Thread: Deserted Island Mafia: Game Over: Villagers Victory; Uncertain Ending

I thought sharing role PMs was a modkill in all Mafia games.

Two things: first, I'm role #6. Second, vote coolking.

Originally Posted by Clam Chowder

I thought sharing role PMs was a modkill in all Mafia games.

No. Most high-leveled mafia games allow the sharing of role pm's, and just expect the mafia to be very crafty in their fake claims. Go check smogon mafia games for instance.

Huh... I wake up and I have a gun to my head.

...

Sweet! People actually care about me in these games for once XD

Nah, it's okay if you guys really want to bandwagon me for living long in all the other games. Sounds stupid but... fine. If that'll make you happy. I'd rather prefer not being the first guy to die.

And yeah, I voted no lynch cause I thought that it would help. But I guess I was wrong. Mizzle is a confirmed innocent, as is Rayne (well, I'm believing him), so I won't be voting for them obviously.

Hmmm...

I'll figure out someone to vote for by day's end.

*drinks coconut juice*

Too much stuff goin' on. I pity Nick.

You know Rayne has never even hinted at himself being innocent, right? xD

By the way, shall I use my role on night 2? It would prevent nightkills again, but then again, the same for cop reports...

Actually, I was talking with Rayne last night. Decided to take a gamble and trust him.

For once he's not the roleblocker XD

Originally Posted by Ryuutakeshi

For once he's not the roleblocker XD

When was he a roleblocker? I don't remember him being a roleblocker.

lololol you have AMNESIA

Rayne the Roleblocker should always be the roleblocker role in any mafia from today onwards. Any.

Originally Posted by J J M

The less opportunities for the mafia to strike, the better. :P

You do know that it means less opportunities for night abilities, right?

The mafia is gonna win this game anyway, so it shouldn't matter much.

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

The mafia is gonna win this game anyway, so it shouldn't matter much.

What's the reasoning behind THAT?

This is my reasoning behind that:

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

Yes you can lynch me. But what then? We do not know if I'm innocent or mafia. We do not know wether person X didn't vote me because we're both mafia, or wether person Y started a bandwagon against me because he's mafia. We know nothing. All that's different from before is that now I'm dead, as opposed to alive. Normal strategy gets us nowhere in this game.

That's why I propose the only system that does work (Aside from cop reports), and you're trying to lynch me for it? Now that's not very effective now, is it?

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

Seriously, if innocents already start refusing to reveal their role, then we could just immideatly forfeit the game. Because if the innocents don't have to do it, the mafia don't have to do it, and then it'll all just stay with guesswork, which will eventually lead to manipulation by the mafia, and their victory.

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

But I guess it's hopeless. If nobody wants to reveal their role, then the game will be leaded by "gut feelings", voting people who don't follow bandwagons, and hopefully some cop reports, untill the cop dies. All untill the last innocent is down, the mafia wins, and we finally see what role people refused to reveal, and wether it was because they were mafia, or just afraid.

That strategy doesn't work in this game Umeko. Because if you keep quiet about it, then we won't know untill the end of the game, which gets us nowhere.

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

Posts? I can tell you guys I'm the cop, and let you kill random people. No one will ever find out I'm a liar.

I can point out everyone who is suspicious with their posts, but mafia can too, and no one will ever find out if an actual innocent or mafia was lynched.

I can use my gut feeling, but so can the mafia to point out everyone. Plus anyone who uses gut feelings to vote and determine suspiciousness should learn to use their brain.

For a moment I thought you'd say "Because the mafia won all the games here" or something like that. XP