Thread: Havendale Mafia 3 - Not All Hope Is Lost [Endgame]

I don't get it, he posted in thread that this is not his first game, and yet you keep saying that this is his first game =/

If it's still only his second or third game, that means he still doesn't really know how to play yet. Especially if this is his first game in a long time. He's still not suspicious to me at all.

Eh... I guess I can give it to him.:p

So... I guess the mafia makes the first move.

(I'm gonna die! :()

Okay well Stellar Gale is new, that's all fine and good. However, he is also not an idiot, and he was given ample opportunity to explain his actions and defend his innocence, which he chose not to take advantage of. I'm not particularly convinced that he's mafia, but for this reason he has earned my FoS.

Originally Posted by Feliciano

If it's still only his second or third game, that means he still doesn't really know how to play yet. Especially if this is his first game in a long time. He's still not suspicious to me at all.

Same here this is my second game in two years :I My first one was the very very first mafia ever.

wow, you were gone a long time. Welcome back to the war room :)

So... nighttime. Waiting for something to happen.

Shuckpluff, you're kinda gunning after a new player and it's starting to feel like you're just picking off the, if you're excuse the expression, easy targets. We don't know if Gale is mafia but your attempts at trying to keep the focus on him are... suspicious in nature.

So be it.

I actually find it likely that no mafia participated at all in what happened yesterday since so few people were actually involved.

Either way, whether you're new or not, I would think you should probably know to address requests for you to explain yourself, especially when there were multiple requests and you got a mention. It just seems like common sense to me.

*shrugs* He may not have gotten it.

yeah, you could be right. but that doesn't mean you are :p

Originally Posted by TheShuckpluff

Okay well Stellar Gale is new, that's all fine and good. However, he is also not an idiot, and he was given ample opportunity to explain his actions and defend his innocence, which he chose not to take advantage of. I'm not particularly convinced that he's mafia, but for this reason he has earned my FoS.

But the point a few of us seem to be trying to get across is that he's new, he doesn't know all the various things that make people look bad yet. Being suspicious of someone for doing something that they're probably not even aware of is wrong is actually somewhat cheap.

Originally Posted by Feralize

But the point a few of us seem to be trying to get across is that he's new, he doesn't know all the various things that make people look bad yet. Being suspicious of someone for doing something that they're probably not even aware of is wrong is actually somewhat cheap.

I understand what you guys are saying, but my point is why didn't he come back and explain himself even after being prompted to do so multiple times. Simple stuff.

I agree. No matter how new or anything somebody is, I don't understand how somebody could NOT come and defend himself.

Even somebody who hasn't played in a while would probably know that not defending himself would just come across as more suspicious.

Well, he said he wasn't going to be on today. He might be on tonight though. I'm not 100% sure.

And there's the trouble with saying that because he didn't defend himself he is suspicious. Haze has a life outside of this game. Frankly, if he doesn't come defend himself I'd say he just never saw it. Because he wasn't here.

Tried to post this earlier, but Bulbagarden went down right when I posted it:

He was on earlier, but he still hasn't said anything about this....

FoS:Stellar Gale

I think we've given him enough time to defend himself (I think someone mention him earlier, so he should have seen this), but you could be right Ryuu, he might just be too busy to focus on this right now, but I'm still suspicious.

Considering he has to study for final exams and if he doesn't pass, he might lose his internet...yeah, I think studying would be more important than being here.