None of them were going because of the exciting danger. They tagged along because they wanted to be there for Yuma and help rescue Rei. So, I don't quite see where you're getting that they're all excited for such a dangerous mission, although none of them are smart enough to really realize how dangerous it is either.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
Except that there's been nothing in the show to indicate that the writers have any interest in making the Numbers Club members be capable of protecting themselves. That would require them to be more active, which they aren't interested in doing so when all of them are just cheerleaders for Yuma and nothing more. They've had nearly a hundred episodes to make these useless characters more useful and they haven't done so. I don't see any reason to think that they could change their minds about what to do with them anytime soon.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
I realize that it wasn't important, so it didn't get focus. The problem I have with it is that there wasn't much of an indication that any of them were that all that close with Rei. The fact that all they knew about him was an act is an issue when they didn't know the real Rei and that it was most likely simply a means to get close to Yuma, so that makes their so-called friendship with Rei just as artificial as Yuma's relationship with him is. They wouldn't have cared about Rei being a Barian Guardian had they known about that most likely because they would have bought it without really questioning it like Yuma did. I'm not sure if they would have considered him a hero, but they probably would have been impressed with him being an undercover agent in a sense. Still, Rei barely talked to any of them on-screen and I don't really put much of any stock into saying what could have happened off-screen. I could just make up anything and say that it happened off-screen, but without something solid enough on-screen to back it up, it doesn't mean anything. There certainly wasn't any connection between Rei and the Numbers Club to make their desire to help find him believable. Laughing together over something doesn't make them look like decent friends in my book.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
While Bruno primarily had one-on-one interactions with Yusei, I thought that he worked into the group dynamics of the team well before cheering when they won the WRPG. Their friendship wasn't the focus and they didn't have an instant click with Bruno like he did with Yusei, but there was enough there for me where I could find them being sad over Bruno's death believable. That was more believable than the Numbers Club wanting to go save Rei when I think he only talked to Kotori and Tetsuo out of the whole group. Zexal really lacks interesting protagonists and a strong group dynamic, but I think that the latter is because of how nearly everyone in the main cast is there just to be Yuma's cheerleaders and have nothing else going on to make them more engaging characters. The dull characterization doesn't help either. While I'm not sure if I'd consider GX to be first in that regard, I agree that it is better than Zexal in those areas since most of the characters had more fleshed out personalities and while they all were connected through Judai, their entire worlds didn't revolve around him either.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
I'm not sure if disrespectful is necessarily the right word for that situation, especially when it wouldn't be just blabbing it out to a friend as you put it. It's more like one of those morally gray situations where you learn a secret that could be hurtful to them or to others and you're unsure about if you should tell someone about it. While Yuma has chosen to keep it with only one moment where he questioned Rei to let Astral in on the secret, so it lacks the moral dilemma that I described in that vague example most likely because Yuma lacks the emotional maturity that these short of situations tend to require, that sounds more similar to the situation with Rei's secret. It wouldn't be disrespectful for Yuma to tell Astral because keeping Astral in the dark is potentially putting him in danger. Yuma doesn't know how keeping these Barian cards are going to affect Astral, especially when combining them with Hope, and keeping a big secret like that from him isn't going to help their relationship either. Rei claims that knowing that he's a Barian Guardian would put Astral's life in danger, but his life is already in danger whenever Yuma faces a Barian villain or someone with the Rank Up spell card and Rei never explained why that's the case. There's no reason why I should take what he said at face value. Yuma did because he blindly trusts his friends and he's too stupid to realize all of the suspicious nature from Rei as a result. There's really nothing about his relationship to Rei that makes me think that they're close enough to the point where Yuma would want to choose keeping Rei's secret from Astral for no good reason over keeping Astral in the loop out of concern for his safety when using these Barian cards.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
While we don't know that he's manipulating Yuma for sure, there's far too much suspicious hints and behavior from him to make me think he was being honest with Yuma about the whole Barian Guardian stuff. Besides that, weren't you saying before that the constant hints were making the twists less interesting?
Rei didn't really treat Yuma like they were close. Whenever he was talking in his more serious voice, it was mainly to discuss the situation with the other Barians and investigate. Yes, Rei would be the superior in that area, but there weren't any moments while they were talking one-on-one like that that made me believe that he did see Yuma as an equal and that he wasn't just using him. Though, perhaps it helps that I continued to see him as suspicious the moment he told Yuma not to tell Astral anything. There's really nothing worth putting my emotional investment in their relationship. It's built on lies, Rei most likely continued to lie after calling himself a Barian Guardian, never really showed any genuine connection with Yuma and while Yuma does care about Rei, the fact that it's still surrounded by lies and is completely one-sided shows that there's really nothing there. I'm just suppose to feel invested in it despite the lack of a genuine connection between the two of them and the show is just acting like they were so close when there was just nothing there at all in my opinion. That doesn't work and their relationship is just completely artificial and not worth a penny to get invested in. Out of the cases of instant friendship with a character that has some involvement with the villain later on, Judai and Johan were handled the best in terms of their genuine connection, but I still find more reasons to care about Yusei and Bruno than Yuma and Rei. While it wasn't perfect by any means, Yusei and Bruno did feel like good friends by the time Yusei had to duel him and I could feel a bit sad over Bruno's death. It might help that Bruno's connection to Zone wasn't hinted like crazy compared to Rei's connection with the Barian villains.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
It can help, but it doesn't necessarily make the friendships more genuine or more interesting. The Numbers Club's fights certainly haven't done that, especially when most of their arguments have been over Yuma or something stupid like who gets to be the female mascot of the club, as if that meant anything. I'd describe the friendship among Yuma and the Numbers Club as generic more than anything else mainly because none of the characters are interesting or have much of anything else going on in their lives beyond cheering for Yuma.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
Given his behavior and what Vector's Barian form looks like, I don't see how it's just a possibility and not practically confirmed.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
Anyway, to change the discussion a bit, I've started watching some episodes from the original Yu-Gi-Oh!(not the Toei series) to try to make me watch it again, but I'm failing in getting interested in it. With 5D's I was hooked with the interesting plot and characters, and while it had its boring moments I would still be in the mood of continuing to watch it. Maybe it's just the nostalgia from it being the first and because I was younger, but now I just don't really care for it.
Attacking them back home wouldn't really be a problem for them as they could just use more Barian Sphere Cubes to attack Yuma directly. Even with the group of monsters being weak, I doubt that they would have the Numbers Club be able to handle it or that they would make them more active. If they were interested in doing something like with them, they wouldn't be just Yuma's cheerleaders.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
They were talking about having lunch at that point, so I don't know if they were going there for fun as well. That still just make them look incredibly stupid to me.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
Both personalities he had looked like acts, or at least the Barian Guardian self is highly suspicious. Actions speak louder than words. Simply saying that they were friends really doesn't do enough to me to justify that they got close off-screen, especially when he primarily interacted with Yuma and just hung out with the others because they're almost always with Yuma. There isn't really any connection and even if there was, it was fake due to how Rei was clearly putting on an act with them. So, similar to his relationship with Yuma, there's nothing there with Rei and the Numbers Club to show any genuine connection. Laughing over something doesn't really help when it's all an act.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
I've been watching 5Ds over the past couple of months and I do think that he did click with the group. There weren't a lot of one-on-one interactions besides with Yusei and Bruno, but I thought that he clicked with the group as a whole to make it look like they were friends. Not necessarily super close friends, but decent enough to where they did seem to click with him and being sad over Bruno's death once Yusei told them about it seemed believable. Though, Bruno only knew that he had to help Yusei and he didn't have any memories of what else he was suppose to do until right before dueling Yusei, so he didn't suffer from being an obvious villain like Rei has. Comparing Team 5D's interactions with Bruno and the Numbers Club with Rei might not be the best comparison due to how the Numbers Club members aren't important. While some characters in Team 5D's spent more time on the sidelines than I would have preferred, they were still more important to the plot than any of the Numbers Club members.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
While it isn't confirmed, I think that should have come up because of how much Barian powers can hurt Astral, but it didn't. On the other side of the coin, I don't see any reason why he had to keep Rei's secret from Astral other than he blindly trusts his friends and to create more tension between him and Astral. Rei didn't really provide a reasonable explanation as to why Astral's life would be in danger if he did learn about being a Barian Guardian and the only reason Yuma didn't question it further is because he's an idiot. If I was in his situation, I would see how manipulating Hope with Barian cards and just having Barian cards around could potential cause damage to Astral and I would question Rei more about it. It's not like Rei's story about being a Barian Guardian is completely believable. Astral just felt uneasy about using Barian cards, not really questioning the use of them, but I think that Rei telling Yuma to keep his secret started what could have been a morally gray situation had Yuma the emotional maturity to recognize it and Rei's reason for keeping Astral in the dark was believable.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
True. Though, I can't really see Rei being anything other than a villain for multiple reasons.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
Whose to say that jumping in front of Yuma wasn't part of the plan? Giving the support cards to Yuma before dueling Vector, showing up just before he needed one of the support cards and protecting Yuma seemed way too planned out, along with pretty much everything else in that duel, to write off as Rei being a genuine friend at this point. They weren't close because of how Rei was lying to Yuma for a good chuck of this season, it is highly likely that he's lying to him about being a Barian Guardian and nothing he's said or done to Yuma since revealing himself as a Barian Guardian has made me think that he genuinely likes him, but believing that he's still lying probably helps in that regard. I'm not sure if it's really an incredible job fooling an idiot like Yuma. At this point, I question how anyone could think that Rei is genuinely Yuma's friend, but I haven't taken anything he's said at face value either.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
I actually couldn't tell that until right before their duel because of how Bruno had done nothing but helping Yusei with finding a way to Accel Synchro. He was still suspicious, but it wasn't nearly as obvious as they're making it out to be with Rei. Even at the end, he still chose to help Yusei by showing him another advance form of Synchro summoning to help defeat Zone, so unlike Rei, Bruno wasn't a villain himself, but just connected to one. I know that it hasn't been confirmed yet with Rei, but there's no reason for me to believe that he is actually Yuma's friend. Though, perhaps comparing Rei with Burno isn't quite accurate when they both served different roles in their respective series, but in terms of throwing hints, they were more subtle about it with Bruno, which made the twists much more effective when they didn't broadcast them for twenty episodes. I thought that Rei was someone from the Astral World at first too, mainly with the season preview mentioning that beings from the Astral World would appear too, but I don't think that he's really trying to help Yuma. Why would he want to keep Astral in the dark about being a Barian Guardian? How would Astral's life be in more danger with that information? With those important questions in mind, why on Earth should I take anything he has said at face value? If Rei isn't helping the Barians in some form or another, then I'll find a hat to eat. It is a different situation than it was with Bruno, especially when Bruno didn't really know much about his connection to Zone until all of his memories returned, but I'm not sure if it's necessarily more interesting when it's painfully obvious that Rei is a villain, while at least it was more of a surprise with Bruno, he isn't really an interesting character and there's nothing genuine with his relationship with Yuma. Burno faded into the background at time, but at least there was something in his relationship with Yusei to make their friendship feel genuine and believable.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
It was more stupid to me than anything else. There aren't really any moments where their friendship is anything more than generic and the Numbers Club having such bland personalities really doesn't help.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
It practically is in my opinion, but it should come up in the next episode regardless.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
I haven't been able to find any good subs for DM. I've seen a few episodes in the original version and I could still get into it. It wasn't perfect, but I'd take DM over Zexal any day of the week. At least DM had good characters, great duels, even though some of them did drag on, and an engaging storyline.Originally Posted by HumanDawn
Last edited by Hidden Mew; 22nd March 2013 at 08:56 PM.
I'm a bad reviewer, since once I get obsessed with a show I can't bring myself ta find any flaws in it, but here are just some quick thoughts on the mind-blowing episode that is episode 96.Excuse the badness of this review- I haven't had my coffee yet XD .
YAY! There is a ZEXAL thread!
Well, I am BlueWartortle, great ZEXAL fan, yet still at the catch-up. Yet, I have "studied" everything about Barian worlds and such.
After all , Yuma & the gang are heading to various Barran ruin to find some special number.
In that case , Yuma need some people who are good at researching .
-Kotori is good with computer , She can help in the running various program.
-Casswell good at study so he might help in researching the ruin.
-Filp is good at cunning so he might be useful . Plus he's short so he can go in place that other can't go in the ruin.
Plus , Kaite & Shark can use some socializing .
Since they are in Barrian World , Kite & Shark has to interact with Yuma's other friend .
In the manga , Cathy help Yuma by using her wealth !
Is The Yugioh Zexal Manga better Or Anime better ?
No, they don't have to interact with Yuma's circle of friends. I doubt that there will be anything forcing them to interact more with the Numbers Club, especially when Kaito barely cares for anyone who isn't Haruto as it is. They'll probably just primarily interact with each other, Yuma, Astral and possibly Rio depending on what role she plays in this conflict, but they don't have to interact with the other characters. The Numbers Club members are just going to be cheerleaders and possible hostage bait for Yuma.Originally Posted by Hurricane Kishore
I haven't ready any of the manga, so I can't answer that. I might give it a read at some point, but some of the stuff I've heard about it makes me want to avoid it. The first few chapters play out like the anime until they finish the duel against Kaito, which was a terrible decision in my opinion when that just made the first few chapters seem like a waste if they're so similar to the anime, and then when it gets into its own storyline, it can have some really weird moments like what I heard about Black Corn. I wish that they had saved off on doing a Zexal manga until after the show had been running for awhile like they did with the GX and 5D's manga. Creating a different version of Zexal right from the start would have been better choice just to attract more people to see a different take on the same characters and concept, although I don't think that the characters are too different from their anime versions from what I've heard about the manga at least. Plus, it would have given the GX manga more time to wrap up its storyline, instead of rushing through the conclusion and then having a sudden epilogue appear. It still disappoints me that the GX manga had a rushed conclusion most likely because of a third monthly Yu-Gi-Oh! manga started up. At least the 5D's manga seems to be getting really good, but not nearly as impressive as the GX manga was for me.Originally Posted by Hurricane Kishore
I like how after months of waiting Zexel is getting good. Just got around to seeing the new ep on my DVR where we find out about Yuma's dad. I swear the series takes ages to get could. For me I found it got into a plot around the tournament start
This week's episode was okay. I think that the problems of having three duels going on at once is really starting to show. Misael used his Chaos Number card, but we didn't see any of it because of the primary focus on Yuma vs. Vector. Shark vs. Durbe isn't really going much better when they'll usually show just one turn for both of them before going back to Yuma. I guess that they didn't want Shark and Kaito to not do anything when they're some of the few characters that can actually do something to advance the plot, but since there is much more focus on Yuma vs. Vector, I think that they should have saved the other matches for their own episodes. It certainly would have made more sense for Misael to use his Chaos Number for when his match against Kaito is the primary focus, but I did like the design of his new monster at least.
I still think that Numbers Club members are useless. Even after avoiding that black hole, I don't think that means that they're capable to handling the ship mainly because if Orbtial hadn't gotten back into the Ship to help them, they would be dead. I also think that they should have been more upset at Yuma than I think that they were. Because of Yuma being such a naive idiot, he allowed for his friends, who aren't even involved in this conflict, to be put in life-threatening danger. If he had actually thought about what he was doing and the long term consequences of his actions, he could have avoided this. Granted, yelling at him while he was facing Vector probably wouldn't have helped, but honesty, he deserved it far more than them cheering him on some more. It certainly would have made more sense. Despite that and how I still dislike the Numbers Club members in general, I'll give Kotori credit for taking charge. I still don't like her, but like with going in a crumbling building to save Yuma after his duel with Tron, I give her credit for having guts.
Vector wasn't as entertaining as he was in the last episode, but he still did a great job with manipulating Astral. Astral should have doubts over Yuma because of how he chose Rei over him and not really for a convincing reason in my opinion. I was disappointed with how Dark Zexal looked like though. I thought it would be a new design entirely, instead of just making the original version darker with black hair in place of the gold. That was a bit disappointing. Dark Astral during the preview looked incredibly creepy though.