Thread: Bionicle Mask of Mafia-Day 10- Reign of shadows. ENDGAME. Mafia victory!!!

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

... Attest?

You were tracked.

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

... Attest?

You were tracked.

Cool. So does this make it highly likely that I'm Town?

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

Cool. So does this make it highly likely that I'm Town?

You almost certainly killed GliscorMan (the odds of any role other than a killing role visiting him that same night are low).

You are likely Town (I wouldn't use the word "highly" but that's quibbling), but Serial Killer is also possible, of course.

Did you also kill Dark Blueberry?

Originally Posted by Fynx

Oh dear, just when I was typing a post. x)
@Paperhorse; the same reason you were quiet :P

I'm bothered about this one though-

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by Orion

Vote: VeloJello

For being the last to confirm :I

I like that you're willing to take someone to two votes - I don't like that you basically copy/pasted Midorikawa's reasoning, however.

For my part in this wretched Day 1 tradition, I shall:

Vote: GliscorMan

Reason: I want to see if he unvotes.

The situation is that VeloJello had gained two votes, and Master Mew's vote in this post made it a tie.

to Master Mew: Your suspicions were elsewhere - for example, Orion for basically copying another player's reasons for voting. Not on GliscorMan (as I read by your wording 'wretched Day 1 tradition', doesn't look like a serious accusation to me). Why not place a vote for those that you actually suspect? Were you trying to defend someone?

Funny, MM said this to me and I believe jokool for not voting who we most suspected at the moment on day one.

Originally Posted by Fynx

Buoy's kill can't be Dark Blueberry's. If she landed the kill, the information wouldn't have been revealed. Seems we have a vigilante.

Originally Posted by Fynx

VOTE: Midorikawa

From what I've read in the thread, seem the most suspicious.

Reasons?

Wow three posts through the game. Did I miss their other ones somewhere or is this literally all they posted? Not much help to town.

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

I'm sorry but I find it hilarious that Doctor jokool was the doctor

As for suspicions...I got nothing

Nothing? Really?

Originally Posted by Zima

Huh. I was roleblocked last night. It's a real shame I'm practically useless. :P

now why would anybody roleblock you?

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by Momoka

So, any suspicions we have right now?

I still think @Midorikawa scumslipped in this post when she said she didn't think Zima "could be saved" - indicating she knew Zima would flip Town. It's possible that she just genuinely expected Zima to flip Town, except that when I asked her about it she said she had no opinion on Zima's alignment.

Vote: Midorikawa

I don't see how that's a scumtell...

Originally Posted by FinalArcadia

I'm going to go back through the events of Day and Night 3 to see what can be gathered from those posts, but I will bring this up:

Callisto hasn't posted since January 18th. And considering that jda95 was subbed out for inactivity, it's not as though such things aren't being looked at by the hosts. It's been about five phases (I think this counts as the sixth, though I'm mathematically challenged) since he's said anything in-thread, which is both not very constructive, but also worrying. Worrying because he hasn't received a public prodding like, say, Smasher did before subbing out, so something is happening behind the scenes.

Whether it's in a mafia QT or in PMs or something, I'm not sure, but it's highly possible Callisto could be communicating with scumbuddies while staying quiet here.

VOTE: Callisto

Hopefully this will involve you in the discussions, @Callisto, since you've not done much for town's scumhunting, from what I can tell.

She hasn't viewed the thread at all.

Originally Posted by Zima

Personally, I'm suspicious of HumanDawn because he literally started asking for claims for no reason. He may have stated that he wasn't confirmed and it was optional, but his main reason behind it was to see what roles exist, and that doesn't sit well with me, also considering that we just lost the doctor.

Well, I would have liked to know their claims. I didn't ask Doctor Jokool for a claim.

Originally Posted by Paperhorse

Vote: Midorikawa

I find her suspicious too, especially how she brushed off the possibility of Zima being silenced.

How was that suspicious?

Originally Posted by Fynx

VOTE: Midorikawa

From what I've read in the thread, seem the most suspicious.

And nothing that was said on her was actually "suspicious".

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

... Attest?

You were tracked.

Why would you claim of being a Tracker out loud in the open?

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

Cool. So does this make it highly likely that I'm Town?

You almost certainly killed GliscorMan (the odds of any role other than a killing role visiting him that same night are low).

You are likely Town (I wouldn't use the word "highly" but that's quibbling), but Serial Killer is also possible, of course.

Did you also kill Dark Blueberry?

Nope. Didn't kill her. Serial Killer? Bringing myself that much attention?

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Originally Posted by Fynx

Oh dear, just when I was typing a post. x)
@Paperhorse; the same reason you were quiet :P

I'm bothered about this one though-

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by Orion

Vote: VeloJello

For being the last to confirm :I

I like that you're willing to take someone to two votes - I don't like that you basically copy/pasted Midorikawa's reasoning, however.

For my part in this wretched Day 1 tradition, I shall:

Vote: GliscorMan

Reason: I want to see if he unvotes.

The situation is that VeloJello had gained two votes, and Master Mew's vote in this post made it a tie.

to Master Mew: Your suspicions were elsewhere - for example, Orion for basically copying another player's reasons for voting. Not on GliscorMan (as I read by your wording 'wretched Day 1 tradition', doesn't look like a serious accusation to me). Why not place a vote for those that you actually suspect? Were you trying to defend someone?

Funny, MM said this to me and I believe jokool for not voting who we most suspected at the moment on day one.

Originally Posted by Fynx

Buoy's kill can't be Dark Blueberry's. If she landed the kill, the information wouldn't have been revealed. Seems we have a vigilante.

Originally Posted by Fynx

VOTE: Midorikawa

From what I've read in the thread, seem the most suspicious.

Reasons?

Wow three posts through the game. Did I miss their other ones somewhere or is this literally all they posted? Not much help to town.

"the same reason you were quiet"

Gonna bluff this one and say they're scumbuddies. like hell i'd even consider that it was to avoid joke voting!!!

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

Why would you claim of being a Tracker out loud in the open?

I didn't. I said you were tracked. There's a distinction.

That aside, Tracker is a weak investigative role. Claiming it wouldn't be dangerous if I were.

Why did you claim Vigilante in the open?

Originally Posted by Master Mew

Originally Posted by HumanDawn

Why would you claim of being a Tracker out loud in the open?

I didn't. I said you were tracked. There's a distinction.

That aside, Tracker is a weak investigative role. Claiming it wouldn't be dangerous if I were.

Why did you claim Vigilante in the open?

It's not dangerous to claim Vigilante out in the open once used.

Midori seeming to know Zima's alignment definitely is odd; with Zima not flipping as a mason, it outs that possibility. The only other town-aligned ability that would know that is the cop, right? But there wouldn't have been much reason to check her, iirc. That really only leaves Midori knowing Zima's alignment through being scum, as far as I know.

Best we've got right now, so VOTE: Midorikawa.

Also, it seems kinda odd that Midori tried to bring up random suspicions to me. She said she had none, but then went and posted that against someone it was extremely easy to make a case against without even trying? I mean, yes, she did give things against Velo, but the abrupt one against Fynx bothers me a little. i think the only other one was on Velo but i just woke up so dfghjkl; i apologize if so ><;

Wow, thanks Takua. So much for being old friends...

I was so curious as to what my role could do in the future, that I completely ignored the present. I hope you guys pull this off.

May the wind be ever-under your wings!

@Neon Borealis is there any way for me to sub out? Apparently I'm a lot busier than I thought I would be when I signed up to play. Life. u.u

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

@FinalArcadia; 10-11 at night is the time where I walk my dog at some point, and these past few days its been 8-16 degrees which is freezing and my hands get cold from walking her. Not to mention my house gets very cold even with heat on. And my internet is crappy and constantly cuts out or moves slow, so sorry if I didn't want to deal with the cold and my internet at the same time. Honestly if you're going to vote for me then please have a real reason. If you're voting me for a moment of laziness not helping the town then how about going after someone that hasn't even tried to scum hunt which is a lot of the players. And just for you I'm sitting freezing in a hallway right now just to make sure my internet doesn't cut out when I post this.

Though part of your claims against Paperhorse is that she didn't post here but was on Skype? Your excuse here about the cold doesn't sound a whole lot different, especially when you were indeed online here but neglected to post your reasons for suspicion on Gliscorman then.

I did have reasons. You showed a lack of regard for town and the key scum-hunting time (the day phase) by not answering Gliscorman, saying to wait when there was only 30 minutes until the update. And then there is that you did seem to know that Zima was town, yet held a vote on her until being questioned about it, switching to Gliscorman. If you really felt he was more suspicious, why would you not have voted him in the first place over Zima?

And you said you had no suspicions, and have only provided alternative suspects after they were given by others. Honestly, you've tried giving reasons to vote others, but not why we shouldn't vote you. Do we have any reason to have a town-read on you? If so, please explain, because I'm not seeing it, especially not now.

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Why did you choose not to vote? Also some FT contains hints. Brushing it off won't help the town at all. We should consider all possibilities.

What did you think of Orion's vote/unvote at the time?

I didn't think much of it tbh. He was just being too polite.

Originally Posted by Paperhorse

Originally Posted by Buoy

@Paperhorse; Why do you care?

I just wanted to know other people's reasons for not voting, and to stir up activity. This is a big game, and having too many inactive people can kill it. Also, since it's a big game, people can slip under the radar easily.

Now that I answered your question, will you answer mine?

You didn't say anything first day either yet started calling out inactives. Why didn't you say anything about the activity already in thread?

Like I said before, I wanted to know other player's reasons for being silent like I was.

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Originally Posted by Paperhorse

Originally Posted by Master Mew

@Paperhorse Hi, how are you?

You've been uncharacteristically quiet, it's Day 3 and you've only posted twice since the game began. Who do you think we should lynch today?

Hi, I'm good, thanks for asking. I'm not 100% sure who we should lynch today as of yet. FinalArcadia brings up good points about Zima, (especially since I've had the same thoughts) but I'm a bit worried she's been silenced. Since we know there is a silencer in the game, and she hasn't said anything.

And no one said it's not a possibility. Now was there anyone else suspicious to you?

Yes. I was suspicious of you, Midorikawa. Especially after this post on night 2.

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Well now we know there's a silencer, though I don't get why they silenced Orion when he had suspicion on him.

Something about that post struck me as odd. I just get the feeling that you knew you could easily pull off a mislynch of him. If he didn't defend himself, it's a lot easier to pull off a mislynch.

Also, I was suspicious of both you and Zima, as well. I figured one of you must be mafia. So when she flipped town, I was convinced you are mafia.

And I'm pretty sure I'm right. Hence my vote on you.

Also, I was suspicious of HumanDawn, but now that he outed himself as Vigilante, I'm leaning towards town on him.

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

And again you could have given thoughts about the active players

I wanted to see what Zima's alignment was before I threw suspicion on you.

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Because you obviously had time to talk on skype but apparently none to scum hunt

That's rather unfair. I have other interests besides this mafia game.

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Originally Posted by Buoy

hello confirm or something
@Paperhorse; i'm coming to get u

Why would Buoy say that? I'm curious.

I have no idea. Ask him.

The word "save" can imply a great many of things.

A) It could mean saving Zima from being wrongfully lynched, implying she knew her alignment.
B) It could mean Midori was trying to see what Master Mew would say to that.
C) It could mean that she meant 'save' in a way of 'why didn't you help her out more if you thought she was town and could be saved'?

I don't think we should all go after her because of a misuse of word choice, if that's what happened.
@Midorikawa; Maybe a claim can help?

@Akuraito; I never casted any suspicion on you. My wall post was about Velo and Paperhorse. Why so jumpy?

EDIT @FinalArcadia; The difference is that I've been active in this game while Paperhorse hasn't. Thirty minutes isn't enough time for my slow internet to go through the thread and present my evidence, and that's assuming all those who had votes on Zima were even on. Notably you were the one to lead the lynch on her yet you seem to be getting off nice and clean by adding ridiculous evidence to already ridiculous evidence.

Midorikawa, all you've been doing is throwing suspicion on many others; I haven't really seen a good defense from you. My vote is staying.