Thread: Havendale Mafia 3 - Not All Hope Is Lost [Endgame]

I still think it's just too simple to vote for someone who is playing their first game. :/ I'm not letting my feelings get in the way honestly. xD

But yeah, at least let the new people last longer than one phase. Because what if he was an important role like cop or doctor?

Originally Posted by Scarlet Enchantress

I still think it's just too simple to vote for someone who is playing their first game. :/ I'm not letting my feelings get in the way honestly. xD

Well he could still come here to defend himself. There are still 5 hours left in the phase.

But yeah, at least let the new people last longer than one phase. Because what if he was an important role like cop or doctor?

What if he's mafia?

and if he's not mafia, I sure hope you guys feel like fools for going after him just because he's new. and because he has over 50,000 posts. :P

Because honestly, I don't see how he's mafia. People follow bandwagons all of the time and you don't go after them.

Originally Posted by Scarlet Enchantress

and if he's not mafia, I sure hope you guys feel like fools for going after him just because he's new. and because he has over 50,000 posts. :P

Lolwat? I didn't even know he was new until you said it.

I keep hearing that "what if" phrase thrown around a lot. Really, I'm not sure why. Everyone has an equal chance of being the doc or cop.

I'm not voting for him because he's new. I'm voting because he did try to start a bandwagon against shuckpluff in a... less than subtle fashion. I'm not playing biased, I swear.

And Octy, I'm not sure what you are getting at with that last one. People do go after others for starting and following bandwagons (usually the guy who started them). In day one if there is a huge amount of people who voted for the same guy, you can bet that at least some of them are mafia.

It was a joke. I was only trying to make light in this game. ^^;; and I know you aren't being biased so don't worry. xD

Maybe I'm just a little biased because he's a new player and I feel like new players should be given a chance to last past day 1. If he does turn out to be mafia, then feel free to go after me on Day 2.

Seriously though, Ryuu, I know you aren't being biased. I'm just pulling your leg about the 50,000 post thing.

Now THAT I was making a joke about.

We'll be right back with Missed That Joke right after these messages from the other players!

I was making a joke about your joke, but you missed the joke? I'm confused now.

I'm also confused about what to do at this point.

Originally Posted by Scarlet Enchantress

It was a joke. I was only trying to make light in this game. ^^;; and I know you aren't being biased so don't worry. xD

Maybe I'm just a little biased because he's a new player and I feel like new players should be given a chance to last past day 1. If he does turn out to be mafia, then feel free to go after me on Day 2.

Seriously though, Ryuu, I know you aren't being biased. I'm just pulling your leg about the 50,000 post thing.

I know what you're saying, new players first need to learn how to cope with pressure or else they'll never come back. I think he already has enough pressure of him, so I'll unvote. I really hate big wagons as they're usually hard to stop even if enough information clears the target.

Originally Posted by Ryuutakeshi

XD So, is Havendale 3 going to be come some kind of couple vs. couple reality show?

It's quite a shame that PichuBoy is just a sub because with him and buoy and Hitomi and I this would be perfect. :P

Anyways I do agree that Stellar's vote is interesting to say at least. It seems very mafia-ish vote like that as Ryu said "quietly slide in and start a bandwagon against someone while forming an alliance with the other player." However (if we assume he is not mafioso) I can understand why he would see TheShuckpluff kind of suspicious because Shuckpluff's playing style was quite aggressive. I'm going to hold my vote for now to see if Stellar has something else to say.

Originally Posted by Mr. Fahrenheit

Originally Posted by Ryuutakeshi

XD So, is Havendale 3 going to be come some kind of couple vs. couple reality show?

It's quite a shame that PichuBoy is just a sub because with him and buoy and Hitomi and I this would be perfect. :P

Anyways I do agree that Stellar's vote is interesting to say at least. It seems very mafia-ish vote like that as Ryu said "quietly slide in and start a bandwagon against someone while forming an alliance with the other player." However (if we assume he is not mafioso) I can understand why he would see TheShuckpluff kind of suspicious because Shuckpluff's playing style was quite aggressive. I'm going to hold my vote for now to see if Stellar has something else to say.

Which I sincerely hope he does. There are 4 votes against him out of 24 players and there are still 4 and a quarter hours left in the phase. It's far from decided, and there is a lot he can say.

@Stellar Gale;

Originally Posted by Fresa

I know what you're saying, new players first need to learn how to cope with pressure or else they'll never come back. I think he already has enough pressure of him, so I'll unvote. I really hate big wagons as they're usually hard to stop even if enough information clears the target.

Since my vote is the deciding vote right now, I'll Unvote as well.

I really don't want someone lynched without more info on them.

Current vote count:
TheShuckpluff - II
Stellar Gale - II

@Stellar Gale; is this your first game?

Vote: Mr. Fahrenheit

i'll take the vote off you if you tell me that you and hitomi are actually canon or not so i can acquiesce my shipper heart.
THIS INFORMATION IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN THE GAME OKAY GUYS

Originally Posted by Ryuutakeshi

I would kill the RNG if it gave Feli and I lovers or masons as our roles. :p

That happened once, remember? In the Assassin's Creed Mafia - you were Ezio and I was Ezio's lover, purely through RNG chance

Hm...I think I'm actually going to hold off on voting for now. I really can't see how anyone's being suspicious at the moment. Shuckpluff is being a little aggressive, but not overly so, and Stellar Gale hasn't really done anything suspicious. His behavior is pretty consistent with a first time player.

On a separate note, this thread should now officially be the "War Room Shipping Mafia" now. Sorry Zenax