[
I don't know if his deck really needed balance. I thought it was fun. I think the whole adding a fear of bugs was more 4kids trying to create more tension in that duel rather than trying to make Yusei afraid. There was that whole being afraid to duel again after dueling Kiryu that was actually a flaw and showed him struggling to overcome it. As for his death, I thought it was to show his connection to his father, which would come up again in the later arcs, but it was probably just there to add a bit more tension during Jack's duel against Carly. It really didn't bother me that much.

Originally Posted by
Human I liked the plot of the Dark Signer arc as well. Its lack of realism just really bugged me. Now I know that this is fiction, and so exaggerated plots are inevitable to see, but the arc was too exaggerated and flawed for me to make me feel compelled or really care at what the characters were facing through. Carly's writing was gorgeous and top-notch, though. She felt really relate able despite her overly exaggerated plot with Jack about being the King and Queen of future Hell. It was a shame that she didn't show up much after the arc, but since her character was over with it didn't bother me. Jack talking to her of about what happened would have been really nice.
A lack of realism in a Yu-Gi-Oh! series doesn't really upset me and I really don't go into any series expecting that at this point. The first arc had more of a sense of realism, but there were hints of something bigger coming with Godwin gathering the Signers and that vision near the end of Yusei's duel against Jack. I didn't think that the plot was too exaggerated, especially Carly's subplot with Jack. That was handled extremely well in my opinion. Her character was done after that arc, but it was still kind of a shame that she was reduced to mainly comedy relief after all she went through. I still would have loved to see Jack and Carly interacting more and talking about what happened though.

Originally Posted by
Human I found Fuya and Cat-chan's plots to be more compelling and entertaining due to their realism, despite having fewer episodes. I really can't see how Cat-chan's growth is arguable. She was an extremely shy girl who wanted attention, friends and Yuma to care about her. After Yuma opened her eyes, she started to hang around with him and be social with people through duelling. That made for an interesting and compelling plot. She showed her development and expressed it after her duel with Dog-chan. She made me care for her, she made me happy to see her grow, learn, not keep things and lessons from others so they could learn and grow as well. She felt real despite her ability to be able to talk to and understand cats. Being comic relief now doesn't really bother me since her plot has been over with like Carly's. With it, she brings a smile to my face, and so, I can't ask for anything more from her.
Fuya was engaging and likable, but I don't feel much of anything for Cathy. Considering how little focus she gets and the fact I kept forgetting she was even in the cast during the WDC arc, I don't know if I can say she had a plot per say. Honestly, I don't know if I'd consider her real. Even with her strange cat powers, which also have yet to be explained by the way, she just feels like the typical shy girl of the group. She's not as shy now, but she still comes off like that to me. I liked her more than Kotori for awhile, but that doesn't say much and she was still pretty bland. I usually don't like characters being reduced to comical relief, especially if what they're doing isn't funny and just comes off as annoying. It's great that you like her so much, but she's just bland and her duel with Dog-chan made me think of how dumb it was rather than any growth she had.

Originally Posted by
Human Aki's plot never really interested me. She had no personality to begin with(making her a female Yusei in my eyes, only worse), her plot was too exaggerated for me to make me care or be invested in her and was dragged on too much. Dragged plots(depending on how they're set up and how they progress) generally bore and bother me. I do agree on how it was still interesting to see a female main lead so drastically different in demeanour and personality. As I've said earlier in this thread, I like how some of the female characters on this show are shown to be very independent so seeing Aki being strong half of the time was nice to see. I honestly think that she's an interesting character, but she's just not one that interests me.
Aki was not a female Yusei. They were both distant and quite at the start, but Aki had more clear flaws and emotional baggage from the start. She was fine letting Divine think for her, didn't realize that she enjoyed hurting people with her powers and had emotional scars from growing up with her psychic powers. That does not sound like a female Yusei, especially when she didn't value friends like he did. I don't know if I'd considered her plot exaggerated, but I was interested in her backstory and I did feel more sympathetic towards her near the end of her duel with Yusei.

Originally Posted by
Human I already knew that you were the type of girl that wouldn't sink to such a low level. I remember the days of Yu-Gi-Oh! 5Ds, where I would read comments of girls on the internet that would whine and complain if other characters who weren't named Yusei appeared on-screen. It's fine to be displeased that your favourite characters aren't getting as much screen time as you want them to get, but insulting others(not kidding around, but actual personal attacks) who dare wish to like other characters more is a huge no. The designs of the characters are to help express and make the audience understand the personality of the characters more. The problem with 5Ds being too dark(especially in the Dark Signer arc) was because, unlike DM, GX and Zexal, it couldn't let the audience catch a break. There was always something thrown at you, always some new revelation, something new to think of and some tension filled duel thrown in. If the audience was allowed to catch a break with the pacing, I'd say more people would have liked it.
I just wanted to clarify that I don't do something like that. I didn't really see a lot of comments like that with 5D's. There were Yusei fans, of course, but the ones I've see weren't like that either. I still don't think that the 5D's or the Dark Signer arc were too dark compared to other arcs in DM and GX. There wasn't a chance for a break since a person did need to see at least the first sixty-four episodes to understand the events of the arc. I honestly didn't think that was a huge problem. Most people I've seen talk about 5D's praise the first two arcs, although they don't call them perfect by any means. The characters were interesting, at least I think they were, the storyline was engaging, the pacing didn't feel too fast, the Riding Duels added some diversity and the plot always advancing helped to keep the storyline fresh and make people continue watching it. A breather during those first two arcs might have been nice, but I don't think it really hurt the series, especially when there were plenty of breathers in the later arcs, for better or for worse.

Originally Posted by
Human I thought that the duels were fun and comical without trying too hard and that the faux seriousness being thrown in some of the episodes was thoroughly more enjoyable. A change of focus is always nice. An utter waste of time? I don't see that because they helped Yuma get more heart pieces, advertise other monsters, be entertaining, and show some compelling and fun one time characters. Seeing Astral almost dying in his Numbers duels never really bothered me since it wasn't happening too frequently. It did help raise the tension in the duels. When Astral died, I felt really sad for Yuma. When he did come back to life, I was glad that a plausible reason was given unlike when Yusei died and got revived. Yuma being selfish? If he's being selfish to you, then it's because he's just a kid. I really liked the episode of when he didn't tell his sister and grandmother about his Parents day because of how busy they were. He actually felt human, relate-able, compelling, interesting and... real. It was sweet, touching, and proof that the family themes in Zexal were superior, more interesting, compelling, relate-able and exciting to see.
Most of Zexal's attempts at humor feel more stupid than funny to me. Even with Yuma getting another heart piece, some duels felt like a waste of time because of how boring they were and how they didn't connect to the plot beyond that small detail. It's not like they couldn't have brought in more plot elements earlier so that his duels wouldn't feel like one could skip them and not lose anything of value. The duels against the kids with the construction deck and Anna especially felt like a waste of time since they didn't even given him a new heart piece. None of the one-shot characters he dueled against where compelling or entertaining to me in the slightly. They were either boring or annoying jokes. I was fine with Astral dying nearly every duel. I was just saying before that they didn't have a problem doing that in the first arc, so I didn't think that they really needed to take a break when the second arc started. Astral being revived was a combination of the powers of the crests and Yuma's father appearing out of nowhere. I don't know how it's that much better than how Yusei was revived. Yuma in that episode was more tolerable, but I don't think I could ever see Yuma as being relatable considering how stupid he is. The family theme in this series is nice, but I don't think I'd praise it that much.

Originally Posted by
Human I don't think that the standing duel in the second episode was to show that they still existed. I'm pretty sure the audience is smart enough to know that just because they made card games be played on motorcycles, it doesn't mean that standing duels have stopped existing. If that was what the writers intended with the duel, I'd say that it's an insult to the intelligence of the audience. The duel was odd. Card games on motorcycles was a new concept, why not flesh it out? For me to think that it had a great start, I'd say I needed to know more of the setting with an extra episode being spent in the Satellite to flesh out the area and its history more. Heck, I don't think that the massive hole that the explosion of Momentum caused even appeared or was mentioned. It was information that was needed to be known.
I just thought that they'd want to show a standing duel anyway, especially when I don't know if any standing duels were shown when they first started to promote the series. I think considering it as an insult to the audience's intelligence is a bit much. I thought that they fleshed out Riding Duels quite a bit during the course of the series. We learned more about the history of Satellite and the explosion of Momentum caused later on in the series. Considering that most people thought Satellite was the result of a massive natural disaster, I don't think that they could explain that in the early episodes anyway.

Originally Posted by
Human The duels were meh. Junk Warrior became like Hope, only it was a less interesting monster. Ushio being the buttmonkey got old the second time he lost. Actually, why didn't he summon that 3000 Defence points monster that was used by Security in the double duel against Crow and Yusei in his second duel as Yusei tried to flee from the Satellite? It was easy to summon too. He only needed to discard the 2000 Defence points version to special summon the 3000 Defence points one. He got a better deck to take Yusei down. Yusei was being a huge threat, why not give him such a strong card? Ehh. We'll never know.
Junk Warrior was often summoned, but it didn't always win the duel for Yusei like Hope, or Hope Ray, does for Yuma. As for why Ushio didn't get that 3000 Defense Points monster, my guess is that they didn't think of that card by the time they were setting up for his second duel against Yusei.

Originally Posted by
Human I don't think that they dragged down. The power of Xyz monsters still interested me. Tokunosuke taking hold of Hope and Shark Drake was pretty exciting. It added to Tokunosuke's creepiness and made the duel more enjoyable for me.
Considering the duels against Yuma's teacher and especially Tokunosuke could have been cut down to one episode if they trimmed them down, they definitely felt like they dragged on. Tokunosuke taking both Hope and Revise Dragon wasn't really that exciting, although it was interesting to see what happens to a person with two Number cards, but neither duel felt like they needed to be two episodes long or enjoyable at all.

Originally Posted by
Human Nope. He would have just been revived by his father anyway. That would have actually helped build and lead Yusei to have something compelling happen to him. When he was revived, it wasn't mentioned afterwards or lead to anything when it needed to be. Being revived "just because" doesn't work for me.
I don't know if he would have been revived since unlike the time he was revived by his father, Yusei wasn't surrounded by the spirits of the Underworld who were killed by Zero Reverse. There's no guarantee that his father would have been able to revive him outside of that situation, so I don't think that he could have officially lost that duel.

Originally Posted by
Human It's actually different from Yuma not officially losing to Kaito, even though it bothered me the first time. But unlike Kiryu, Kaito had a plausible reason to stop the duel. Kaito had to go to Haruto to see and take care of. Kiryu's reason was to scare Yusei and make him suffer... which he did in the duel itself. I'm pretty sure that crushing him with his Earthbound God would have done more than enough harm. I didn't find Yusei's reaction be a lot more believable. Martha told him that he was scared of what happen, and that was it. Yuma was scared too, but didn't become desperate because his personality and bonds with his friends and family helped him power up his Kattobingu to do better to help Astral. That made the moment when III used magic(giving a good reason) to remove his Kattobingu the more tragic. I was so used to see Yuma being happy. Seeing him sad was a huge emotional turn off for me because I looked up to him as a character that would try to smile and spread joy to those around him. Yusei, who despite being a calm and collected character, should have been broken with the Earthbound GOD almost crushing him. Instead he woke up, said he was scared at that moment, and went back to his calm and collected self instead of expressing his fears properly like Yuma properly did.
I know that Kiryu wanted to strike fear into Yusei, but he couldn't finish the duel even if he wanted to. If a D-Wheel is broken, a Riding Duel can't continue, even with evil magic involved and that's not the first time something like that happened either. Kaito had Haruto to take care of, but he couldn't have defeated Yuma anyway since Astral would have died and Yuma would have lost his soul, although I don't know if his key would have protected him from that. That's pretty much the same reason. Yusei's reaction to almost dying felt a whole lot more believable than what they were going with Yuma. Nearly losing his souls and losing Astral didn't have nearly as much of an impact on Yuma's character as that kind of situation did with Yusei and didn't make me more engaged with his character. Yusei did express fear. He still looked calm, but he was afraid of dueling again until he had to help Aki and after hearing what Godwin said to them about Dark Signers, he was clearly afraid and shaken up, which led to Jack punching him a couple of times.

Originally Posted by
Human It was believable, but bothersome because I wasn't really looking forward to see him beating his enemies. He was still treated as being right and superior than everybody else by the characters themselves, despite not getting called the King. Now I know that like the other protagonists, they were treated the same way, but unlike Yusei, we weren't constantly reminded that he could stand up more than his friends and was somebody that everybody needed the help of. Him coming back to life was jarring and his sudden ability to go back in time thanks to the Crimson Dragon was even more annoying(which wasn't even mentioned or established to be able in doing so prior to the movie). As things stand, I feel that Yusei was treated to have far more superior powers than the other protagonists.
I don't know if that's really that much different from the other protagonists, especially when even Yuma is treated like the center of the universe for all of his friends practically.

Originally Posted by
Human If a duellist is unable to duel due to some means, then they have lost already. I don't know how a little technicality has the power to surpass magic that should kill somebody. It doesn't even make sense. The magic sealed them. If he couldn't fight then he lost and should have died.
The magic is tied to the life point counter. If that doesn't drop to zero, then they don't die. Being unable to continue the duel doesn't mean that it will drop to zero. Like I mentioned before, it wasn't like Yusei was the first one to be physically unable to continue a duel with evil forces and live.

Originally Posted by
Human There was no need to mess with Yusei's mind. Goodwin's brother did say that it was a welcoming duel, but that's not a justifiable reason. Yusei didn't look like he had the upper hand. He surely had a card in his deck that would have saved him, but he didn't mention or say that he even stood a chance. The purple blast Yusei got from Godwin's Earthbound God did appear to last less and be less stronger, but even so, that makes little sense because when it attacked Jack and Crow, the attack looked stronger and more powerful. Yusei was given a less powerful looking blast to make his ability to still be able to ride and duel "more realistic". In reality, Yusei would have fell down and Goodwin would have won and succeeded in his plan, but due to 5Ds' writing, that didn't happen.
I'll have to rewatch those episodes since I thought Yusei was close to finishing off Godwin's brother and he took Rally in as a way to mess with Yusei's mind and prevent him from winning the duel. I don't know about Yusei not falling after Jack and Crow did, but it really didn't bother me that much.

Originally Posted by
Human I could say that to every TV series in the world. 5Ds flaws just bother me more. I do respect your opinion and thoughts. As you've said countless times here already, it's just a matter of taste. What I really like about the Yu-Gi-Oh! sagas are the different settings, stories and characters that helps to make each saga have a different and unique feel to it. That's why I think the fandom is sort of "torn". It isn't a problem unless it starts some silly war, so differing opinions on each saga isn't the problem some people are making it out to be.
Zexal's flaws bother me a lot more than most of the flaws in 5D's. I respect your opinion as well and I appreciate that. I just don't think Zexal offers that much to the majority of the fandom, especially compared to the other series.
Bookmarks