Thread: Choose Your Flavor Mafia! ✧ 11/29/2012 ✧ GAME OVER (No Spoilers in the Title!)

I don't know for sure, but Aelita's miller claim is really bothering me and making me feel more inclined to believe Dark Blueberry.

Is there anybody willing to believe there could be TWO doctors in a game with only ten players? It'll make the town way too overpowered if there were two people who could cast protection.

So @Aelita; you can't be the doctor when there's obviously someone else with that role

Originally Posted by Dark Blueberry

Is there anybody willing to believe there could be TWO doctors in a game with only ten players? It'll make the town way too overpowered if there were two people who could cast protection.

And the fact that there are apparently two cops unless Buoy is lying.

Originally Posted by Rio Kamishiro

Originally Posted by Dark Blueberry

Is there anybody willing to believe there could be TWO doctors in a game with only ten players? It'll make the town way too overpowered if there were two people who could cast protection.

And the fact that there are apparently two cops unless Buoy is lying.

So there's a chance he could really be the cop?

Originally Posted by Aelita

Hey guys, there's two scenarios here: bouy could be lying or I'm the miller. I'm certainly not mafia. This kind of sucks that I was out so early because now I feel like the only way to survive is claiming, anyways; I'm the doctor.

And this.

You sound like you're not even sure about your own role.
Vote vote vote

Originally Posted by Aelita

Originally Posted by Rio Kamishiro

Originally Posted by Dark Blueberry

Is there anybody willing to believe there could be TWO doctors in a game with only ten players? It'll make the town way too overpowered if there were two people who could cast protection.

And the fact that there are apparently two cops unless Buoy is lying.

So there's a chance he could really be the cop?

Maybe. I just find it unlikely there are two cops in the game.

Especially considering this game's size... I don't know who to believe anymore...

The reason why there can't be two doctors in this game is because of the mafia:town ratio. Most likely there are three mafias at the most, and if there are two confirmed docs, all they need to do is keep casting protection on themselves while lynching other people. This will make the game one-sided if the cop helps. There isn't a Strongman in this game, so the docs will be near impossible to kill.

Now, two cops...I dunno. It seems highly unlikely as well but more possible than two docs.

Originally Posted by Dark Blueberry

The reason why there can't be two doctors in this game is because of the mafia:town ratio. Most likely there are three mafias at the most, and if there are two confirmed docs, all they need to do is keep casting protection on themselves while lynching other people. This will make the game one-sided if the cop helps. There isn't a Strongman in this game, so the docs will be near impossible to kill.

Now, two cops...I dunno. It seems highly unlikely as well but more possible than two docs.

there are no two doctors, just one! And that is me you filthy scum

Originally Posted by Aelita

Originally Posted by Dark Blueberry

The reason why there can't be two doctors in this game is because of the mafia:town ratio. Most likely there are three mafias at the most, and if there are two confirmed docs, all they need to do is keep casting protection on themselves while lynching other people. This will make the game one-sided if the cop helps. There isn't a Strongman in this game, so the docs will be near impossible to kill.

Now, two cops...I dunno. It seems highly unlikely as well but more possible than two docs.

there are no two doctors, just one! And that is me you filthy scum

Don't call me scum XDD you're not the doctor :P also, the two cops already planned on lynching you for being miller before you claimed doc

I thought Buoy checked her and said she was miller. I didn't think she claimed anything aside from doctor... or am I missing something? O-o

Originally Posted by Scarlet Enchantress

I thought Buoy checked her and said she was miller. I didn't think she claimed anything aside from doctor... or am I missing something? O-o

Aelita didn't claim, but she didn't say she wasn't the miller either

But she never said she was either. So, she could still be telling the truth.

Does anyone think this whole situation seems a tad... set-up? I'm beginning to think this was the mafia's plan.

Let's assume both Buoy and Aelita are mafia.

What if hypothetically Buoy claimed cop in thread like that to bus his fellow mafioso, Aelita... in order to clear himself. He would then want the real cop, me, to check him the next phase and he would come up town... possibly because he's the godfather.

Aelita suddenly claims doctor to save herself from being lynched. Dark Blueberry comes forth and calls herself the real doctor... this situation is nearly identical to what happened to me and Buoy just a few hours ago. Does no one else think this seems orchestrated?