Thread: Choose Your Flavor Mafia! ✧ 11/29/2012 ✧ GAME OVER (No Spoilers in the Title!)

Originally Posted by Rio Kamishiro

Does anyone think this whole situation seems a tad... set-up? I'm beginning to think this was the mafia's plan.

Let's assume both Buoy and Aelita are mafia.

What if hypothetically Buoy claimed cop in thread like that to bus his fellow mafioso, Aelita... in order to clear himself. He would then want the real cop, me, to check him the next phase and he would come up town... possibly because he's the godfather.

Aelita suddenly claims doctor to save herself from being lynched. Dark Blueberry comes forth and calls herself the real doctor... this situation is nearly identical to what happened to me and Buoy just a few hours ago. Does no one else think this seems orchestrated?

If that's the case, then we got two mafias on our hands. Even if we get nightkilled, the rest of the townies will know who to lynch

That makes a lot of sense, Rio. Are you suggesting this based off your many mafia-alignment experiences? XD

If it is true that we have 2 mafia, then we don't have many to lunch. If we can figure out who then this should be easy... right? D: *wonders if Voldemort is mafia*

Originally Posted by Aelita

sorry to rain on your parade but that was just the stupidest statement I have read so far, seriously guys; you're taking it to the next level

excuse me while I roll on the floor laughing

You already have six votes. And you are certainly not the doctor.

Bye-bye in advance

Yeah, looking into the game is totally silly. Claiming miller doctor isn't any less likely, no sirree.

Doesn't matter anyway, I don't think the votes will change. We'll all find out soon enough.

Wow, the activity has just EXPLODED in this game...

@Dark Blueberry
@TheMissingno.
@Scarlet Enchantress
@Aelita
@Soulmaster
@Rio Kamishiro
@Buoy
@Sputnik
@Mijzelffan

SOMETHING HAS HAPPENED

The Town had descended into chaos... Everyone began rapidly claiming what they had done the night before, all hoping to cast aside suspicions - but their claims were completely irreconcilable!

Even the Host, who had timidly reappeared to assess the situation, was no longer sure who was who.

Opening up his briefcase, Master Mew quickly hurled the accused's dossier into the Town Square (which was beginning to look more and more like a page out of Where's Waldo) just as the lynching had been decided, before diving behind a desk to see what would happen next...

Aelita, you are:

Ino Yamanaka (Naruto)



A chūnin-level kunoichi of Konohagakure's Yamanaka clan and a member of Team Asuma. Along with her team-mates, Ino makes up the new generation of Ino–Shika–Chō, just like their fathers were before them.

Additionally:

You are a Doctor. During each Night Phase, you can PM the Host and say Protect: Player and the player you specify will be immune to the Mafia Nightkill during that Night Phase.

You are allied with the Town. You will win when all members of the Mafia are eliminated.

Aelita has been lynched. She was allied with the Town.

It is now Night 2. Send in your Night Actions via PM to Master Mew by 11:59 P.M. U.S. CST on 11/21/2012.

SERIOUSLY?! ;_; NO WAIT THAT CAN'T BE - TWO DOCTORS IN A 10 PEOPLE GAME?!

FOS: Dark Blueberry

I don't think I need to explain why.

Originally Posted by Sputnik

FOS: Dark Blueberry

I don't think I need to explain why.

NO REALLY I SWEAR I'M THE DOCTOR AS WELL. I thought I was the only doctor and naturally thought Aelita was lying cuz there can't be two doctors in such a small game.

BUT THIS ;_; I'm really sorry - I have no defense but I SWEAR that I've got a doctor role.

I believe her. But why did Aelita lie about being a so-called "miller doctor" then..?

It wouldn't say on her role PM that she was a miller. Read it over again.

Huh? Okay. Oops, I forgot it wouldn't...

Cop, please check Dark Blueberry tonight. I'm pretty sure she's mafia, but do it just-in-case.

Being a miller isn't revealed to the miller, and, by extension, I guess it wouldn't be revealed upon death.

FoS: Dark Blueberry.
Hammering a doc claim was not a good idea, even if you are a doc, where there is still the same possibility of there being two docs as two cops.

I'm still going to check Rio, however: since I'm almost certain that Aelita was the miller, if Rio comes up guilty, then she's definitely mafioso. I find this post of hers particularly interesting:

Originally Posted by Rio Kamishiro

Does anyone think this whole situation seems a tad... set-up? I'm beginning to think this was the mafia's plan.

Let's assume both Buoy and Aelita are mafia.

What if hypothetically Buoy claimed cop in thread like that to bus his fellow mafioso, Aelita... in order to clear himself. He would then want the real cop, me, to check him the next phase and he would come up town... possibly because he's the godfather.

Aelita suddenly claims doctor to save herself from being lynched. Dark Blueberry comes forth and calls herself the real doctor... this situation is nearly identical to what happened to me and Buoy just a few hours ago. Does no one else think this seems orchestrated?

Let's see. Aelita turned out innocent, meaning she's the miller, which, by extension, means that my cop-check was true, which is more valid proof of me being the cop than what you have -- a "Soulmaster is an alignment that I'm not saying, even though I already did" check, in other words.

Let's treat this as though Aelita hasn't died yet.

I'm going to say that this theory can be also applied to you, although slightly different -- you COUNTERCLAIMED a cop, with an innocent on somebody. By counterclaiming me, you're going to create more difficulties than is necessary, and we did reach that agreement to check each other tonight and you agreed to it without qualms, "possibly because you're the godfather". That surprised me, to be honest -- your co-operation was unexpected, since you were stubbornly saying that I wasn't a cop, that I was lying, and that you wouldn't tell me anything, and then you turn around and agree with one of my plans. I grant that I was trying to negotiate, but that was quite a sudden change. By the way, tunnelling on a particular set of possibilities is quite scummy, in my eyes: there are multiple possibilities about the situation, but you're just taking the ones that will make me look somewhat suspicious.

However, the main thing is, Aelita flipped town and was telling the truth about her role. If this situation is truly 'nearly identical' to the situation that occurred between me and you, then you're basically admitting that I'm telling the truth about my role and that I'm town.

A simple "cop check" on me will tell all, will it not?