Sorry Envoy... stole your idea :P
These are pretty interesting bird pokemon both are offensive pokemon that rarely use special moves they both primarily rely on their speed to get ahead & destroy their opponents quickly.
Pigeot is a much better defender than attacker thought it does'nt have any defensive moves. It is the slower weaker of the two pokemon but it has slightly better defence & much better special defence.It also has a mediocre movepool apart from learning featherdance & Mirror Move.
Staraptor is the faster stronger of the two but it's lowish defences compared to pigeot. It has a major attack boost compared to pigeot & it has the slight speed boost. It has a resonable movepool with access to Close Combat, Brave Bird & Endeavor.
They both have access to similar TM's & basically the same tutoring moves apart from uproar(pigeot) & Endeavor (staraptor)
Who has better design?
Who would win in a fight?
Who would help you achieve your pokemon dream?
I think Staraptor would poop all over pigeot
See all these threads for similar things all curtosy of Envoy!
Venusaur vs Torterra
Meganium vs Sceptile
Charizard vs Typhlosion
Blaziken vs Infernape
Blastoise vs Swampert
Dragonite vs Salamence
Also look out for this new thread im making
Noctowl vs Swellow vs Fearow