Thread: Deserted Island Mafia: Game Over: Villagers Victory; Uncertain Ending

Originally Posted by Teh Shiny Drapion

Two things: first, I'm role #6.

Hmmmm numbers don't mean anything since Phoenicks went and removed numbers and shuffled the roles.

Role 6 is this...

In your former life, you were a cop. Before you jumped from the boat and swam to shore, you grabbed several weapons. You may use these once to kill a person of your choice at night. Be careful to not draw attention to yourself – if killed before you use your weapons, they will fall into your killer’s hands….

... which if it is you've just given the mafia a clue as to how to get an extra kill for one night. Though IIRC, that wasn't orignally number 6...

Mij was wrong anyway, there's a sure fire way to find out who the mafia are because we don't know the roles upon death. Why? Because now the mafia has no reason to vote for themselves and that's very telling. I mean, before, the mafia would vote for their own player because they knew that in case of a bandwagon, the role of their dead ally would be reveal and had they defended their fellow mafia, they woul have aroused suspicions. But that doesn't apply anymore, so the mafia won't vote for themselves, plus they have no incentive not to massively vote for the same person should one of them be on the chopping block. That, plus the player with the ability to check roles is working in our favor right now.

Though, it implies one thing people and it's that we need to vote during the day. Unless there's a cop report, bandwagoning leads nowhere since we need to be as diverse as possible with our votes, since by voting for someone, you automatically establish that you're not in an alliance with that person. The more you vote and for different people, the less people simply post once a day to bandwagon, the more precise of a mosaic we'll have at the end.

Here ended my thoughts, feel free to agree or disagree... vocally if possible so I can gather intel on you ;)

Originally Posted by coolking503

I'm trying to get that into our games. I gave a sample pm AND a pm formatting (which any future hosts can use, with credit). When you are mafia, fake claiming is half the fun.

I agree -- I'm trying to do it a different way. Faking a role PM is a rather formal proceedure that doesn't really get you anywhere. Once everybody knows that they can be faked, what's the point?

Also, Phoenicks, I can understand godkilling him for the screenshot, but at least add it to the fricken rules now. THe whole mafia customs thing is stupid, plain and simple.

I did. It's in my catch-all rule. The general 1-8 rules are for the rules of the game. The catch-all is for the typical customs that get posted everywhere. I don't need to say "Don't cheat". It's assumed.

And I don't understand what "mafia customs thing" is supposed to mean.

Originally Posted by coolking503

I would like to reserve a spot

Ya, I think not. You've got to get there, just like everyone else. (although I will be coming down hard on lurkers, and I'll be keeping a backup list)

Something has happened!

Night of the First Day:

You, watchingly with careful did the innocents vote in one, the other, and another way vote. Drama there was with here and there being accusations and everybody but one being suspect. So they lynched him out of spite.

And then you saw, and then they did, and then he was, the villagers affix coolking to rope and pull a lever so he dropped from a platform and died. To help his soul go to heaven, thoroughly killinged him did they: body of coolking was drowned and shot and run over and dropped from a helicopter – then the helicopter crashed into him so a hole openly sucked, pulled, dragged, and gravitied his body downwardly directing. Then the people mourned, for a helicopter would have been a great way to escape the island. And then you prayed and hoped that you had killed an innocent. And God (or was it Phoenicks?) smiled down.

Dawn of the Second Day:

You wake up in the morning feeling like P. Diddy. (Which was good, since he wasn’t stuck on the island.) Remembered then that you got drunk on the first day (because the deserted island has a huge bar) and that you should brush your teeth with a bottle of jack for good measure. Having discovered you not dead, and that all others got drunk too, everybody hungoverly decides to go to town and try to lynch somebody for being smart instead of unsmart, this time.

It is now Day 2. You may vote again.

The way the host of this game talks, makes me hate the living even more. See paragraph 1 of that post.

Hahahaha thats funny, they all got drunk, how are they going to pick the right person to lynch when drunk, i think that would be bad

Phoenicks, the Ke$ha reference is a bit worrying.

Nick, you should update the first page with the current status of the players...if that's okay in your game.

So... what now.
Back to square one but... with one less player.

Coolking, I will never understand why you gave up your role so quickly, but on the other hand. I don't even understand people all that well.

Thank god I didn't miss the night phase. Right, we need to keep the pervert, and try to vote off a mafia, who will we lynch?

HAHAhA, I am the first to understand the true meaning of the dead mechanics. Hopefully a mafia joins me here in hell.

Pokemad, the perv's gone.

Originally Posted by coolking503

HAHAhA, I am the first to understand the true meaning of the dead mechanics. Hopefully a mafia joins me here in hell.

For now, have fun talking with Mizzle. ;]

Why can't Phoenicks write the phases in a way we can understand?