Favorites: Bulbasaur, Tepig & Chimchar all tied on first place. They look awesome and I like the typing and ways they can work.
Semi favs: Squirtle, Oshawott, Treecko
Not ranked exatly ranked: Piplup, Turtwig, Charmander, Cyndaquil, Totodile, Torchic, Mudkip
ROCK BOTTOM: Chikorita & Snivy...The fandom killed Snivy for me...And Chikorita was never useful for me...
And all you Chiorita fanatics: ...Just shuuuuuuuuut uuuup....
I said it doesn't work with MY playstyle...If you like it go ahead and use it but be quiet...
I really like Chikorita.... but it does really suck.
Anyway, my all-time favorite is Bulbasaur. Not even for the nostalgia factor. I just find it a fairly bulky, powerful pokemon.
My least favorite was Totodile, just because, but then Tepig came along. ANOTHER fire/fighting starter? I know Game Freak has resorted to making ice cream cone pokemon, but they can't be THAT out of ideas!
Back, and better than ever! :D
Despite the fact that I feel that Fire type starters are extremely overrated, my favorite starter Pokémon has to be Cyndaquil. I just loved playing through Johto with that Fire Mouse. I like its color scheme too; it makes it look like its part Dark-type. I usually go for water starters, except for Oshawott, which brings me to my least favorite starter. Oshawott just doesn't look appealing to me. It's evolutions are pretty okay, though.
Dinovolvin' since the Late Triassic
Favorite: Cyndaquil and Chimchar. The former because nostalgia and stuff (First starter in a serious run-through. I was very young when I played LeafGreen, so that Charmander doesn't count) and the latter because, well, I like fire and I like monkeys. Strangely, I don't like the Mankey line and the Pansear line, so I think it's the only fire monkey done right.
Least Favorite: Chikorita. Ugh, so unremarkable it hurts. And I just don't like the design.
Favorites - Charmander and Snivy. I'm actually not a big fan of Charmander and Charmeleon, but I love Charizard (I know it's overrated, but I can't help it). I also think Snivy's line is cool-looking.
Least favorites - Tepig and Bulbasaur. Bulbasaur's line has always come across as bland and uninteresting to me, and Tepig's line is just plain ugly in my opinion.
hard choice in fact its too hard to decide unless i split it gen wise (and even then its hard)
gen 1 fave: squirtle first ever mon (fr) and probably my favourite water starter
gen 1 least liked: bulbasaur cant say its bad but never grew on me
gen 2 fave: cyndiquil just so cute
gen 2 least liked:chikorita just...well rubbish
gen 3 fave: tie all of them are either too cute/epic/amazing too not like
gen 3 least liked: none
gen 4 fave: turtwig looks so cute and its evos are so badass
gen 4 least liked: empoleon from the game point never liked it then when i watched the anime that didnt help much
gen 5 fave: snivy the only decent gen 5 starter albiet still not amazing
gen 5 least liked: oshawott and tepig not their fault as such but their evos are just...
Favorite: Totodile. Best reptilian Pokemon design of all time, imo. Plus Feraligatr is a monster. Plus Wooper is my favorite and I must always have one in my G/HG team. Along with Feraligatr it can be ensured all the water HMs are evenly distributed.
Least: Tepig. Tepig itself is cute enough but Emboar is awful looking, and both fire/fighting starters before it are so much better-designed and just as strong, if not stronger. And if you have a worse design than the Chimchar line, you have some very serious problems.
I don't understand all the Mudkip hate. I tend to favor water starters, though. But Swampert's electric immunity? Fuck yo' Dragonite's Thunder; Blizzard, bitch! xD
Honestly I just caught a Torkoal and it, alongside my Swalot, murdered the face right off that Sceptile. Problem solved.
Last edited by metalamor; 12th November 2012 at 06:23 PM.