Thread: BrockBack Mafia -{15/03}- END GAME! MAFIA AND KARAMAZOV WIN

Vote Hellion

He could just be claiming his role, because from my knowledge it hasn't proven that what he claimed is true. I don't trust it, along with the fact that he doesn't care who gets out as long as he survives.

Originally Posted by Baron Dante

Well, if this was a succesful doctor, s/he could contact Derpx3 on who was protected. I suppose knowing who it was could give us some leads.

A doctor, you say? Fun fact: Brock left the show to study and one day become a Pokemon Doctor. OBVIOUSLY Brock is keeping us alive so he can toy with us.

I need your votes. :3c

Originally Posted by Karamazov

Originally Posted by Baron Dante

Well, if this was a succesful doctor, s/he could contact Derpx3 on who was protected. I suppose knowing who it was could give us some leads.

A doctor, you say? Fun fact: Brock left the show to study and one day become a Pokemon Doctor. OBVIOUSLY Brock is keeping us alive so he can toy with us.

Yeah, that's probably not what happened :P

From the flavor text, it seems like whoever was targetted had some kind of night kill evasion ability.

@Coasting Wingull I don't know, I think @Hellion is telling the truth. Why else would be he showing us what the mafia is doing? Especially if he's an independent like he claims to be. I think his story checks out. His only motive is to survive and has a useful skill.

Vote: @Karamazov He just seems...suspicious :3C

Vote: Hellion

I agree with Coasting Wingull, he's an independent and he would do anything just to survive and win this game. Who's to say he can't form an alliance with mafia? Who's to say he won't give us false information?

@Tsutarja: To be fair, he said that he will simply post anything he "hears". This allows the Mafia to attempt to create false information to go with. (Granted, it depends if it's just random posts, or if there is some kind of logic behind the choosing... if there is a logic on how the posts are chosen, and the Mafia finds this out, they can completely manipulate the posts that come through)

I'd say that we'd rather let Hellion go on for now, and if it really starts to seem suspicious, (As in, no information dropped seems to help us), we lynch him. Just... let's make sure we have a certain amount of doubt at them not being true.

@Baron Dante

I'm just saying, I'd rather have an independent lynched rather than accidentally lynch an innocent.

Vote: Hellion

Hellion has said not lynching wont help him win, he claims his only objective is survival, meaning he's a threat to the town as well as the mafia. He shown he will vote to lynch townies. Yes he claims he can "hear" the mafia and true the mafia may be posting fake info for him to hear, but Id rather play it safe as independents can be threats as well as Mafia. Then again, how do we know he isnt making this ability up, he could be faking this whole thing. Sorry, but I dont trust Hellion.

Originally Posted by Highway Unicorn

Vote: @Karamazov He just seems...suspicious :3C

Everyone finds me suspicious.

Vote: Highway Unicorn

Nice of you to randomly post a vote for me. I find that suspicious. A scientist would never jump the gun on an assumption alone; they'd be doing experiments and such with their cute assistant in order to come up with a more concrete and logical conclusion. And since you're not acting like a scientist (where's your perky female partner?), I think you are part of the mafia.

Originally Posted by Karamazov

Nice of you to randomly post a vote for me. I find that suspicious. A scientist would never jump the gun on an assumption alone; they'd be doing experiments and such with their cute assistant in order to come up with a more concrete and logical conclusion. And since you're not acting like a scientist (where's your perky female partner?), I think you are part of the mafia.

Kinda hypocritical seeing this come from you as you voted me for no good reason. And after asking you how come I confused you, you said that you don't think, but that you merely act. Follow your own advice? :/

@Karamazov I'm not a scientist, just a fan of their work :3C Therefore, no, I didn't use any science to determine anything. And neither did you, apparently :3

Originally Posted by Coasting Wingull

I don't trust it, along with the fact that he doesn't care who gets out as long as he survives.

So you're willing to cut off one of the town's only sources of information? Also, it's true that I don't care who dies, I go with the bandwagon. The players themselves make the decision as to who dies. Right now, it's illogical for you to go after an innocent since it A- Means you waste another lynch on someone who's not a mafia and B- You lose a potential vote against the mafia next day phase, which in a tight vote could help the town.

It's interesting to me that you're doing that when the heat was on @Karamazov... same for @Shiny Celebi. Gee I wonder which group of players all work together and try to protect one another. It was a long time ago since we both played as mafia, but I remember your style Coasting Wingull and this reeks of it.

Vote: Karamazov

@Tsutarja: Well, true. However, as Hellion just said, he is one of the towns only way of getting information. Even if some/all of the info is false, it's at least something.

On the other hand, if there is no pattern to how the information is taken from Mafia, there's no reliable way to fake information. At that point, there's no way the mafia will let Hellion live. So, if yo uask me, let Hellion live for now. If he isn't killed by the Mafia in a decent amount of time, we can assume him being Mafia and kill him.

This way, if the Mafia wants to kill him, it's one less innocent killed by them, which I'd say is better than one innocent killed by lynch.

@Karamazov: You are always guilty. That's why you are also always innocent.

Yo, peoplez, PM me :P

Hmmmm...it freakin' sucks that the cop was taken out so early. While Karamazov is being odd, he is always being odd, so that doesn't give us any indication of his alignment.

@Baron Dante
Do you have a better idea on who to lynch than Hellion?