There were two more mafia members? Wow, I didn't think there would be that many =O
Sorry I couldn't be on to help at the end. I should have done more.
It was a good game, if anything, I'd say the town was at a disadvantage and we did well with what we had.
Independents and Mafia made up roughly one third of the game. Leaving little wiggle room. Then we had a town role that won when they died, a mafia with a lynch immunity, a mafia with a double vote that would cause problems in end game, and a cop that didn't get definitive answers (mixed with a miller).
Yeah, those are some tough odds to beat =P. I think we did well, although everyone should be more active.