Thread: Ash vs. Game!Red

Someone's gotta' do it.

VS.

Do you prefer the favourite anime hero? Or the cool and collected protagonist? Why?

It's the same person basically0_0
Anyway i picked Red

I love them both equally, but in a battle Red would win sadly.

I'm going with Ash (he has a lot of strong Pokemon with him and I like how he battles, as well as his personality in the anime).

I love Ash too much to say Red. :) Even though Red has 3 votes more ô_ô

Red hands down.

I voted for Ash out of pity.

And there are like, four different Reds in canon, and only PokeSpec!Red is that awesome. Game!Red is a tie. All of the other ones...

PokeSpe. Red wins this one. His personality is similar to Ash's, yet he has a cooler team.
Also, Red's Pikachu + Substitute =

Red is the most powerful NPC in the games. He would beat Ash to a pulp. Plus he's just more awesome.

Please, Ash is just some brat pretending to be Red. That's how he comes off to me anyway.

I like Ash more. I'm just more familiar with his character.

And honestly, Red's design has never been my favorite.

Red in both the game and from Pokemon Special. Red actually became Pokemon champion and for all intents and purposes the strongest trainer.

Plus the fact that Red actually ages, gets taller and becomes more mature (in the manga).

Are you kidding Red is more badass. (That's meant to be one sentence.)

PokeSpe Red... Much more of a bishounen, and less of a chaste hero.
Do want.

Red as in both Pokemon Special and game-wise, Seriously, Kanto-Johto Champion anyone?

While Satoshi keeps on resetting himself everytime he goes on another region, at least Red has a more realistic team after all this time. ^3^