>Proved my power role instantly.
There are only very specific power roles that could now be in a game this size. Why would you put yourself in even more danger from the mafia kill?
I was honestly suspicious of Zima there, but I guess she was just a townie.
Humandawn is acting weird, I'm not going to lie. But, thinking about it, he has two things going for him: being the second person to vote Buoy (that still counts for something), and the lack of a doctor counterclaim anywhere. The lack of a mafia kill on night one, according to Humandawn, was the result of the doctor (who at first claimed to be a JOAT) protecting him. Do we have any other explanation for this?
I wish the doctor could speak up without the obvious risk of being nightkilled. Then we could find out how truthful Humandawn is being. Too bad we don't have any confirmed town...
@HumanDawn; I really don't feel like quoting you over and over again, so I'm just going to respond.
1. When the convo between you, Midorikawa, and Akuraito leaked, it revealed that one of you was suspicious about me. I invited all three of you to contact me privately about these suspicions.
2. It's a pretty damn big "if" because you are arrogantly assuming that you're important enough to be protected over everyone else playing, even the doctor themselves. You are acting extremely suspicious, your claim about the protection still unproven and the story behind it now having changed three times, and brazenly announcing that you have a "power role" to attempt to further convince us of your importance to the town without giving any information about what the role actually is. If you feel so safe, why not publicly claim in full detail?
@Neosquid; The lack of a kill on night 1 can be attributed to the doctor or a role - as I previously speculated, the pictures indicated that they went after Rose, who's title as the Seer of Light could very logically include a one-time kill immunity. HumanDawn, seeing that there was no kill, immediately claimed that he had been the target and received protection. Neither the JOAT or the Doctor (whoever it really was) could safely counter his claim without revealing themselves - which might be why he now claims to know who the Doctor is.
3. You are not confirmed innocent, and therefore have absolutely no right to expect claims from anyone. Even if you were confirmed innocent, no one is under any kind of obligation to claim to you. The game does not revolve around you, and your arrogant behavior is doing nothing to help your claims of innocence.
4. Yes, as a matter of fact. If you could produce such proof, I'd love to see it, because right now, you're looking scummier than an infested swamp. I don't care if you put the second vote on Buoy on Day 1 - you are acting like a threat to the town, and I will continue to treat you as such until such proof is revealed.
END OF INTERMISSION 2:
Sburban Jungle | Homestuck
I see that you've taken an interest in my protege. Would you like to be introduced to her? She's quite fiesty. Hee hee.
Of course not, for a good host would never introduce the possibility of conflict between guests. And I'm the best host there is.
Instead, today our story will cover something much more interesting -- the story of the heir and th--
Ah, I can see that my protege is eager to introduce herself anyways. Very well, but we'll make this brief, for I have many other points of hospitality to attend to, and only unlimited time in which to do so.
Now, child, as you have been very naughty, I'm afraid that I will have to give you the stiffest of penalties. Hoo hoo.
@Nepeta Leijon; is being replaced by @Master Mew;.
THE PHASE ENDS AT 11 PM EST, 13 MARCH 2013. YOU HAVE 22 HOURS.
START OF ACT 3:
I've skimmed the thread and scoped out the general layout of the game up to this point. I've concluded that the primary event of the game thus far is still the Day 1 lynch - is this a fair assessment?
There seem to be two camps of thought on this topic - the camp that believes HumanDawn is mostly cleared by this event, and the camp that suspects conspiracy.
I lean heavily toward the former. I have a very hard time imagining scum-Human spearheading a lynch on his partner like that - read through the interactions between Human and Buoy and it becomes evident (to me) that Human was serious and Buoy was genuinely frustrated at what he perceived to be poor reasoning, rather than scum confused as to why his partner is lynching him.
Someone tell me why I'm wrong.
@twinArmageddons; or @Phoenicks; I'm pretty sure those are bits of a few separate conversations - could they possibly be separated a little more?
@Master Mew; HumanDawn claimed he received Doctor protection Night 1 (though he first claimed that it was the JOAT who protected him), where the images indicated that Rose (Froakie) was the intended target. Seeing as how I was wrong about Rose's role including a kill immunity, Froakie must have been the one who received protection Night 1. Since HumanDawn was now obviously not the target on Night 1, this presents three possibilities: HumanDawn did not receive any protection, HumanDawn received protection from the doctor while a JOAT protected Froakie, or HumanDawn actually was protected by the JOAT while the Doctor protected Froakie. My gut is telling me that HumanDawn lied about his protection in order to bait either the JOAT or the Doctor into claiming to him, since there was no way they could safely do so without exposing themselves.
As for his interactions with buoy on Day 1, I admit I have little in the way of a response. I also don't have a solid argument as to why, if HumanDawn was scum, the other mafiosi wouldn't have taken a more active hand in defending buoy in an attempt to stop a stupid move by their teammate. The only reason for that I can think of is sheer inactivity. I'm mainly getting scumreads off of his actions since then, since he appears to believe that he's now the most important person in the game and anyone who doesn't agree is suspicious. I remain far from convinced about his innocence, but either way, his arrogant and reckless behavior in believing that he is completely safe from harm is, IMO, harmful to the town.
Hm. Two revealed messages from me. I must have been more talkative than usual last night. But I suppose the cat's out of the bag now; game, you have my claim. Anyone who can is free to check me if they think I'm lying, and my invitation to those who still find me suspicious to contact me privately still stands.
EDIT: Interesting how Mijz speculates that Froakie and I are going to start voting for someone this phase, and then Froakie ends up dead.
Phoenix Wright: Trials & Tribulations ~ Examination (Allegro) Extended - YouTube
Phoenix Wright Allegro themes make me have so much more fun.
I have access to a QT where everything that is posted in it CAN NOT BE LEAKED. Now, why would a Mafia member have access to one? Wouldn't it be best if they used it for themselves? It's QT title is "Buries Session" by the way.
Here are the first 5 QT Posts:
When the Doctor saw what the host said, they said their full claim.
The QT was why I thought I had a mason.
There's a contradiction with your logic here. You came up with the theory that Rose was the one that was targeted through the FT somehow(how you did, I don't know), but you came up with a theory that it's because she has a kill immunity like Nightkill Immune for example, when the FT itself confirmed that it was through doctor protection with "Doctor".
Why did you claim to Neosquid(apparently) about being a one-shot doctor? He has literally done nothing that would count as "evidence" of being Town(I'm not saying I haven't ever done it). If you claimed to me, it's not like I would have asked for counterclaims or outed it. Especially a role that is really uncommon, unlike JOAT and Doctor. Although, with you saying that I'm being "scummier and scummier"(I don't know who else it could), I guess it's understandable, but I doubt it has any logic to it.
Now that it's out of the bag, could you please tell us how it works? I don't know how it does, as I've never been in a game with one, I think. I don't think I said that I found you to be suspicious.
Last edited by HumanDawn; 13th March 2013 at 10:12 AM.
So Mizzy is apparently the reporter, and Feli is apparently a one shot lynch doctor?
She didn't claim to me, I don't know who she claimed to. Also, I at first misread the post as "one shot doctor", which would help explain her huge suspicion towards you, but it's actually a one shot lynch doctor.Why did you claim to Neosquid(apparently) about being a one-shot doctor? He has literally done nothing that would count as "evidence" of being Town(I'm not saying I haven't ever done it). If you claimed to me, it's not like I would have asked for counterclaims or outed it. Especially a role that is really uncommon, unlike JOAT and Doctor. Although, with you saying that I'm being "scummier and scummier"(I don't know who else it could), I guess it's understandable, but I doubt it has any logic to it.
Neosquid, do you think that there are any characters that fit reporter that would be part of the Players? If there is, I'd say Mijz is fully clear, but he hasn't posted a report yet.
I meant to add more to my post, but then I got busy and just posted it, forgetting to fix it.
@Tailisu10; @Parma; @ectoBiologist;
You 3 haven't contributed to the game, posting your opinions on what has been happening(talisu has been a bit, actually) and your thoughts on others. I don't think Parma and ectobiologist have said a single thing in these past 5 phases especially outside of their "role confirm" post, which is making me wonder why they haven't been subbed out yet. Dark Blueberry and m0ckingbird20 actually can sub in for them, so what gives?
@HumanDawn; If I see a lynch about to happen, before the end of the Day phase I can send in a PM and stop that person from getting lynched. I can't protect myself from getting lynched, and I can only do this once. I claimed to Zima, by the way, before she went and got herself modkilled, in return for her claim.
My speculation on Rose's ability was completely valid, given the perimeters of her role in the comic. But since Froakie didn't die on Night 1, she must have received Doctor protection - which means you couldn't have.
How would it have been too risky for other mafiosi to defend buoy? It was Day 1, nobody knew anything about anybody. There was no real reason for them not to try and defend him, because what's the point of losing a teammate on Day 1, especially to what started as a randomvote?
EDIT: I think I know how to get the attention of the inactive people. It is a day phase, after all.
You haven't said a word since your (late) role confirmation. What gives?