Thread: Betrayal Knows My Name Mafia - End Game (Mafia/Opasts Won) - 10/1/12

@Dark Blueberry; Greece was the first to make the votes focus on Tris79 during Day 1, and Atomic and Human followed.

All of this would be, of course, guesswork, DQ (there's Drumbeats so I'm not using DB when referring to you XD). However, countering these arguments just because 'innocents have been lynched for the reasons' does not work. Yes, they can be town, but they can be also mafia. Mafia players have been caught based on their votes. However mafia can lie, votes are something they'd NEED to be careful of. What are you going to rely on for lynches then if not for these guesswork? Only cop checks? Role checks? Lie detects? Even they are prone to being wrong.

If there is a player that have been suspicious enough for a lynch, then I'd say lynch them. Do you think I'm suspicious? Have my actions and words made me seem suspicious and have I failed in providing a persuasive defense? Then fine, go ahead, I should be lynched. Information comes from lynches, and the activity that you want also comes from actual events happening. Hardly town gains from No Lynch except in the situation called 'MYLO' (such as when town has two more players against mafia in number), when it'd actually help narrow down suspects after mafia kills a target during the upcoming Night.

Anyways, again, on Greece, I'm more on the fence now than suspecting her seeing what happened during Night 2 and Day 3.

Originally Posted by Buoy

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Thought so. Alright then FoS: Buoy

@Buoy; You go and say players are mafia without stating a reason and then you say you can't post your reason yet you're obviously not silenced and role-blocking wouldn't do that. It seems more to me that you're mafia aiming at townies with suspicion on them

ya that's totally what i'm doing

Why won't you tell us your reasons? You're not silenced since you're posting

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Originally Posted by Buoy

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Thought so. Alright then FoS: Buoy

@Buoy; You go and say players are mafia without stating a reason and then you say you can't post your reason yet you're obviously not silenced and role-blocking wouldn't do that. It seems more to me that you're mafia aiming at townies with suspicion on them

ya that's totally what i'm doing

Why won't you tell us your reasons? You're not silenced since you're posting

because reasons

Originally Posted by Buoy

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Originally Posted by Buoy

Originally Posted by Midorikawa

Thought so. Alright then FoS: Buoy

@Buoy; You go and say players are mafia without stating a reason and then you say you can't post your reason yet you're obviously not silenced and role-blocking wouldn't do that. It seems more to me that you're mafia aiming at townies with suspicion on them

ya that's totally what i'm doing

Why won't you tell us your reasons? You're not silenced since you're posting

because reasons

At first Blueberry was suspicious to me but since you're calling her mafia without stating why I'm starting to think she's innocent. In other mafias with her she has a bad habit of making scummy comments as a townie

@Synthesis;

I'd like to see some activity please.

Honestly, I'm not really getting a mafia read on Buoy. If anything, I interpret his actions as trying to get Dark Blueberry or Belarus. to slip-up, since I'm assuming he is suspicious of them. Or it could all just be him just trying to get a reaction.

While I'm also not really reading mafia on Belarus., I do have some suspicions of Dark Blueberry.

Originally Posted by Mintaka

@Dark Blueberry; Greece was the first to make the votes focus on Tris79 during Day 1, and Atomic and Human followed.

All of this would be, of course, guesswork, DQ (there's Drumbeats so I'm not using DB when referring to you XD). However, countering these arguments just because 'innocents have been lynched for the reasons' does not work. Yes, they can be town, but they can be also mafia. Mafia players have been caught based on their votes. However mafia can lie, votes are something they'd NEED to be careful of. What are you going to rely on for lynches then if not for these guesswork? Only cop checks? Role checks? Lie detects? Even they are prone to being wrong.

If there is a player that have been suspicious enough for a lynch, then I'd say lynch them. Do you think I'm suspicious? Have my actions and words made me seem suspicious and have I failed in providing a persuasive defense? Then fine, go ahead, I should be lynched. Information comes from lynches, and the activity that you want also comes from actual events happening. Hardly town gains from No Lynch except in the situation called 'MYLO' (such as when town has two more players against mafia in number), when it'd actually help narrow down suspects after mafia kills a target during the upcoming Night.

Anyways, again, on Greece, I'm more on the fence now than suspecting her seeing what happened during Night 2 and Day 3.

Alright. You convinced me. However... you must seek what lies within before lynching them. While this may be just a game, we all want to win, right? Yes, town doesn't gain from No Lynch, but they don't exactly gain from lynching another townie - and if they turn out to be someone with a vital role - be it doctor, cop, or bomb - then it would pretty much make things tough.

Then again... we can't just sit around and do nothing. Well, this thread had been pretty active over the last few days. And I'm not really going to go after someone who started a vote on Tris79 because of obvious reasons I had seen throughout pretty much every mafia game.

@Synthesis

He's been on yesterday and got mentioned. I'm wondering why he won't respond - maybe he can't speak in thread? Could that be possible?

Originally Posted by Elysion

He's been on yesterday and got mentioned. I'm wondering why he won't respond - maybe he can't speak in thread? Could that be possible?

If he couldn't speak in thread then he wouldn't get an inactivity warning. He's not PMing or posting in QTs, just inactive with the mafia

Oh...he got one? Oh alright. Well, that's weird.

Originally Posted by Elysion

Oh...he got one? Oh alright. Well, that's weird.

HCL just posted it

Oh right. I can't believe I totally missed that. Wow.

Well, here now. I haven't even checked this thread since confirming.

Originally Posted by Synthesis

Well, here now. I haven't even checked this thread since confirming.

wow talk about INACTIVE

WHUT. whuthaveubeendoingimeanuwereonystrday!?

My chatspeak has been activated. But seriously, you haven't bothered checking this thread since confirming? Wow.