Thread: My Little Pony: Mafia is Magic - ENDGAME! Town, jda95, and Sputnik win!

Originally Posted by Mijzelffan

Originally Posted by Andrea Luminosity

[MENTION=24706]Mijzelffan[/MENTION];
Would you prefer him to not be active at all or to make posts like "I LIKE FEET"? I mean, not a lot has been said at this point, so it's kind of inevitable to be grasping at straws.

No that's not it. It's like this. People vote without stating a reason. Fahrenheit quotes said people and asks them to provide a reason. Then pichuboy comes in and asks fahrenheit why he is asking people who voted without reason for a reason. Kinda like he's defending the right of people to vote without having a good reason to vote. And that's not helpful.

Ok, you seriously need to actually realise what people are saying, because nowhere in my post did I mention reasons for voting. I was saying that he was probing someone about their vote for Phoenicks when it was Phoenicks himself that voted. Sorry if it just seems like mindless tunnelling if you're not even going to bother to look to see who made the vote.

[EDIT: Ok, I can see where you might've thought I mentioned reasons for voting. When I said "justify", I meant no-one had any justification for being voted, not justification for voting someone. This is the same thing that Mr. F called Phoenicks out on in his "jokey" bit.]

I'm sick and tired of people trying to masquerade jokes as serious playing. It's not that I didn't realise it was a joke, it's that it wasn't clear whether it was or wasn't and so I just assumed it wasn't. Why does assuming people are actually making a serious post and not a jokey one make me scummy?

Originally Posted by Andrea Luminosity

(although thinking on it more, I am surprised that he did not pick up on Mr. Fahrenheit's tongue in cheek or see that Mr. Fahrenheit did in fact ask Sputnik what was up with her vote).

a) Mentioned above.

b) I misread what he said, thinking he was only criticising the reference to a previous game and not the actual vote BECAUSE of that reference. I'm not sure what else I can say other than 'Sorry, I was wrong'. Obviously, the fact that I misinterpreted it makes my previous "why are you only focussing on Phoenick's vote" null.

---

Anyway, all this aside:

[MENTION=28152]Phoenicks[/MENTION], what WAS with the self-vote? Any particular reason?

[MENTION=28152]Phoenicks[/MENTION];
So I'm scum for finding Mr. Fahrenheit's wording humorous. Ok, I guess we aren't allowed to have a sense of humor in mafia games *puts dunce cap on and stands in the corner facing the wall*

As for:

So far we have Phoenicks being mysterious and voting for himself (joke? trying to get the conversation started?)

I was just typing out my thought process, and part of that was speculation as to why you'd vote yourself. I would like to know why you voted for yourself, but 1) you already said you're the fool in response to KidBeano and 2) even if you are not being serious about that, I don't know that you'd give me a straight answer.

[MENTION=34795]KidBeano[/MENTION];
I can't reach across the interwebz and tune into your thought process. I didn't get any indication from your response to Mr. Fahrenheit that you realized he could be joking (no where did you mention that he could be joking). I don't think it's scummy to scrutinize a "joke" vote ("joke" because it might not be a joke at all but instead be using a joke as a front), but I did find it odd that you didn't entertain the other option in your response to him.

Anyway:
[MENTION=53556]Sputnik[/MENTION];
What was the purpose of voting Bomika? You can't seriously think that she's scum because you haven't voted for her for a while. Also, she hadn't even said a single word at that point.

[MENTION=53461]Dark Blueberry[/MENTION];
Would you have voted for Sputnik if she had voted someone other than Bomika?

Originally Posted by Andrea Luminosity

So I'm scum for finding Mr. Fahrenheit's wording humorous. Ok, I guess we aren't allowed to have a sense of humor in mafia games *puts dunce cap on and stands in the corner facing the wall*

Just like Human yelled at me for being supportive in the last game I was in. No humor! No cheerleading! Only Serious Players Allowed. :B

Originally Posted by Andrea Luminosity

@Sputnik;
What was the purpose of voting Bomika? You can't seriously think that she's scum because you haven't voted for her for a while. Also, she hadn't even said a single word at that point.

It was mostly to test her reaction. A townie wouldn't react negatively to a single vote.

There could be a double-voter among who has voted, but I feel as though that is unlikely.

Originally Posted by Andrea Luminosity

@Dark Blueberry;
Would you have voted for Sputnik if she had voted someone other than Bomika?

Nah. I placed a vote one her for that reason. If Sputnik didn't vote, then I wouldn't have voted her.

Don't get me wrong - I have nothing to do with Bomika.

I LIKE FEET

also something about not voting.

[MENTION=51542]Andrea Luminosity[/MENTION];

The other reason was because she was the first one to come to mind, but I do that in just about all large games.

I thought her reaction was out-of-character. No one should react negatively to a single vote that was placed on them, so I saw it as scummy.

---

Oh really, Dark Blueberry? Let's find out for sure.

Unvote: Bomika

Vote: Dark Blueberry

Dark Blueberry: I (Phoenicks, Sputnik)
Sputnik: I (Dark Blueberry)
Mr. Farenheit: I (Laterose)
kidbeano: I (Mijzelffan)

Current vote total from what I've concluded. If this is incorrect, feel free to tell me.