lurking in the ones who voted PB - the reasoning is easy when it's just "hi i'm following a bandwagon don't mind me"

so wait are you saying you are sticking out for Pichuboy

What.....I was going to justify my reasons till I saw Hitomi's reason and decided that that made more sense. Are you not allowed to change your mind?

Also, I told everyone Mr F wasn't mafia when everyone thought he was...because of my VERY STRONG FEELING that I stil have but got roleblocked, therefore I'm contributing to the town more then you have.

Originally Posted by Ma†erialGirl McQüeen

What.....I was going to justify my reasons till I saw Hitomi's reason and decided that that made more sense. Are you not allowed to change your mind?

Also, I told everyone Mr F wasn't mafia when everyone thought he was...because of my VERY STRONG FEELING that I stil have but got roleblocked, therefore I'm contributing to the town more then you have.

You 'changed your mind' within six minutes of posting original suspicions. ._.

Originally Posted by Soulmaster

Originally Posted by Aestivate

It was just by chance that it was PB this time and not Mizzle - whom I guess has proved his case enough for town. I don't like the justification for most of the votes on PB - "oh he followed a bandwagon blahblahablabh THEREFORE HE IS DEFINITELY MAFIA" even though it worked, it feels like a shot in the dark. The only one who I could even consider to actual have remote justification for votes on PichuBoy during his lynching is @Paperhorse but that is only because she is crazy and psychic. YES, it WORKED but ALL of your votes were votes towards PichuBoy were following a bandwagon... which was the justification over half of you had over voting him in the first place. The reasoning is circular, wouldn't you say? At least our justifications towards voting Mizzle actually had something attached to them.

So, in theory, there could still be mafia members lurking in the ones who voted PB - the reasoning is easy when it's just "hi i'm following a bandwagon don't mind me"

so wait are you saying you are sticking out for Pichuboy

Not one bit. I said it was LUCKY that PichuBoy, a mafia member, was lynched but what if he were town? What then? If you were more astute with your interpretations, maybe you'd realize that "sticking up for pb" was the opposite of the commentary I was providing.

I was merely observing that it was a lucky shot, because there were no good justifications to vote him in the first place, just that people hopped on the bandwagon are not off the hook just because they voted for him. Voting for a mafia member doesn't automatically make you town when there are crappy reasons to vote for someone in the first place. Hopping on a bandwagon is much, much more telling. I am advising my fellow townies to be wary of people that voted PB and to not place false hopes in the wrong people just because "hey look guys, we got one."

This is a game without outside communication, after all.

Bye guys. it was a very fun game. I can't say Buoysel Aestivate anymore but it should be obvious now who to target...

Oh, fantastic. Now let us all follow what the dead person says, because he's obviously right. Especially after leading a mafia bandwagon!

Oh shit can I change my vote.....I noticed Hitomi actually voted for PichuBoy not Mizj.....fuck I'm such an idiot.

Well actually then new theory. I think you and Buoysel are mafia or partnered because you two have similar voting patterns and almost do what each other do on this game so

Unvote: Hitomi (sorry again I read MM's post wrong again)
Vote: Aestivate

Deflecting again, I see? ;]

I am very suspicious of you Aestivate so Vote:Aestivate

I like how your reinforcing your idea unlike me who admits I was wrong.

Ask anyone I tend to skim read a lot of things, and them quotes are confusing...theres like ten or something. So for now you and Bouysel seem to be fishy.

Originally Posted by Ma†erialGirl McQüeen

Oh shit can I change my vote.....I noticed Hitomi actually voted for PichuBoy not Mizj.....fuck I'm such an idiot.

Well actually then new theory. I think you and Buoysel are mafia or partnered because you two have similar voting patterns and almost do what each other do on this game so

Unvote: Hitomi (sorry again I read MM's post wrong again)
Vote: Aestivate

Calling out so many different people is not helping you right now. It makes you look really suspicious.

@Soulmaster
Care to elaborate on why you are suspicious of Aestivate?

And wow, the flavor text for Paco's death is so sad :(