Thread: Havendale Mafia 3 - Not All Hope Is Lost [Endgame]

Yes, you did bring Exor up. And you also said that that kind of stuff could be done in another thread, which it was. Also, you were an active part of that silliness too. So yes, I was making a comparison.

Technically, wouldn't that make him just as guilty?

If you are referring to TheShuckpluff, yes it would.

I think we need to settle down a bit. We don't want another fiasco (like with what happened in an unmentionable mafia game).

Anyway, I will admit that what happened earlier was a bit odd, but it's not enough to suspect people of being mafia yet.

Originally Posted by Hawkeye

Yes, you did bring Exor up. And you also said that that kind of stuff could be done in another thread, which it was. Also, you were an active part of that silliness too. So yes, I was making a comparison.

I don't see what your point is. I asked for Octy's and Jokool's opinions on the participants in yesterday's conversation. The only reason I said Exor's name was because he was the first one to post and I wanted to be clear that I was talking about the entire conversation.

Yes, but the fact you were a part of the whole conversation doesn't make you automatically cleared. It looks like you're just trying to draw attention away from yourself and putting attention on people who we don't have reason to be suspicious of to begin with. Ryuu and Feli don't strike me as being suspicious and if anything, their conversation was all in good spirits (meaning that they did it for fun). It's also possible that the two have a linking role, so maybe it's a part of their roles.

Vote: The Shuckpluff

Though my vote can easily change if we get more information/evidence.

I've read through all the posts for this day phase, and I just don't see what TheShuckpluff has done that is so suspicious.

He cast a vote because nobody else had, and doing so is a good way to get information by gauging peoples' reactions to the vote (or seeing if anybody simply bandwagons). And like he said, it seems like he only mentioned Exor by name because that would be an indicator of where the conversation in question started.

To me, it just seems like TheShuckpluff wanted everyone to get into serious game mode.

Originally Posted by Scarlet Enchantress

Yes, but the fact you were a part of the whole conversation doesn't make you automatically cleared. It looks like you're just trying to draw attention away from yourself and putting attention on people who we don't have reason to be suspicious of to begin with. Ryuu and Feli don't strike me as being suspicious and if anything, their conversation was all in good spirits (meaning that they did it for fun). It's also possible that the two have a linking role, so maybe it's a part of their roles.

Fair enough. No, I never claimed to be automatically cleared. I don't expect anyone to be automatically cleared because it's day one. That does not, however make me mafia.

I voted for Ryu, as I said before, because someone had to get the game started. I don't think he's mafia, but the evidence that I came up with is something, and something is always more than nothing. Voting for someone is a good way to start discussion, and random voting is really really lame.

That said, let's look at what happened as a result of my vote.

1) Ryu voted for me - Null read. He voted for me to balance my vote for him.

2) Octy voted for me - Null as well. You gave some explanation, and I'm sure you're annoyed with me for some of my posts earlier in thread.

3) Stellar voted for me - This one strikes me as a little bit interesting. He voted after Ryu had already voted, so it's possible that he was trying to initiate a wagon after Ryu's balance vote. He also offered no explanation, even after I asked for one.


Thoughts?

I doubt Zenax would do something as blatantly obvious as linking Ryuu's and Feli's roles together.

That would be like me linking PichuBoy and Buoy or linking Hitomi and Mr. Fahrenheit :3c

Originally Posted by TheShuckpluff

That said, let's look at what happened as a result of my vote.

1) Ryu voted for me - Null read. He voted for me to balance my vote for him.

2) Octy voted for me - Null as well. You gave some explanation, and I'm sure you're annoyed with me for some of my posts earlier in thread.

3) Stellar voted for me - This one strikes me as a little bit interesting. He voted after Ryu had already voted, so it's possible that he was trying to initiate a wagon after Ryu's balance vote. He also offered no explanation, even after I asked for one.


Thoughts?

It's a wagon, and I really don't like the reason behind it.

With that said, I'd like to Vote: Stellar Gale for now to try and balance things out.

I would kill the RNG if it gave Feli and I lovers or masons as our roles. :p

That being said, you're right about Haze's quite attempt at voting. It would like a mafia to quietly slide in and start a bandwagon against someone while forming an alliance with the other player.

So...

UNVOTE: Shuckpluff
VOTE: Stellar Gale

I'll show you 50,000 posts :P

How dare you vote for my boyfriend?! This is his first mafia game and his cherry has yet to be popped!

Honestly though, I still think that Shuckpluff is still suspicious. That's just my gut feeling.

Originally Posted by Ryuutakeshi

I would kill the RNG if it gave Feli and I lovers or masons as our roles. :p

That being said, you're right about Haze's quite attempt at voting. It would like a mafia to quietly slide in and start a bandwagon against someone while forming an alliance with the other player.

So...

UNVOTE: Shuckpluff
VOTE: Stellar Gale

I'll show you 50,000 posts :P

XD I wasn't going to unvote you because I wanted to balance yours out and I thought that you wouldn't be back until late tonight, but here you are, so...

UNVOTE: Ryuutakeshi
VOTE: Stellar Gale

XD So, is Havendale 3 going to be come some kind of couple vs. couple reality show? Cause we aren't supposed to be letting relationships impede our style of play :p

Nah, kidding.

Yeah, I don't leave for another few hours. Need to hang around until the mail gets in.

Haze, I'm sorry your first game didn't last that long.

I see I was mentioned.

Anyways, I don't like voting very much on day 1, so yeah.