Thread: Pidove or Starly...

Mamepato. It's a pigeon! :D

I kinda prefer Starly. I've always liked it.

Mamepato is pretty cool too, but Wargle beat it out on my favorite Isshu bird...

Mamepato looks more like an actual pidgeon while Starly is cuter. It's a tie.

Never liked starly evolutions that much.
So its Mamepato for now.

Starly.

Its evolutions are better.

I like Mamepato because it's cuter. If there's one thing, I estimate that Mamepato will have high HP and good defences.

At this point, based on everybody's posts up to now (including mine), Mamepato won 15 people compared to 5 who chose Starly. Only one declares it a tie.

Starly it's one of my favourite pokemon and was my first shiny

Mamepato is original(ish), starly is just a cheap pidgey rip-off.

i pick starly
i like its design better personally
and it evolved form saved my life in platinum

Pidove has really grown on me.

I'm not a big fan of the Starly line but the Pidove line sucks hard. They have no good moves and horrible coverage and iffy stats. Staraptor on the other hand was designed to be good at battling and it suceeds at that to large extent.

Starly, because its final evo learns Close Combat!

I like the Pidove line too, design-wise Its movepool, though...Eh.

Pidove all the way! I really like the little guy, I even use an Unfezant on my Black file. Maybe it's because I always root for the underdog.

Mamepato sucks almost as much as purrloiin. Starly all the way.

Pidove, I just love its cry.